What do you make of the BBC’s review of the Birmingham show?

[Mus 7,883]

 

26 minutes ago, sipthistea said:

All these people claiming they know who Lady Gaga is, or saying who she should be. 

But she keeps proving them wrong. 

“People take me both way too seriously, and not seriously enough” Sip this Diamond Tea 

[highongaga 869]

[mezzanine 476]

28 minutes ago, TheQueenLG said:

I said 'lots of you'. That doesn't necessarily mean you. And all I'm trying to say is your criticism is very ill-timed seeing how much pain Gaga is in.... I don't praise every fart that comes from her ass... Stop being rude. And don't lie. Most of the negativity in this thread is from pressed LMs who had their show cancelled, which was completely out of Gaga's control and not her fault. That's the tea here, honey. 

that has nothing to do with me, and definitely not my cup of tea because i saw 2 concerts of this tour so 

 

 

people can note things that are not "that" good for them without meaning they're bitter

[Glamourpuss 29,062]

38 minutes ago, ryanripley said:

if those interludes aren't creative and gaga then idk what is 

I was also feeling a bit glad my show got cancelled but I just realised I won't experience those amazing interludes. 

[Irrelevant 20,281]

53 minutes ago, MJHolland said:

Personally I really disliked how scripted the show was 

Like obvi choreo has to be scripted and rehearsed but every word between songs sounded so planned

She plans a lot of her speeches in other tours too

[ryanripley 86,575]

Just now, PussyGlam said:

I was also feeling a bit glad my show got cancelled but I just realised I won't experience those amazing interludes. 

why were you feeling glad?  

[KianG7 57]

Can we please stop comparing EVERYTHING she does to the BTWB ?

The JWT was such a magical experience for me with the stages, bridges and interludes. It might be less avant garde than some of her past stuff but that doesn't mean its unoriginal or not creative 

You should realize that no other current pop star could have delivered such a show 

[Glamourpuss 29,062]

4 minutes ago, ryanripley said:

why were you feeling glad?  

I couldn't afford accommodation and travel but was some how going to go anyway. 

Also, I feel bored of Joanne already but don't know if that's my depression talking cos I don't have enthusiasm for anything right now. 

[Impostor 4,114]

I'm living for this thread but it's also a mess

Gaga has helped me so much in the past but now she seems to have faded away. Ugly truth. I still believe in her potential and I still think she is ****ing talented and amazing, but her new style and new music are not smart enough. In fact, even low budget alternative artists look better than her these days 

[Ruthy 686]

k

[brklyn 11]

The review has been updated:

"UPDATE, 3 FEBRUARY 07:45 GMT : I'm extremely sorry to hear that Lady Gaga has had to cancel the rest of her tour because of her ongoing condition and that she is suffering from chronic pain. Although her show didn't quite hit the spot for me, there is no question that she gave 100% of her energy to it. It was just great to have her back and I know she'll be devastated not to be able to perform in front of her hundreds of thousands of fans, 99.9% of whom I'm sure would have given her a thumping five-star review. Get well soon, Gaga."

[mezzanine 476]

i was gonna say something about her, her speeches, and more stuff but i can already smell the sh*tstorm coming straight to my face so I'll just shut the f*ck up 

[QueenMortuana 1,193]

Agreed. They put that pretty well without sounding like they were bashing her for it.   I saw the show twice (stadium and arena) and had a great time but it’s definitely not like the other tours 

[SEXODUS 5,927]

7 minutes ago, brklyn said:

The review has been updated:

"UPDATE, 3 FEBRUARY 07:45 GMT : I'm extremely sorry to hear that Lady Gaga has had to cancel the rest of her tour because of her ongoing condition and that she is suffering from chronic pain. Although her show didn't quite hit the spot for me, there is no question that she gave 100% of her energy to it. It was just great to have her back and I know she'll be devastated not to be able to perform in front of her hundreds of thousands of fans, 99.9% of whom I'm sure would have given her a thumping five-star review. Get well soon, Gaga."

inb4 someone trashes him/her for this bc GGD lives for drama 

[mezzanine 476]

yes, but it seems that if you give your opinion you're dragging gaga, you're mean and you can't log into gagadaily anymore.

 

i couldn't go to the MBT so for me, the best  tour was the BTWBall as show, then the JWT, then the artrave (maybe because I don't remember it that well), then the C2C tour.

and for me, her voice was shinning at the JWT like never before and it was my favorite when we talk about singing LIVE and serving vocals.

@ speeches, this one was feeling colder, maybe in the US was different, but here was like too scripted, it is always but at the BTWball felt more natural

 

end

 

is it that DRAMATIC? we just ended gaga's career? no

so i don't get all this drama for having AN OPINION, so if she just tours with marina abramovic in 2028 and they just **** on stage while this is sounding:

is it gonna be gaga's best tour? because it will also mean a change and an "artistic evolution" 

 

well this is how you sound sometimes from the outside