Would you be here for Jack Antonoff producing a Gaga album?

[Guest JolanJoringel]

 

I mean, he produced three iconic female pop records of 2017:

 

 

And yes, I know what he said about Gaga and that he wouldn't work with her ... It's just a hypothetical question. And maybe his mind will change ...

I would love it 

 

[GagaIsDope 679]

Melodrama's my favourite album of all time so yes

[xoxo Craig 55,649]

No, I hated Reputation and thought it was very basic and not much substance to it. The album was very repetitive, like we heard the same track over and over again.

I didn't connect with Melodrama either, everyone was hyping it up and when I listened I was disappointed. The sounds on there weren't my thing, and I'm not a fan of her voice.

WITH THAT BEING SAID, Gaga usually brings the best out of producers and usually their sounds/previous work with other artists DO NOT reflect the sounds that will be on a Gaga track. If Gaga was to work with Jack, I would be disappointed but still hold hope that it doesn't sound like his previous works

[Guest JolanJoringel]

Just now, Craig Barnes said:

No, I hated Reputation and thought it was very basic and not much substance to it. The album was very repetitive, like we heard the same track over and over again.

I didn't connect with Melodrama either, everyone was hyping it up and when I listened I was disappointed. The sounds on there weren't my thing, and I'm not a fan of her voice.

WITH THAT BEING SAID, Gaga usually brings the best out of producers and usually their sounds/previous work with other artists DO NOT reflect the sounds that will be on a Gaga track. If Gaga was to work with Jack, I would be disappointed but still hold hope that it doesn't sound like his previous works

Have you listened to St. Vincents Masseduction yet?

[xoxo Craig 55,649]

What did he say about Gaga exactly? 

[xoxo Craig 55,649]

Just now, JolanJoringel said:

Have you listened to St. Vincents Masseduction yet?

Who is St. Vincent? 

[iCpro 14,846]

His work on Melodrama and Beautiful Trauma blew my mind, I would so be here for Gaga x Antonoff 

[Guest JolanJoringel]

3 minutes ago, Craig Barnes said:

Who is St. Vincent? 

An iconic musician! And the third record I listed above, besides Melodrama and reputation ...

 

[Guest JolanJoringel]

4 minutes ago, Craig Barnes said:

What did he say about Gaga exactly? 

He added, "Taylor Swift is cool, because she's the closest thing today that hearkens to Michael Jackson -- to great, great pop music. There's a difference between her and Gaga and Katy Perry and Lily Allen and all that. It all feels throwaway, comparatively."

Source: https://abcnews.go.com/Entertainment/funs-jack-antonoff-slams-lady-gaga-katy-perry/story?id=24599534

 

That was in 2014 ... Maybe his mind changed with everything she has done afterwards.

[DelusionalGaga 29,409]

I guess it all depends on Gaga's input. If we get a Melodrama then yes, if it's a Reputation then no ma'am. Masseduction was kinda underwhelming too. 

[duckworth 2,951]

I love his work but I dont think his sound won't do well with Gaga's. 

[ryanripley 86,575]

idk he doesn't really excite me

[xoxo Craig 55,649]

12 minutes ago, JolanJoringel said:

He added, "Taylor Swift is cool, because she's the closest thing today that hearkens to Michael Jackson -- to great, great pop music. There's a difference between her and Gaga and Katy Perry and Lily Allen and all that. It all feels throwaway, comparatively."

Source: https://abcnews.go.com/Entertainment/funs-jack-antonoff-slams-lady-gaga-katy-perry/story?id=24599534

 

That was in 2014 ... Maybe his mind changed with everything she has done afterwards.

Comparing MJ to Taylor?! Mess

[xoxo Craig 55,649]

11 minutes ago, JolanJoringel said:

An iconic musician! And the third record I listed above, besides Melodrama and reputation ...

 

These tracks do nothing for me, it doesn't excite me or make me want to stream the song again. I don't like this sound at all, so it's still a no from me

[kaelergrey 5,386]

10 minutes ago, JolanJoringel said:

He added, "Taylor Swift is cool, because she's the closest thing today that hearkens to Michael Jackson -- to great, great pop music. There's a difference between her and Gaga and Katy Perry and Lily Allen and all that. It all feels throwaway, comparatively."

Source: https://abcnews.go.com/Entertainment/funs-jack-antonoff-slams-lady-gaga-katy-perry/story?id=24599534

 

That was in 2014 ... Maybe his mind changed with everything she has done afterwards.

I like some of Taylor Swifts music but being compared to a "Legend" is a reach. MESS