Jump to content
review

Anthony Fantano (theneedledrop) reviews Joanne


kevinthesheep

Featured Posts

Azor Ahai
56 minutes ago, LilARTPOP said:

Does anyone else find him hot? Or are those my low standards speaking? 

Praying he gives Joanne at least a 6. Anything below would kill me:giveup:

Um he's bald . He looks like an Uncle. Are you into that? :sis:

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Replies 64
  • Created
  • Last Reply
LilARTPOP
1 minute ago, Azor Ahai said:

Um he's bald . He looks like an Uncle. Are you into that? :sis:

I could be............. :toofunny:

Ask Jesus Christ who the 5 star chick is
Link to post
Share on other sites

high heeled fem
2 hours ago, Leaf said:

It means more than MC.

Really wasn't impressed with his review of the last Angel Olsen record which was a masterpiece 

yet he loves the new one .??? Also he gave new pj not High enough 

he can be weird hit and miss at times 

Link to post
Share on other sites

GagaLover1928
11 minutes ago, high heeled fem said:

Really wasn't impressed with his review of the last Angel Olsen record which was a masterpiece 

yet he loves the new one .??? Also he gave new pj not High enough 

he can be weird hit and miss at times 

It's almost as if people have different opinions on music :huh:

Link to post
Share on other sites

monsterdino
2 hours ago, Britney Spears said:

Looks like you don't know him :p . Anthony would only give 8 to an album that he finds FLAWLESS. He really liked ARTPOP and he gave it 6.He thought it was her best album. Born This Way got 5? or something. Everything above 6 is GREAT

I watch every one of his reviews (the albums I listened to or about to listen) I said that I'm expecting 8 bc I have a feeling that he'll gave it an 8 :sweat:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Nicogly
40 minutes ago, monsterdino said:

I watch every one of his reviews (the albums I listened to or about to listen) I said that I'm expecting 8 bc I have a feeling that he'll gave it an 8 :sweat:

I feel its going to be a 7.  Has he ever given an album 10?

Rock On and A Last One For the Road 🚬
Link to post
Share on other sites

monsterdino
3 minutes ago, Nicogly said:

I feel its going to be a 7.  Has he ever given an album 10?

Yup, To Pimp A Butterfly by Kendrick Lamar

Link to post
Share on other sites

NIghtmareElm
Just now, DeathEater said:

 

If it's already been posted please merge or delete.  

Same rating as he gave ARTPOP.  I disagree with him though.  The album wouldn't of done so well if she went full on country/folk.  The album works so well with hints of country and folk while keeping her style of pop.

Link to post
Share on other sites

FATCAT

I agree with him. He brought some of my own deeper thoughts regarding the album to the surface.

This kitten over here (meow)
Link to post
Share on other sites

Versace
21 minutes ago, DeathEater said:

 

His comment on Angel Down "For a Gaga song it's pretty heavy, it's pretty serious...It's gonna be interesting seeing how Gaga fans take it, her going into that direction"

It seems like he hasn't heard Speechless, Dope or Til It Happens To You 

Does he think us Gaga fans only appreciate songs like Just Dance and Bad Romance, pffft, this guy is coming off as pretentious tbh.

His review overall: He thinks it's a meh/ok album and that Gaga doesn't go all the way but that what she was trying to achieve is appreciated. He seems like the type who listens to a Gaga album once and think she has nothing to offer besides Poker Face and Bad Romance as a fixated notion. Also it's like it irks him that Joanne is sonically inspired by icons like Elton, Bowie, Ace Of Base as if it's bad thing or he's expecting 100% originality sonically in 2016. What's more pathetic he compared Joanne to a more daring Meghan Trainor album shying away from becoming an Amy Winehouse record, or at least that's what I got lol. 

The only criticism against Joanne I can understand is from personal reasons, the music isn't someone's cup of tea, they think it's outdated, too simple, not trendy enough, not pop enough, fine but these critics should shove it, this is her best album musically/lyrically and vocally. This a good album by all good album means. Come for ARTPOP fine, heck even come for her previous work fine but don't come for Joanne from a musical stand point, it really looks bad. Is Joanne more Iconic and infectious than let's say The Fame and The Fame Monster, no but after 10 years they are gonna sound outdated by everyone's standard, which let me tell you they already are starting to. Joanne is a classic that will be in every music lover's collection, 10 years from now.

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

arthurhmangum

I don’t care what anyone says, but Joanne is what I needed at this point in my life, and it's a great album. Bye. 

mZjnCQX.gif

 

 

Stressed, depressed, but well dressed.
Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...