Jump to content
opinion

Why is Gaga labelled as a cheap madonna copycat?


Luna Lovegood

Featured Posts

Mister G
1 minute ago, Musicisfreedom said:

Wouldn't say most even, that forum does not represent most Madonna fans, a lot of us aren't even able to get accepted there. I think Little Monsters just get to see the loud minority because of the dumb fan war. 

And I agree it hasn't really gotten as bad with Ava, and I hope it doesn't. But Little Monsters have bullied people off of social media for winning awards Gaga was nominated for. My point, fanbases can get pretty brutal and ugly.

Wasn’t it discussed recently that if anyone shared a friendly opinion towards Gaga even as a Madonna fan they got banned or frowned upon at Madonnation?

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Replies 69
  • Created
  • Last Reply
Musicisfreedom

I do want to say, even though Gaga and Madonna have had their share of this "feud" as well, don't judge an artist by their fan base. Both Gaga and Madge are incredibly talented, beautiful and wonderful women. And both should be celebrated for their art and impact on society. 

 

Bitch I'm Madonna
Link to post
Share on other sites

JINNOCIDE

I believe it's because they were very similar (white american-italian, blonde girls) both in the way they approached things. Madonna has this "be a superstar" thing since Express Yourself, a thing Gaga repeats on Born This Way. I've seen things Madonna said that Gaga said it too, and I'm not a super Madonna fan (Hung Up slays tho), so I can see Madonna stans seeing similarities on Gaga and getting mad.

I don't think it's enough reason to hate on both artists. People picked on Gaga because she was the very big next thing and Madonna legacy's was already built. It's a fandom thing I think, the bigger the popstar the bigger they'll attack the next star to try to protect their fave.

To me it's just exhausting and I bop to both.

Stream Borderline and Stupid Love on Spotify when it's available 

gg1.png

STAN RINA SAWAYAMA
Link to post
Share on other sites

Musicisfreedom
1 minute ago, Mister G said:

Wasn’t it discussed recently that if anyone shared a friendly opinion towards Gaga even as a Madonna fan they got banned or frowned upon at Madonnation?

Yes, I believe so. I wasn't even able to make an account there. Its an absolute sh*tshow. Most Madonna fans I've met don't claim them as part of our fanbase. They are a very vile minority that I hope doesn't represent the kind people i have met on other M forums and even here.

Bitch I'm Madonna
Link to post
Share on other sites

Mister G
2 minutes ago, Musicisfreedom said:

Yes, I believe so. I wasn't even able to make an account there. Its an absolute sh*tshow. Most Madonna fans I've met don't claim them as part of our fanbase. They are a very vile minority that I hope doesn't represent the kind people i have met on other M forums and even here.

I have always loved both M and Gagz and felt the world was big enough for both to exist. If we could get a collab one day that would be golden.

Link to post
Share on other sites

The Bling

Because most popstars do random one-time references, Gaga shaped most of her career choices, aesthetics and sounds after Madonna

I won't reply to butthurt quotes :spin: SEETHE

Sigmund Freud, analyze this
Link to post
Share on other sites

JINNOCIDE
2 minutes ago, Musicisfreedom said:

Yes, I believe so. I wasn't even able to make an account there. Its an absolute sh*tshow. Most Madonna fans I've met don't claim them as part of our fanbase. They are a very vile minority that I hope doesn't represent the kind people i have met on other M forums and even here.

Well... let's not forget how people here bash Madonna too. Remember when it was "ok" to call Madonna old? Like, do these people think time doesn't pass to them? :air:

STAN RINA SAWAYAMA
Link to post
Share on other sites

Runway
1 minute ago, The Bling said:

Because most popstars do random one-time references, Gaga shaped most of her career choices, aesthetics and sounds after Madonna

I won't reply to butthurt quotes :spin: SEETHE

Nice edit, didn’t know yall could type so fast at the geriatrics

Link to post
Share on other sites

Lord Temptation

Nobody compares Madonna to Gaga anymore. Only from 2011-2017 or so when the Great Gaga Backlash was infecting hearts and minds.

But it’s 2020 sis. That scheisse is old.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guillaume Hamon
4 minutes ago, Musicisfreedom said:

don't judge an artist by their fan base.

Honestly if I was disliking artist each time I saw repeated nastiness from its  fanbase I could hate grande, beyoncé, BTS, bieber, nicki, del rey, madonna, Swift, gaga herself and many more so... Good advice! ;) 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Lord Temptation
1 minute ago, MessyTop said:

I’m amazed the thread hasn’t been locked. Woof 

It hasn’t been locked because it’s not about Billie :poot: :madge: :ally:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Musicisfreedom
Just now, JINNOCIDE said:

Well... let's not forget how people here bash Madonna too. Remember when it was "ok" to call Madonna old? Like, do these people think time doesn't pass to them? :air:

I agree 100%. I've seen Gaga say the nastiest things about Madonna, especially calling her old and other juvenile insults that do nothing but make you look dumb. 

But MNation is a totally different beast when it comes to fans bullying other artists. It is an absolute hellhole.

Bitch I'm Madonna
Link to post
Share on other sites

JINNOCIDE
10 minutes ago, The Bling said:

Because most popstars do random one-time references, Caca shaped most of her career choices, aesthetics and sounds after Madonna

I won't reply to butthurt quotes :spin: SEETHE

But she never hid this? :air:

She always said how Madonna was a big inspiration. Was she the ONLY inspiration to base her entire career tho?

tenor.gif

STAN RINA SAWAYAMA
Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...