How each eras singles should have been and what would they peak at

[Ladey Gaygay 9,321]

So im taking inspiration from youtube queen's @KatieJudasGaga4 video and Heres how this thread goes

Fame

The Fame (#5) *Buzz Single*

Just Dance(#1)

Poker Face(#1)

Paparazzi(#1)

Lovegame(#3)

TFM

Monster(#3) *Buzz single*

God Romance (#1)

Telephone(#2)

Spoiler

Alejandro was good but i don't think it  was a good single choice

BTW

Government Hooker(#10) *Buzz Singles*

Judas(#5)

The Edge of Glory(#1)

You and I (#4)

Schiesse (#15)

Born this way(#1) The last hurrah for the album

ARTPOP

Aura(#10-#5ish)

No Buzz single

G.U.Y.(#1!)

DWUW *solo or xtina vesion* (#2)

Sexxx Dreams(#3)

Joanne

A-YO(#25)*Buzz Single*

John Wayne(#8)

DIC(#5)

Hey Girl(#30) *Only "Flop"

Angel Down(#1)

Million Reasons(#1)

ASIB

Shallow(#1)

ARUTW(#3)

INLA(#10)

 

Im basically A little manager and G.U.Y deserved better

 

[Didymus 34,379]

Too lazy but yes, G.U.Y. really did deserve so much better

[Enzo 37,977]

So... one #1 for each album

[rumours 45,521]

4 minutes ago, GlitterandTeeth said:

G.U.Y.(#1!)

4 minutes ago, GlitterandTeeth said:

Angel Down(#1)

I need whatever you are smoking.

[Ladey Gaygay 9,321]

1 minute ago, Rumours1977 said:

I need whatever you are smoking.

This is all the reason i need

[Ladey Gaygay 9,321]

3 minutes ago, Enzo said:

So... one #1 for each album

[noisullitcefrep 3,871]

7 minutes ago, GlitterandTeeth said:

Alejandro was good but i don't think it  was a good single choice

It was literally one of her most successful songs in Europe

[Luke78619 23,300]

How you gon say

10 minutes ago, GlitterandTeeth said:

ASIB

 Shallow(#1)

When shallow was the first single and peaked at #5 

why not just change every peak to #1 whilst we’re at it 

[teawhore 7,667]

The Fame

1. Just Dance - 1
2. Poker Face - 1
- Starstruck - 34
3. Paparazzi - 3
4. LoveGame - 5

The Fame Monster

1. Bad Romance - 1
- Speechless - 13
2. Telephone - 2
3. Alejandro - 4

Born This Way

1. Born This Way - 1
- Hair - 12
- Judas - 18
2. The Edge of Glory - 1
3. Marry the Night - 6
4. Yoü and I - 7

ARTPOP

1. Applause - 3
- Venus - 29
- Dope - 12
- Gypsy - 32
2. Do What U Want - 12

Joanne

1. Perfect Illusion - 10
- A-YO - 66
2. Million Reasons - 4
3. Joanne - --

A Star is Born

1. Shallow - 5
- Maybe It's Time - 18
- Heal Me - 45
2. I'll Never Love Again - 3
3. Always Remember Us This Way - 9

 

and this one is actually realistic!!

[tomsches 17,388]

How are we supposed to know how it would have charted? 

[MaryJaneHolland 77,348]

Sis you need some reality check with all those #1s

Joanne should've been:

A-YO (8)

Million Reasons (20-25)

John Wayne (4)

DIC remix with a feature (8-10)

[Ladey Gaygay 9,321]

9 minutes ago, tomsches said:

How are we supposed to know how it would have charted? 

Like a gut feeling

[Ladey Gaygay 9,321]

8 minutes ago, MaryJaneHolland said:

Sis you need some reality check with all those #1s

Joanne should've been:

A-YO (8)

Million Reasons (20-25)

John Wayne (4)

DIC remix with a feature (8-10)

Im a delusional stan so...

But GUY is everything

[Ladey Gaygay 9,321]

18 minutes ago, Lo Lee Ta said:

The Fame

1. Just Dance - 1
2. Poker Face - 1
- Starstruck - 34
3. Paparazzi - 3
4. LoveGame - 5

The Fame Monster

1. Bad Romance - 1
- Speechless - 13
2. Telephone - 2
3. Alejandro - 4

Born This Way

1. Born This Way - 1
- Hair - 12
- Judas - 18
2. The Edge of Glory - 1
3. Marry the Night - 6
4. Yoü and I - 7

ARTPOP

1. Applause - 3
- Venus - 29
- Dope - 12
- Gypsy - 32
2. Do What U Want - 12

Joanne

1. Perfect Illusion - 10
- A-YO - 66
2. Million Reasons - 4
3. Joanne - --

A Star is Born

1. Shallow - 5
- Maybe It's Time - 18
- Heal Me - 45
2. I'll Never Love Again - 3
3. Always Remember Us This Way - 9

 

and this one is actually realistic!!

[Monster7 5,697]

28 minutes ago, noisullitcefrep said:

It was literally one of her most successful songs in Europe

I was going to say this, it was more successful than Telephone and in some countries it almost tied with BR

Also, I think buzz singles are not a good idea, your singles order in BTW, AP (Applause not being a single) and Joanne is a mess