What is Gaga's most vocally challenging song?

[Moo 2,082]

Well, Perfect Illusion and Diamond Heart are clearly the ones she struggles with most, at least recently. 

The slower tempo ones that she likes to sing high, like Alejandro and Paparazzi aren’t so bad, as she has time to get ready for the note. I feel like Diamond Heart in particular is rushing through too fast for her to prepare 

[Twitter 14]

4 hours ago, Miracle said:

She's done Paparazzi falsetto a couple times in the last couple years.

 

I think she tried it in the private wedding she did last summer?

 

Facts!

 

[Twitter 14]

From each album. This includes songs involving heavy choreo or vocals alone:

TF: Paparazzi

TFM: Speechless

BTW: Judas & Marry The Night

AP: DWUW, Gypsy, MANiCURE

C2C: Half The Album

J: Diamond Heart & Perfect Illusion

[Damon 10,904]

i really don't get why some of you are saying paparazzi

ot: diamond heart

[Anderson123 38,785]

Fashion of His Love. 

[Twitter 14]

43 minutes ago, Antonoff said:

i really don't get why some of you are saying paparazzi

Mainly cause the chorus is vocally challenging live and on the studio version. 

[geopang 4,831]

Judas with all that choreo. She was always breathless during those performances

[River 118,017]

Scheiße

She's always singing very bad the German part.. it's like she's singing in gibberish

[actsleazy 6,633]

4 hours ago, Jade Welling said:

I think the verses of Judas are incredibly difficult....the pitch and the weird accent and everything....its very strange...it's the only song she's ever seemed to struggle singing live im

i've always thought her voice never fit Judas which is super weird to say since it's her song 

but the belts during the last chorus always stuck out to me 

[AnglerfishbraBENUS 5,734]

6 hours ago, Moebius said:

Perfect Illusion is straight up brutal for her voice. It's just a hard song to sing in general.

As mentioned before, she can't really pull of Paparazzi's falsetto as well anymore. Ofc her voice got deeper and that was not really up to her.

Judas with choreo left her breathless  

Honestly besides having literally no room to breathe and it being in an impossibly high key, PI isn't that hard.  Idk why she didn't lower the studio version

[joannesrats 26]

6 hours ago, Hyoha said:

I sing and Dope's chorus is extremely difficult for me, because you're jumping from a low to a really high register in a split second during the "high for so long" part. If I'm not mistaken it's her song with the biggest jump from one note to another.

It's actually not! It's only an octave jump, but in Diamond Heart from "...girlfriend, rain..." Is an octave and a 5th!

[joannesrats 26]

24 minutes ago, whipopotamus said:

Honestly besides having literally no room to breathe and it being in an impossibly high key, PI isn't that hard.  Idk why she didn't lower the studio version

The key isn't that high, it's n A major and it modulates up to C major. The highest note in the song is a D#, which is the same not as an Eb - the same note that she's singing in the chorus of dope on "high for so long." For me, personally when I sing it, it's just because of the tone of the song. It's a very angry, shouty song and that's why it's difficult to sing. If it was just belting it wouldn't be too hard, either with proper breath!

Edit: Typo 

[joannesrats 26]

So sorry for the music rants, I'm a music major 

 

As for actually answering the question, I'd say The Cure. It's really lyric-heavy, and when she sings it live she isn't singing it in her mix like she is in the studio and she has a hard time not getting nasal. Then in the chorus, it's in her break so it's hard to keep it supported without sounding flat, thin, or shouty. 

[AnglerfishbraBENUS 5,734]

10 hours ago, PhillipBagshaw said:

The key isn't that high, it's n A major and it modulates up to C major. The highest note in the song is a D#, which is the same not as an Eb - the same note that she's singing in the chorus of dope on "high for so long." For me, personally when I sing it, it's just because of the tone of the song. It's a very angry, shouty song and that's why it's difficult to sing. If it was just belting it wouldn't be too hard, either with proper breath!

Edit: Typo 

She literally changed the key on tour though.. It's too high.  She can take it a step or two down and it would be perfectly fine

[adamsenigma 9,520]

10 hours ago, PhillipBagshaw said:

The key isn't that high, it's n A major and it modulates up to C major. The highest note in the song is a D#, which is the same not as an Eb - the same note that she's singing in the chorus of dope on "high for so long." For me, personally when I sing it, it's just because of the tone of the song. It's a very angry, shouty song and that's why it's difficult to sing. If it was just belting it wouldn't be too hard, either with proper breath!

Edit: Typo 

This. I mean, it's not hard for me to hit the notes, but if you want to sound good while singing it you have to sound angry, graspy, like you're having one big ass meltdown, and that's difficult to me since I have a very r&b type of voice. Anyway, I can still sing most of Beyoncé's songs where she's shouting all the way through.