Jump to content
opinion

Real difference between Gaga v Madonna


OOPS22

Featured Posts

sipthistea

Well, that's Madonna I guess...I kind of understand her personality, that's how she is. She's always ironic, but I don't think she was doing it in a rude way. 

I love how sweet Gaga is. She's too sweet :kara:

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Replies 48
  • Created
  • Last Reply
Windowlicker
1 minute ago, EDP said:

She just needs to know that if you act that way, you won't get a lot of fans nowadays. When was the last time she had a top 10? :bon:

 

I think she's doing just fine in the fans department, seeing as her tours are some of the highest grossing of all time.

Link to post
Share on other sites

13 minutes ago, headonfire said:

 

And you guys really think that Gaga is always always like this? Nice, sweet, caring, kind? Please... That's just naive.

People's personalities are fluid, and many many times, Gaga's kind caring personality is just the persona she is presenting. Let's be real.

Our opinions differ.   There are occasions when each of us is not our usual self, including Gaga.  But the kind, caring personality is not just a persona she is presenting, it's real, it's who she is as a person.

I live outside the space time continuum.
Link to post
Share on other sites

5 minutes ago, EDP said:

Hmm that's not what I said sis. Gaga calls her fans "bitches", "mother****ers"...she flips her fans off and tells us to calm down. And she's unapologetic about it! But she acts that way when it’s appropriate to (like at a concert). That’s Gaga’s upbringing coming through. She is “her father’s daughter”….she spreads kindness to others when it needs to be spread. She’s just a mannered person which I appreciate. 

Madonna can be bitchy and unapologetic as much as she wants. She just needs to know that if you act that way, you won't get a lot of fans nowadays. When was the last time she had a hit? :bon:

 

Well, if you wanna talk about hits... That won't help your cause. In the first 10 years of her career, Madonna had 11 number 1 hits in the US alone. Gaga over the last 9 has had 3, with the last one in 2011. 

In the first 10 years of her career, Madonna had 19 top 10 hits in the US alone. Gaga over the last 9 has had 10.

And I won't even mention touring.

 

Pitting one against the other is just silly...

Link to post
Share on other sites

Just now, headonfire said:

Well, if you wanna talk about hits... That won't help your cause. In the first 10 years of her career, Madonna had 11 number 1 hits in the US alone. Gaga over the last 9 has had 3, with the last one in 2011. 

In the first 10 years of her career, Madonna had 19 top 10 hits in the US alone. Gaga over the last 9 has had 10.

And I won't even mention touring.

 

Pitting one against the other is just silly...

Madonna is also 59, so of course she's going to have more numbers. 

Based off of your responses though, you seem to think Gaga is fake. If that's how you feel about her, why are you on this site? No shade I'm just genuinely curious. :oprah:

"The only prisons that exist are ones we put each other in."
Link to post
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Ronk said:

Our opinions differ.   There are occasions when each of us is not our usual self, including Gaga.  But the kind, caring personality is not just a persona she is presenting, it's real, it's who she is as a person.

And you know that because? Are you guys friends? That's impossible to say with certainty. I love Gaga for who she is with us, but I honestly know that you can't be like that all the time. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Just now, EDP said:

Madonna is also 59, so of course she's going to have more numbers. 

Based off of your responses though, you seem to think Gaga is fake. If that's how you feel about her, why are you on this site? No shade I'm just genuinely curious. :oprah:

It's not about having more numbers because she is 59. I was just showing you that in the same time span in Gaga's and Madonna's career, Madonna was doing much much better than Gaga is doing now, so there's not really a point to bring hits to the conversation.

And as you can see on my last post, I love Gaga for the way she is with us, but I'm sure that's not who she is. Not saying she is fake, but like she has said many times, she puts on different personas, and this is just one of them.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Windowlicker
1 minute ago, EDP said:

Madonna is also 59, so of course she's going to have more numbers. 

I don't see why you brought up such a superficial comparison to begin with then, because last time I checked Gaga's singles weren't lighting up the charts either.

Link to post
Share on other sites

tellemhone
47 minutes ago, EDP said:

If this was posted, my bad! I didn't know. :awkney:

I said I think so I'm not sure

I probably saw it somewhere else :oprah: 

 

:air: :air: :air:
Link to post
Share on other sites

@everyone saying Madonna was more realistic: I don’t believe so. If that were me, I would be even more thankful than Gaga was, cause people put in a lot of effort to make things like that, and even if you have a personality, it doesn’t hurt to show gratefulness. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, headonfire said:

It's not about having more numbers because she is 59. I was just showing you that in the same time span in Gaga's and Madonna's career, Madonna was doing much much better than Gaga is doing now, so there's not really a point to bring hits to the conversation.

And as you can see on my last post, I love Gaga for the way she is with us, but I'm sure that's not who she is. Not saying she is fake, but like she has said many times, she puts on different personas, and this is just one of them.

An interesting Gaga persona is her early one ... weird, crazy, freakish.  It turns out that persona was meant to help bullied kids who were made to feel like freaks in HS, just like Gaga when she was in HS.  She needed to connect with those kids in order to help them.  When you think about it, she gave up the GP in order to do so, as they are certainly turned off by weird, crazy, and freakish.  I posted links to about 80 of her earliest interviews, the very time she was putting on the freakish persona.  The interviews show that even in that era, her niceness shows through.  I think you just can't hide what you are really like as a person:

 

I live outside the space time continuum.
Link to post
Share on other sites

Free My Mind
3 hours ago, headonfire said:

Well, let me tell you... This is exactly what I love about Madonna and have loved all this years, like most of her fans -- her bitchy, unapologetic, empowering personality. From the start, she was never one who would play nice. Never. And I love it. 

This is all "let's be nice to the fans" is just fake...

Gaga's pushed this to the extreme and now fans keep wanting more and more, and when she doesn't give them that, well... The reactions are not good and she simply loses them. 

I want my idols to be real, fierce, strong and unashamed to be who they are.

 

 

why r u on gagadaily? really?

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Free My Mind said:

why r u on gagadaily? really?

 

Why? Is it forbidden to love Madonna and Gaga equally? Is it a condition to be on GGD to only love Gaga and hate every other artist?

Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...