Jump to content
opinion

The Joanne Antithesis


Impostor

Featured Posts

DeanWinchester
1 hour ago, Gagadonna said:

Hum I dunno

Legit question btw. No shade intended. Im out of the WoW lore loop

Flyin' like a 1000 Doves
Link to post
Share on other sites

Squeeshy Keety

Why do there have to be so many threads trying to assess the quality of the era based on a single video (that I personally love)? I was relieved when the childish meltdowns ended, but I would have expected more faith in the future of the era by now :duck:

And, might I add, visuals do not have to be so flashy and in your face to be impactful. The AMA performance carries a strong message if you look past the lack of burning pianos in giant glass boxes.

Gaga might not please all her fans, but she is clearly trying to play with the subtleties of her art form. It may take time to refine the low profile visuals after a flying dress and being puked on for ARTPOP, but I believe in her ability to evolve in more ways than some of you (not necessarily the OP) give her credit for.

They / Them 🏳️‍🌈
Link to post
Share on other sites

It's easy for me, because I listen to all kinds of music. I actually discovered Lady Gaga quite recently (this summer). It's strange: I discovered her through her old music, which is the kind of pop music I once thought I would never become a fan of, and once I had become a fan, she released an album with a kind of music I have always listened to. :) Anyway, that's obviously not a problem for me, although I can see why some fans miss her old electronic dance-pop music. Especially younger fans, I imagine (I'm 43, so I suspect I'm older than most fans here).

Link to post
Share on other sites

dannydevito
2 minutes ago, Oivind said:

I'm 43, so I suspect I'm older than most fans here

im 72 and im both the oldest member here and the most iconic one

Link to post
Share on other sites

cryingrainbow

start a  change.org petition for maing john wayne the 3rd single and to buckle up the theatrics and slayage otherwise no one's gonna watch this year's superbowl. i'm mad at gaga, we're not fake fans, we care about her as an artist. 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

androiduser
4 hours ago, KleinKnight said:

Joanne is a good album, because it shows a lot of emotions, which contrasts with the other pop works nowadays (that are very shallow). If you look at the charts right now, you're going to see lots of stupid songs with stupid lyrics and bad vocals. And then you look at what Gaga is doing, and you love that, because it's real.

do we always have to put other artists down? It's really sad how fans need to bring other artists down and diminish their work just so they can claim that Gaga is better.

And when Gaga sings shallow sexy lyrics, then it's all amazing, and she's just having fun etc.

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Impostor
7 hours ago, androiduser said:

do we always have to put other artists down? It's really sad how fans need to bring other artists down and diminish their work just so they can claim that Gaga is better.

And when Gaga sings shallow sexy lyrics, then it's all amazing, and she's just having fun etc.

 

I'm talking about the songs with meaning,  though? I'm not really putting other artists down. Not even mentioned their names. It's just a statement.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Impostor
7 hours ago, Oivind said:

It's easy for me, because I listen to all kinds of music. I actually discovered Lady Gaga quite recently (this summer). It's strange: I discovered her through her old music, which is the kind of pop music I once thought I would never become a fan of, and once I had become a fan, she released an album with a kind of music I have always listened to. :) Anyway, that's obviously not a problem for me, although I can see why some fans miss her old electronic dance-pop music. Especially younger fans, I imagine (I'm 43, so I suspect I'm older than most fans here).

I'm 20 and I listen to all kinds of music too. It's not really the problem. As an old fan, what I miss is the huge figure she used to be, with all the fashion, theatrics and artistic performances. I don't really think she needs to go back to that, because she's changed during the last two years. Whether the fans need to like it or not, that's their problem. It's stupid when they say we are not real fans just because we don't agree with her direction :saladga:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...