Jump to content
opinion

Gaga needs a VIDEO EDITOR like Madonna's


Noah X

Featured Posts

narcoswing
2 hours ago, ZombieMirror said:

no she doesn't :awkney:

You have to accept she's not going on Madonna's path :excuseu:

Having a good editor doesn't equal going down Madonna's path.

But even if it would, Gaga should def go down that path. IJS :tea:

Link to post
Share on other sites

MaryJaneHolland
17 minutes ago, JoshieS said:

I've noticed a few threads and comments lately saying "why doesn't Gaga do this like Madonna" ...like no.

Gaga is Gaga
Madonna is Madonna

they're completely different. Lady Gaga makes her music, they're HER songs.

Madonna makes her music, they're HER songs.

People need to realise not everyone is the same, not everyone needs the same promo/marketing/videos etc. 

you missed the point boo

this is not about music, this is about editing :laughga:

basically the OP didnt compare LG and M, they compared their editors 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Joshie S
Just now, MaryJaneHolland said:

you missed the point boo

this is not about music, this is about editing :laughga:

basically the OP didnt compare LG and M, they compared their editors 

no i completely got the point, i just pointed out the music also, how they always get compared each and every step of the way, was just a broad way to put it.

The melody that you choose can rescue you ♥
Link to post
Share on other sites

52 minutes ago, MaryJaneHolland said:

and a choreographer like madonna's :awkney:

sorry richie, you can stay, but only as a dancer :gum:

OT: lots of cuts is stupid :oprah: i mean.... look at the PI video :oprah: plus, this is only a trailer, the tour wont be edited this way

I still can't watch the Iconic choreography :madge:

The night sky tells all
Link to post
Share on other sites

MaryJaneHolland
Just now, Prince Bananas said:

I still can't watch the Iconic choreography :madge:

1 messy choreography is nothing.....

look at Richie tho, his choreos seem to be repetitive :awkney: i'm so scared for the half time show :awkney:

Link to post
Share on other sites

MadeInManu
3 hours ago, Kenon Sings said:

there are over 1000 cuts in under 2 minutes

Perfect Illusion music video says hi :laughga:

Link to post
Share on other sites

PopBitch
4 hours ago, Delusional Aura said:

Sh!t...the production of her tours are always flawless :madge:. I really wished I had gone to the Rebel Heart tour :cryga:

I don't like Madonna much anymore in some of her offstage desperation antics, but Madonna on stage on tour, I was so there for her.  The Rebel Heart tour was emotional for me.  Madonna and the show were amazing.

Link to post
Share on other sites

ZombieMirror
3 hours ago, narcoswing said:

Having a good editor doesn't equal going down Madonna's path.

But even if it would, Gaga should def go down that path. IJS :tea:

nope she shouldn't ,she must do what she wants, she was already there done that, time for next thing she is much more talented to stay only on the POP scene and become what ?! a cliche of the industry TKS better not :staymad: 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Oriane

I highly doubt it's the same editor everytime...

The only GGD member who can read / Credits to Celloo Deng for the profile pic!
Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm an aspiring film editor and I can tell you this is FAR too many cuts. There should be a few long takes here and there to break it up a bit...you can hardly take anything in otherwise.

Side note: Hi Gags, hire me as an editor please

Link to post
Share on other sites

Economy

Dont u know she dont hire professionals to help her anymore?

 

Hence her falling behind in promo, taking forever to release videos and the drop in video quality (perfect illusion) :air: 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Tons of cuts in performances  are never a good thing. It shows an illusion that the performance is better than it actually is. The technique is usually done on performers who can't hold choreography or sing great. Britney Spears is infamous at this editing too. Looks like she's really breaking it down with choreography on video but it's just a bunch of cuts jumping from one to the next that it gives more of an electrifying effect than the actual performance itself.  It's definitely great editing but I think gaga is about showing that she can actually perform throughly and in full.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...