Does Gaga need more "edit" with the songs?

[boysboysboys 278]

Do you think Gaga needs to scale down music-wise?

I was thinking this as I was listening to almost all the Joanne songs and I think, not only should there be more production but I think she should scale down on the lyrics, they're borderline un-singable and too wordy. It's almost like long poetry. 

[2020Covid19IsOurs 6,901]

1 minute ago, boysboysboys said:

It's almost like long poetry

But I love PoetGa

[KarmaPolice 4,731]

2 minutes ago, boysboysboys said:

Do you think Gaga needs to scale down music-wise?

I was thinking this as I was listening to almost all the Joanne songs and I think, not only should there be more production but I think she should scale down on the lyrics, they're borderline un-singable and too wordy. It's almost like long poetry. 

No no no no no hell no. For once I'm happy that she's writing poems instead of the usual verses. It feels that finally she has something to say...that's a sign of growing artistically

[Clip 5,100]

1 minute ago, boysboysboys said:

Do you think Gaga needs to scale down music-wise?

I was thinking this as I was listening to almost all the Joanne songs and I think, not only should there be more production but I think she should scale down on the lyrics, they're borderline un-singable and too wordy. It's almost like long poetry. 

Are they??

OT: A little of voice effects won't be a bad idea. Anyways we have't heard the songs with good quality and voices usually sound MUCH worse on poor quality recordings. I remember when I heard the PI leak, I thought her vocals were horrible but then the song came out and they sounded good

[xoxo cupcakke 4,781]

Music is poetry, poetry can be N-E-THING;

thus, music can be N-E-THING 

[Clip 5,100]

1 minute ago, Tommi said:

No no no no no hell no. For once I'm happy that she's writing poems instead of the usual verses. That's a sign of growing artistically

Oh yess me too

I'm tired of 

Swine

Swine

Swine

Swine

Paint your face and

Paint your face and 

and that sort of songs

[Raulkul 56]

Well, that's Gaga!   And I think the lyrics on Joanne is better than on ARTPOP 

[Sylvanas 5,768]

"Should Gaga compromise her artistry in order to appeal to a mass-pop market"

[boysboysboys 278]

4 minutes ago, Sylvanas said:

"Should Gaga compromise her artistry in order to appeal to a mass-pop market"

That's not what this means though. 

[SS77 2,000]

8 minutes ago, boysboysboys said:

Do you think Gaga needs to scale down music-wise?

I was thinking this as I was listening to almost all the Joanne songs and I think, not only should there be more production but I think she should scale down on the lyrics, they're borderline un-singable and too wordy. It's almost like long poetry. 

That's the best part about Joanne so far. 

Gaga's weakpoint in many of her pop songs are her lyrics. Lyrics are supposed to be poetic, to tell a story or convey an idea in a beautiful way. 

But in most of her past songs, they're the exact opposite. I always criticized her for often writing in short (sometimes unrelated) phrases, rather than in flowing poetic statements. 

With Joanne, it seems like she's finally writing like the latter, and I couldn't be more excited 

[Blackout19 11,728]

They need just to be more POP

[The Child 18,997]

Where have you all heard Joanne when it's only out on October 21st? 

[Clip 5,100]

14 minutes ago, CrazyMonster said:

Where have you all heard Joanne when it's only out on October 21st? 

I mean we've heard the 30 seconds long snippets but no one has heard the whole album

[The Child 18,997]

3 minutes ago, Clip said:

I mean we've heard the 30 seconds long snippets but no one has heard the whole album

Then why is everybody already making their opinion about the album, can't they just wait till October 21st?

[Bazaar 5,752]

How can you judge by a 30 seconds snippet? I really don't get that