Closed: Chart Discussion: Joanne / Million Reasons

[Edge Of Venus 731]

55 minutes ago, NickARTPOP said:

She did much more that that in the end, that was just initial problems. She pretty much only sells to fans and concert-goers at this point.

Not true. Tour bundles only count in the first month and is limited to the US only. And Rebel Heart sold like 20 copies in the US in its 3rd-4th weeks. I'm a huge fan of Madge AND Gaga so I follow both very closely. 

47 minutes ago, BloodyMonster said:

DW is at 900k WW though

Ariana has a smash hit at the moment and the album is still shifting 10k+ every week. It will comfortably cross 1.2M in the end. Imagine if Joanne has a hit single! It can do 2M easily with Gaga's album selling power. Bobby better get his **** together with A-YO to launch SB and the tour.

[HeyMrDJ 62]

1 minute ago, Coop said:

You sure?

Yes. 

[YeehawKylie 7,817]

1 hour ago, GloZell Green said:

Yes but her team hasn't requested the certification plaque (they need to buy it) from RIAA. It has been platinum for quite some time.

Just knowing it technically is, is all I need. Though I'd love for her to have a plaque...

Never saw the entire sales, just pure sales....

[OBEY 57,109]

On 2016-11-22 at 11:55 AM, Matteo Remondi said:

I don't get why you all get so rude if someone says something you don't like. It's a fact that it's getting very low views,  accept that

Its her and her team's fault. She left too long and now she's "back" but not really "back"  

[ZiggyZiggs 30,063]

We all know MR wasn't going to be HUGE. Maybe just maybe a top 10 or top 15 . But A-YO is a certified No.1 record, but all u hunties wanted MR

Ballads don't usually smash on the charts unless your name is Adele

[Americano 31,061]

33 minutes ago, ZiggyZiggs said:

We all know MR wasn't going to be HUGE. Maybe just maybe a top 10 or top 15 . But A-YO is a certified No.1 record, but all u hunties wanted MR

Ballads don't usually smash on the charts unless your name is Adele

AYO is as much of a smash as GUY 

[Americano 31,061]

It's sad to think Slumber Party will have a much better video than MR if we are gonna be realistic. Every time Gaga is quiet about a MV, it ends up being bad, and she's barely noted MRs existence.. If it exists.

DWUW teas with the video coming way too late now and the promotion just being butchered by Bobby. He couldn't get a hit if his life depended on it.

[Americano 31,061]

And not to pile on, but Tony Bennett was able to get a song higher on Hot Tracks than MR this week. That says about enough lol

[Robo Ga 15,314]

6 minutes ago, Americano said:

And not to pile on, but Tony Bennett was able to get a song higher on Hot Tracks than MR this week. That says about enough lol

My faith in Joanne's charting power is officially shook.

I have a million reasons to walk away and zero to stay.

[ZiggyZiggs 30,063]

43 minutes ago, Americano said:

AYO is as much of a smash as GUY 

I honestly think if all that management ruckus didn't happen, ARTPOP would've been a HUGE record. and GUY would've smashed. It is defo a hit that got away. The reason y it didnt smash is cuz most people don't even know it exists. But when they hear it they're like wow this is a bop who is this?

[Bye 3,947]

5 minutes ago, ZiggyZiggs said:

I honestly think if all that management ruckus didn't happen, ARTPOP would've been a HUGE record. and GUY would've smashed. It is defo a hit that got away. The reason y it didnt smash is cuz most people don't even know it exists. But when they hear it they're like wow this is a bop who is this?

GUY is her worst single... Too loud and aggressive. Not surprised it tanked. And a horrible chorus. 

Let's not pretend it's MR's fault it is flopping. It's a great song which responds well to promo and the public like it. Radio has ruined its potential, that much is obvious. I don't think we can blame Gaga or Bobby for the radio snub. 

[ZiggyZiggs 30,063]

31 minutes ago, Biotic said:

GUY is her worst single... Too loud and aggressive. Not surprised it tanked. And a horrible chorus. 

Let's not pretend it's MR's fault it is flopping. It's a great song which responds well to promo and the public like it. Radio has ruined its potential, that much is obvious. I don't think we can blame Gaga or Bobby for the radio snub. 

Your opinion, i dont agree

MR was never going to SMASH. A top 10 maybe ,a top 20 sure. But smash like A-YO not at all.

And stop saying radio is snubbing. We can't be sure yet. STS was released as a single in June, video in July with huge promo. And radio only started to really pick it up a month ago.

[Gypsy Life 118,907]

8. Joanne (+1)

[ViviLittleM 3]

Australia

50 (29) 5 Joanne

[GagaMyBlood95 9,915]

I am almost POSITIVE that MR would have become a hit if they played their cards right. Seriously, and they even didn't have to do so many things for it. I know Bobby is following the charts, so I don't understand why doesn't he react when he sees that Gaga's highest charting song isn't anywhere to be found on Spotify and is falling everywhere without a video out.