Mariah vs Celine vs Whitney

[Stevo 641]

In your opinion who do you think is the most talented in the vocal trinity? (Includes all talents, such as songwriting etc.)  

 

[TheRoof 21,600]

Includes talents such as songwriting 

that's why Beyonce will never be part of that

OT:Mariah , she can be the less humble person on earth but she writtes and produces all of her albums and that's something Whitney  and Celine can't relate  

i like all of them tho 

[XXXXX 4,775]

7 minutes ago, MarlonBrando7 said:

Mariah , she can be the less humble person on earth but she writtes and produces all of her albums and that's something Whitney  and Celine can't relate  

i like all of them tho 

[TheRoof 21,600]

3 minutes ago, BloodyGlory said:

I will give her the benefit of the doubt

[SDG91 373]

MARIAH! But I’m a stan lol

[tthen 4,621]

Easily. No competition there BUT her voice really deteriorated during her final years. I'm not sure if any of the 3 write their songs (don't think so), but Whitney wins. 90s Mariah is a close 2nd.

[tthen 4,621]

1 hour ago, MarlonBrando7 said:

that's why Beyonce will never be part of that

 

Whitney doesn't write her songs too afaik  (yes Whitney is far more superior but just pointing out)

[RAMROD 109,386]

1 hour ago, MarlonBrando7 said:

Includes talents such as songwriting 

that's why Beyonce will never be part of that

 

 

Such ironic things to say when two of most well known songs of Whitney are cover versions *GASPS!* such a scandal!

 

Matter of fact, 80% of ((((Female))) pop singers of the past didn’t write their own songs. Yes, that includes many of your gay staples songs by female singers. All they did just give an idea here and there, just like Beyoncé did. (OH!!!!!!!!! )

 

 

[TimisaMonster 31,073]

Celine....Presently, she has managed her career better, her vocal control and meticulous care of her voice is what has led her to have the longevity, and to this day can still hit notes of her old hits and overall has a sweet and humble personality too as a bonus

Mariah HAD the voice but abused it with alcohol and didn't take care of her voice as she got older. Like Whitney, people reminisce about her younger voice and hits...

Whitney obviously had drug issues that ruined her voice even while she was alive later in her career....she literally had fans walking out of her concerts and how could she record another decent record? Her career was done...she is now just a memory of a once sweet and powerful voice

[Gypsy Life 118,907]

Celine. The only one who can sing 30 years into her career just as good as at her peak.

Mariah and Whitney before her death had Britney-level vocals.

[Eighteen 5,430]

mariah carey to me has had the best voice ever. her whistle notes at one point were so beautiful and clean

[tomsches 17,395]

Since I don't think any of them wrote the majority of their songs themselves, I went for Celine, because she is the only singer whose voice did not deteriorate