Jump to content
opinion

'Joanne' is Fading


DiscoHeaven23

Featured Posts

  • Replies 138
  • Created
  • Last Reply
Edonis
1 minute ago, GagainsiderNYC said:

Is not a bad album, is a mediocre album. And that's the T gaga-kiss.gif

Not really? It's actually a pretty good album and no where near mediocre. The shame is that it's a pretty slow era overall.

Link to post
Share on other sites

retrosexual123

Music is good. Very different from everything she has done before but a fitting evolution. However, with no hits on the album, or even the willingness to work a hit by Gaga herself, sales are low. 

Gaga needs a hit, whoever says otherwise is delusional. Maybe not a BR sizehit but more than what PI got... MR cant even be classed as a potential hit... because of the video, its views and the superbowl... mr is done. Pi was not a hit at all... ayo is all we have left...

Link to post
Share on other sites

Decodekid
12 minutes ago, GagainsiderNYC said:

Gurl for real? She might do 1 song from Joanne and that's about it. Is the greatest hit super bowl halftime show! 

still ! promo is promo gurl and she'll then proceed to announce the tour and second single so that can rise the sales a bit 

Long Live Gretchen
Link to post
Share on other sites

8 minutes ago, Skrill said:

I love Joanne.

I don't care about sales.

Bye.

You should care. 

Sales=money=more albums=Bigger shows=long career

Im sorry but no one can ever say they don't want the person they stan for doing well in charts and sales, popular with the GP and at the top.

That.is.the.T

Link to post
Share on other sites

Naor Daniel

So many people came at me.

I like Joanne but you need to be a fan to really love it. I only listen to PI, MR, DIC and John Wayne, most others feel like they never existed in her discography.

and still, even those I do like, do not feel natural. It's just not her and the music isn't as good.

how can you bring up so many excuses for her music not being successful anymore except for one thing - it's not good enough?

Gaga was super successful for a reason. Her music was game changing and AMAZING af. She's failing to restore that.

my worst nightmare is to be apathetic to Gaga. I just don't want it to happen. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Naor Daniel said:

So many people came for me.

I like Joanne but you need to be a fan to really love it. I only listen to PI, MR, DIC and John Wayne, most others feel like they never existed in her discography.

and still, even those I do like, do not feel natural. It's just not her and the music isn't as good.

how can you bring up so many excuses for her music not being successful anymore except for one thing - it's not good enough?

Gaga was super successful for a reason. Her music was game changing and AMAZING af. She's failing to restore that.

my worst nightmare is to be apathetic to Gaga. I just don't want it to happen. 

Exactly! All these kiss assers making excuses for bad music. Does my head in :reductive:

Link to post
Share on other sites

MessyTop
2 minutes ago, Naor Daniel said:

So many people came for me.

I like Joanne but you need to be a fan to really love it. I only listen to PI, MR, DIC and John Wayne, most others feel like they never existed in her discography.

and still, even those I do like, do not feel natural. It's just not her and the music isn't as good.

how can you bring up so many excuses for her music not being successful anymore except for one thing - it's not good enough?

Gaga was super successful for a reason. Her music was game changing and AMAZING af. She's failing to restore that.

my worst nightmare is to be apathetic to Gaga. I just don't want it to happen. 

Amen! I'm amazed by the insane excuses people make to convince themselves Joanne is good. Nobody likes it, is totally meh and forgettable. 

Good music rises to the top. Joanne was a risk that didn't pay off and faded. 

For crying out loud PI the comeback single for Gaga dissapered into oblivion we didn't even get remixes. 

Face reality. Joanne is done. 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Free My Mind
19 minutes ago, AKB48 said:

low_standards_by_nata_le-d5t9uh4.jpg

i don't have low standards. 

I think the album is a masterpiece, every detail of it seems to be calculated and on purpose, but yet so authentic at the same time. It has songs from the heart, it has lighthearted songs... it has everything I need for a gaga album. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

So 5 pages and I see there's a war happening but :kara:

 

 

so, the January sales are always bad darling! for everyone.

The people that are infront of Joanne, they all have a better streaming base. They have "hit singles" and that's the type of things that "BOOST" streams. Gaga is kinda stucked into the "digital selling era" but maybe she'll move into streams soon (or maybe or whatever). January sales are a mess yeah.

She has like no song playing on the radio, there's no promo rolling around RN... we need to wait

Link to post
Share on other sites

Free My Mind
8 minutes ago, GagainsiderNYC said:

Amen! I'm amazed by the insane excuses people make to convince themselves Joanne is good. Nobody likes it, is totally meh and forgettable. 

Good music rises to the top. Joanne was a risk that didn't pay off and faded. 

For crying out loud PI the comeback single for Gaga dissapered into oblivion we didn't even get remixes. 

Face reality. Joanne is done. 

 

how come when people don't like it they're allowed to because it's their opinion

but when people say they like it they're "making excuses"?

you don't like Joanne... okay.. the world must stop and gaga must instantly put out something you like.

don't be so selfish

Link to post
Share on other sites

Free My Mind

bookmark me, next album cycle will come and you'll all love this record.

same as ARTPOP.

same as Born This Way.

Link to post
Share on other sites

DeanWinchester
16 minutes ago, Naor Daniel said:

I like Joanne but you need to be a fan to really love it

or you can also be a fan of folk-rock-country-inspired music? :shrug:

Flyin' like a 1000 Doves
Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...