Was Gaga's Bowie Tribute Messy or Bad?

[eeaarrllaalloo 3,962]

Most people says yes but was it really?

 

[MaryJaneHolland 77,348]

I liked bits of it, like the face projections. But, the whole Intel thing was so hyped and we got.. a moving keyboard

[Doncho 27,241]

No, I LOVED IT!! She was awesome. The only bad thing about it was all the HYPE they tried to create before the performance. So unnecesary, and it wasnt even that revolutionary like they said. Still a great performance though.

[Red 98,225]

It was amazing, people resent it because of the whole intel bullshit

[GaGaAst 13,023]

They hyped way too much and delivered absolutely nothing extraordinary so people were upset and criticism followed. But it was not a bad performance or a messy one. 

[Delusional 9,221]

Have y’all maybe thought about the fact that the actual better intel tech was reserved for another project (ahem, the super bowl) instead of some tribute?

so stop calling it lazy lmaooo because the intel tech we got later on was amazing 

[dynamite 60,098]

The hype was the problem, the performance itself was good.

[UNIGMA 195]

It would be more epic if she only perform that major tom song in full

[Luna Lovegood 24,424]

It was cute 

[Lazz Monster 19,353]

no

[Bonkers 29,660]

I think she tried to squeeze too many songs, but it was amazing.

[FlopSlurper 34,336]

I loved it tbh

[Killa 17,649]

The rebel rebel fame fashion part is at times superb. 

Rebel rebel is the highlight in my view, think this since the live. Her voice sounds great in the sense i would prefer listening to her than bowie. The rest have great choreo and besides some low notes she could own the songs. 

That main outfit tho.. Disaster and her expression is off putting. The break to lets dance is just not it. As well as the piano, tho kinda liked ziggy stardust. 

For me a ziggy stardust slowed down the 3 i said and maybe changes as closure with some message reinforcement would slay. Maybe even lie so would be too many songs. 

[HausOfG 1,560]

I loved it. I was sad that his son talked **** about it but maybe it was just too soon.  I think he'd act differently to Gaga doing it now seeing as she's not seen as weird

[The Fame 4,192]

There's something about the whole performance that seems very amateur for some reason. The songs don't really blend into each other well and the whole thing seems pretty disjointed (Whether or not that's commentary on the variability of Bowie's sounds I'm not sure, as I'm not super familiar with Bowie's songs or performance styles, tbh). She is also singing in an odd voice that I don't think she ever uses, so I think some people may have issue with that.