Did Gaga really break her hip back then....

[LaLa 19,704]

30 minutes ago, Glamourpuss said:

How come she doesn't seem to have any scarring? I know she can afford some top surgeons but they've done a hell of a job because you can't tell she's had anything done. 

It was done laparoscopically, she has three small scars. See here:

[xoxo Craig 55,649]

9 minutes ago, derpmonster said:

And then she got up and left the stage, and came back for Marry The Night during which she sort of "ran" across the stage. This is simply not possible with a fracture. She had more than just a labral tear (now that I read the quote above) but it wasn't a fracture for sure. 

I know Gaga is a warrior and stuff but literally no one can do that with a hip fracture.

Her labral tear probably happened earlier and she kept performing with it until she got complications. I'm not saying Gaga is lying, I'm saying she might have misunderstood exactly what was going on. People also often use common language for things that isn't medically accurate.

My dad is an orthopedic surgeon and has performed full hip replacements too. I'll ask him about this case.

I mean, if she had Morphine and smoked a joint she'd probably not have felt the pain... its possible that she done that just to get through the show. Then she realised she couldn't go on like that and she really needed treatment. Idk, I'm not an expert and I have only fractured my finger before    I didn't need surgery on it though 

[Magui 2,629]

5 minutes ago, LaLa said:

It was done laparoscopically, she has three small scars. See here:

Thank you. Years ago i remember looking at pictures to try to find where was her scar... This is really stupid and not important lol but you made me realize i was looking at it and didn't see it lol. It's like was looking at pictures with a mental image of a scarr and couldn't see it. 

[Jnick8 530]

1 hour ago, Andy McQueen said:

... Or was it the Fibromyalgia and she just didn't knew? But if I remember correctly, she said her hipbones like really cracked? Or is it possible it was the neuropathic chronic pain but since back then it was still not researched well enough and people didn't take it seriously, she basically had to "invent" a condition or nobody would believe that she is in constant strong pain? Just wondering. It must be horrible to suffer this long day for day, I really hope therapies and medicine can sooth her body pain enough.

 

If she wanted to hide it she would have with art à la Michael Jackson glove (if lost... look it up). Mwah. 

[Guest]

25 minutes ago, ltlmnstr said:

I think the tear happened around 4 months before that montreal video 

This seems reasonable to me. I read that the tear can happen from repeated movements, and all she does when she is touring is literally dancing the same choreography everyday. Twice if you count rehearsals. 

[derpmonster 22,412]

6 minutes ago, xoxo Craig said:

I mean, if she had Morphine and smoked a joint she'd probably not have felt the pain... its possible that she done that just to get through the show. Then she realised she couldn't go on like that and she really needed treatment. Idk, I'm not an expert and I have only fractured my finger before    I didn't need surgery on it though 

Yeah but it's not even just about the pain. Your body can literally not support your weight if your hip is broken. And I doubt she was on morphine during the show but it's possible.

[27monster27 13,540]

2 hours ago, Glamourpuss said:

How come she doesn't seem to have any scarring? I know she can afford some top surgeons but they've done a hell of a job because you can't tell she's had anything done. 

There is a certain type of surgery for a broken hip that you can get that leaves no scars, although I do not remember what it is called.

EDIT: Nvm, someone showed pictures.