Jump to content
charts

Chart Discussion: Joanne / Million Reasons


Noah

Featured Posts

  • Replies 15.3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply
Just now, Algorithm said:

Yesss! I think the GP are here for Gaga ballads this era :excited2:

Everyone who hears it, even my friends deep in the Hive LOVE the song. I think it's a perfect final single

Link to post
Share on other sites

nick4bty

Joanne is an earworm for sure but would never work as a single I don't think. Plus I wouldn't want them to risk their stance with radio after the third single. If the third single is strong, just leave it at that so there's a warm welcome for the next lead single

Link to post
Share on other sites

junolxf
24 minutes ago, Gypsy Life said:

They should delete the video. The audio has a higher replay value.

Aretha-Franklin-says-shes-talking-to-a-c

Delete this. :giveup::giveup::giveup:

"Seems to be trendy lately to talk sh*t about 'Lady Gaga' when your albums/singles drop." - Leviticus 20:27
Link to post
Share on other sites

Gaga Monster
Just now, nick4bty said:

Joanne is an earworm for sure but would never work as a single I don't think. Plus I wouldn't want them to risk their stance with radio after the third single. If the third single is strong, just leave it at that so there's a warm welcome for the next lead single

This. Gaga's team has to be careful with the next single, one screw up and radio will drop her again. Joanne is too risky, so is A Yo. I think her best bet is a cleaned up version of DIC. Instead of singing 'I touch myself to past the time' she should do 'I listen to Z100 to past the time' and maybe add a feature like Rihanna or The Weekend, someone big with streaming and radio. It has a tropical beat which gives it an advantage.

GGD Presidential Elections
Link to post
Share on other sites

stir the pot
1 minute ago, Toph said:

Everyone who hears it, even my friends deep in the Hive LOVE the song. I think it's a perfect final single

Yes, even my roommate, who clearly doesn't like Gaga, has Joanne on her playlist. I mean, wtf, I was surprised when Joanne played, like I really looked at her, like whaaat? lol And mostly of all reviews and reactions I saw, they listed Joanne as the highlight of the album. So I'm here for it as a final single. :hug:

Link to post
Share on other sites

stir the pot
5 minutes ago, Gaga Monster said:

This. Gaga's team has to be careful with the next single, one screw up and radio will drop her again. Joanne is too risky, so is A Yo. I think her best bet is a cleaned up version of DIC. Instead of singing 'I touch myself to past the time' she should do 'I listen to Z100 to past the time' and maybe add a feature like Rihanna or The Weekend, someone big with streaming and radio. It has a tropical beat which gives it an advantage.

lfrT5bQ.gif

 

Seriously though, if MR, a ballad, is smashing on the radio, I don't see Joanne not doing so. I mean I agree with DIC as the next one but I also would like to see Joanne being a single.

 

PS: not me talking about what the next single should be when I was saying stop awhile back RjIGLep.gif

Link to post
Share on other sites

Gaga Monster
Just now, Algorithm said:

lfrT5bQ.gif

 

Seriously though, if MR, a ballad, is smashing on the radio, I don't see Joanne not doing so, should it be released as a single. I mean I agree with DIC as the next one but I also would like to see Joanne being a single.

 

PS: not me talking about what the next single should be when I was saying stop awhile back RjIGLep.gif

She can't do too many ballads though, it just won't do well. Joanne is way too slow and takes too long to grow on someone. It is way too boring and wouldn't work well on Pop radio, DIC will smash if she does that for every radio station. After DIC end the era, focus on the tour and movie, come into the next era with a hit as your previous single and radio on your side and her career is back in good shape.

GGD Presidential Elections
Link to post
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, Algorithm said:

lfrT5bQ.gif

 

Seriously though, if MR, a ballad, is smashing on the radio, I don't see Joanne not doing so, should should they release it as a single. I mean I agree with DIC as the next one but I also would like to see Joanne being a single.

 

PS: not me talking about what the next single should be when I was saying stop awhile back RjIGLep.gif

I didn't help sis it's cool 

Link to post
Share on other sites

stir the pot
11 minutes ago, Gaga Monster said:

 It is way too boring and wouldn't work well on Pop radio

But MR did. and Joanne is not boring. :grr:

11 minutes ago, Gaga Monster said:

come into the next era with a hit as your previous single and radio on your side and her career is back in good shape.

her next era being a hit or not depends on the quality of the lead single she'll release tho.

 

Anyway, whatever her team's decision is, I would accept it. :hor:

Link to post
Share on other sites

emig09

It seems sharing the stations numbers from allaccess.com is the thing now :whitney:

gay engineer
Link to post
Share on other sites

nick4bty
20 minutes ago, Algorithm said:

lfrT5bQ.gif

 

Seriously though, if MR, a ballad, is smashing on the radio, I don't see Joanne not doing so. I mean I agree with DIC as the next one but I also would like to see Joanne being a single.

 

PS: not me talking about what the next single should be when I was saying stop awhile back RjIGLep.gif

Million Reasons is a relatable generic ballad. Joanne is too personal. I mean, sure, anyone who's had a loved one die can relate, but lyrically it isn't the same. 

Her team really needs to be more careful than ever in choosing the best third single. Hopefully they're doing a lot of testing and research to make sure they choose the right song, because radio could easily drop her again, and the next time will probably be for good

Link to post
Share on other sites

Bloody

From what I've understood, in the order of preference it goes:

1. DICers

2. A-YOers

3.Joanners 

:poot:

Link to post
Share on other sites

GagaOhhLaLa

I come back from school to see 5 pages on next single discussion . Ok uhmmm we can talk about that when we need too but right now MR is gaining quickly on radio so stream it.

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Admin locked this topic
  • Admin unlocked this topic
  • Haroon locked and unpinned this topic

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...