Gaga’s voice sounds STRAINED (angry comments warning)

[Sanne Godijn 2,203]

4 minutes ago, zino said:

this is the worst her vocals ever sound to me, even worse than 2008 huskyga. she's losting her range and specially her tone quality, in some songs like born this way acoustic honestly she sounds horrible and almost all the time off key, even when she's not. it's really really sad tell this when just 2 years ago she sounded SO incredible in jwt.

 and it's really sad how some people here likes to pretend that there's no problem, that they are better than ever,  that it's just a cold or tiredness (like, since the first enigma show back in december??). 

admitting it's NOT hating.

 

I kindly disagree with you she sounds the same to me in both videos  so i think your being dramatic

[Der Meister 3,000]

4 minutes ago, Sanne Godijn said:

I kindly disagree with you she sounds the same to me in both videos  so i think your being dramatic

I think you need to have your ears checked darling

[Sanne Godijn 2,203]

Just now, Der Meister said:

I think you need to have your ears checked darling

Nah i dont think so

[chromasine 5,439]

4 minutes ago, Sanne Godijn said:

I kindly disagree with you she sounds the same to me in both videos  so i think your being dramatic

"she's losting her range and specially her tone quality, in some songs like born this way acoustic honestly she sounds horrible and almost all the time off key, even when she's not."

[Benguan 472]

19 minutes ago, zino said:

this is the worst her vocals ever sound to me, even worse than 2008 huskyga. she's losting her range and specially her tone quality, in some songs like born this way acoustic honestly she sounds horrible and almost all the time off key, even when she's not. it's really really sad tell this when just 2 years ago she sounded SO incredible in jwt.

 and it's really sad how some people here likes to pretend that there's no problem, that they are better than ever,  that it's just a cold or tiredness (like, since the first enigma show back in december??). 

admitting it's NOT hating.

 

Personally I don’t entirely agree with you...

the clip of Feb3rd is not the best performance she did for this song. The whole concert in Jan20th is better, so is the song Lush Life.

that being said... I think now her overall tone is deeper and darker. I think this is a better tone quality for this song tbh, sounds so much more powerful. 

However, I do think there are certain parts in her voice that is not as good as the C2C era. Her breath is overall shorter. There are multiple places in the first video that she sang in one phrase where the second video she took breaths in between. She is strained a bit in that clip but I believe the one on Jan20th is better. I personally like her voice now for jazz more than before.

Ps: personally I think her falsetto at the moment is improving so so much!

[zino 173]

8 minutes ago, Sanne Godijn said:

I kindly disagree with you she sounds the same to me in both videos  so i think your being dramatic

she sounds the same in lows, that i think that it's the only part of her voice that actually doesn't changed at all

but her voice cracks in both climax of the song, and you can clearly see that it's way harder for her to sing this now than in 2015,  in some other songs like cheek to cheek, anything goes and lady is a tramp she even lowered the key for the first since she recorded them

[Sanne Godijn 2,203]

1 minute ago, zino said:

she sounds the same in lows, that i think that it's the only part of her voice that actually doesn't changed at all

but her voice cracks in both climax of the song, and you can clearly see that it's way harder for her to sing this now than in 2015,  in some other songs like cheek to cheek, anything goes and lady is a tramp she even lowered the key for the first since she recorded them

So what does that mean

[zino 173]

3 minutes ago, jinko said:

"she's losting her range and specially her tone quality, in some songs like born this way acoustic honestly she sounds horrible and almost all the time off key, even when she's not."

 

[zino 173]

2 minutes ago, Benguan said:

Personally I don’t entirely agree with you...

the clip of Feb3rd is not the best performance she did for this song. The whole concert in Jan20th is better, so is the song Lush Life.

that being said... I think now her overall tone is deeper and darker. I think this is a better tone quality for this song tbh, sounds so much more powerful. 

However, I do think there are certain parts in her voice that is not as good as the C2C era. Her breath is overall shorter. There are multiple places in the first video that she sang in one phrase where the second video she took breaths in between. She is strained a bit in that clip but I believe the one on Jan20th is better. I personally like her voice now for jazz more than before.

sometimes i think her tone it's still the same from 2015, cause in some songs like coquette and what a difference a day makes she sounds bright, this husky deeper tone seems a stylic choice for me

[Sanne Godijn 2,203]

5 minutes ago, zino said:

 

I wanno go so badly

[chromasine 5,439]

5 minutes ago, zino said:

 

So this was where she "sounds horrible and almost all the time off key, even when she's not"  I don't know where you bought your ears, but aside from that teensy part where she really had trouble breathing, to me, she sounded the farthest from being horrible and off key "all the time"  But I don't have the ears you have so... yikes 

 

 

[tylertremallose 1,379]

7 hours ago, GrigioGirl1 said:

I don't really hear the strain in that clip. How is TEOG? That's a tough one to sing. Any strain? 

The smoking needs to stop.

 

[Hurem 17,800]

8 hours ago, KatieJudasGaga4 said:

I'll rather be a snowflake than a fan saying her voice is unbearable. I seriously hate when people call me a snowflake. So, I cannot defend Gaga at all? Why do you have to be such a negative person most of the time. I always see you get negative towards other members and I am really sick of it.

Cause if anyone dares to say ANYTHING that’s not praise about Gaga you jump on their neck with the typical “ah you’re toxic, ah you’re sooo negative” crap. 

[KatieJudasGaga4 67,907]

1 minute ago, Hurem said:

Cause if anyone dares to say ANYTHING that’s not praise about Gaga you jump on their neck with the typical “ah you’re toxic, ah you’re sooo negative” crap. 

Right. MANY others on here don't praise Gaga and do I tell them anything, no.  I only quote people who are being disrespectful towards Gaga. The OP clearly stated that her voice is getting unbearable to hear. Obviously, I'm gonna say something. In other instances, people don't praise Gaga at all, but at least they are respectful about it. I find it kinda funny how you get angry when fans defend Gaga. What do you expect? Its a site dedicated to Gaga. If you get so angry with "cupcakes" and the "crap", you can choose to ignore it, but you didn't.

[Hurem 17,800]

1 hour ago, KatieJudasGaga4 said:

Right. MANY others on here don't praise Gaga and do I tell them anything, no.  I only quote people who are being disrespectful towards Gaga. The OP clearly stated that her voice is getting unbearable to hear. Obviously, I'm gonna say something. In other instances, people don't praise Gaga at all, but at least they are respectful about it. I find it kinda funny how you get angry when fans defend Gaga. What do you expect? Its a site dedicated to Gaga. If you get so angry with "cupcakes" and the "crap", you can choose to ignore it, but you didn't.

Cause it’s annoying as hell when people jump on you for saying you don’t like something about Gaga. I mean, y’all dragged me when I posted a video of Gaga lipsyncing just because “GagA neVeR lipSyNcs!!”