Does the fact that PI is described as rock scare anyone else?

[BenG 19,908]

1 minute ago, Enigma said:

Except she loved rock since before she was famous.

she's been singing rock since she was 13

[Quark 7,098]

Just now, gagzus said:

loving rock doesn't mean she can make it, we all love musicians and not one of us can sing (not even the fans who apparently 'can' are good nn)

Your analogy doesn't even makes sense. Plus by now you should know that Gaga fits perfectly in the rock genre.

[gagzus 15,829]

Just now, Benji said:

I personally think she's not conforming with this direction, if she was, I'd expect another ARTPOP

If she made another ARTPOP i'd probably be hyped since it's my favourite album from her but yes she is conforming because as i said in my other posts, everyone has told her to do rock music and criticised her for making dance music when she apparently has the soul of a rocker on tour.
She's legit doing what people want her to.

[gagzus 15,829]

Just now, Enigma said:

Your analogy doesn't even makes sense. Plus by now you should know that Gaga fits perfectly in the rock genre.

she doesn't because she can't sing it  y'all need to get out of this state thinking that she's amazing when she's not, she's talented yes but not better than anyone else d. She ain't beyonce.

[Pacify Him 9,073]

I think what will scare everybody is if she moves to the metal genre and get those vocals out screaming 

[Quark 7,098]

Just now, gagzus said:

she doesn't because she can't sing it  y'all need to get out of this state thinking that she's amazing when she's not, she's talented yes but not better than anyone else d. She ain't beyonce.

Your delusional if you think she can't sing rock . Plus why did you have to bring Beyonce into this. Gaga is more talented than Beyonce anyways. Beyonce can only sing and dance. Gaga can do much more than that.

[Benji 20,113]

8 minutes ago, gagzus said:

Lol she's LEGIT been told by fans, critics and her idols to make rock music because they find her old music inauthentic and instead of making music that's fun she took the serious route. She just can't stand the fact she lost all her amazing hype and overrated praise so she's trying to get it back. That's probably why i loved ARTPOP as an album because it was fun, authentic, her peak of musicianship on an album and it pissed off the hipster critics and idiot fans. She needs her old attitude but with ARTPOP's intensity not some "i'm trying to be a legend" ****

She's been told that countless times because she's completely wasted on pop. She's tried to make Poker Face over and over again with Bad Romance, Judas, Scheisse and Venus. Popga was stuck in a rut of trying to make a popular hit but rock and indie let's her actually experiment and make what she wants.

Compare rock / indie artists to pop... there's so much more diversity in sound and direction.

--------

She can still make pop driven rock music as well, which I imagine she's doing.

 

[gagzus 15,829]

Just now, Enigma said:

Your delusional if you think she can't sing rock . Plus why did you have to bring Beyonce into this. Gaga is more talented than Beyonce anyways. Beyonce can only sing and dance. Gaga can do much more than that.

lol let's not Beyonce may be overrated but she's definitely better than Gaga point blank. And I'll say it again for you deaf *******s;

she can't sing rock.

[Lurk 410]

If anything, it excites me ? 

 

Totally here for for a rock era- let's be honest she's always been a bit of a rock chic at heart

[gagzus 15,829]

Just now, Benji said:

She's been told that countless times because she's completely wasted on pop. She's tried to make Poker Face over and over again with Bad Romance, Judas, Scheisse and Venus. Popga was stuck in a rut of trying to make a popular hit but rock and indie let's her actually experiment and make what she wants.

Compare rock / indie artists to pop... there's so much more diversity in sound and direction.

rock and indie bores me to tears and their fans overrate and criticise other genres (especially pop) and although our fanbase does that anyway I'm not here for more ego from her or them at all. She's just scared of being a ****ing flop still that's why she's trying too hard tbh.

[HausOfNicole 177]

2 minutes ago, gagzus said:

Lol she's LEGIT been told by fans, critics and her idols to make rock music because they find her old music inauthentic and instead of making music that's fun she took the serious route. She just can't stand the fact she lost all her amazing hype and overrated praise so she's trying to get it back. That's probably why i loved ARTPOP as an album because it was fun, authentic, her peak of musicianship on an album and it pissed off the hipster critics and idiot fans. She needs her old attitude but with ARTPOP's intensity not some "i'm trying to be a legend" ****

People have been telling her that, because it's what she's been embodying all these years. Everything about her literally stems from Glam Rock of the 70s. ARTPOP I agree was fun, but it was messy and disconnected. Had she not been trying to please critics and fans that album would've been a lot better. To say it's her peak musicianship is highly subjective, honestly I would flat out say untrue.

It's not about trying to be a legend, it's about making music rather than forced hits. Doesn't mean the new music won't be fun, but it won't be vapid and soulless; if you want that go buy Glory on iTunes. I did. 

[yxi 4,999]

From the descriptions it won't be pure rock, more like dance-rock

[Quark 7,098]

4 minutes ago, gagzus said:

lol let's not Beyonce may be overrated but she's definitely better than Gaga point blank. And I'll say it again for you deaf *******s;

she can't sing rock.

That is called YOUR opinion. Beyonce can't write and play any instruments for ****. Plus:

 

[Harry 26,836]

Not in the slightest. I would be shocked if she went full on rock anyway, especially for the lead single. Their goal is still ultimately commercial success so they wouldn't jeopardize possibly the entire era with an opening that has no commercial value.

But aside from all that stuff I'd be here for it, actually. I want her to continue evolving. ARTPOP felt like a step backwards. I'd love her to explore other influences and I'm a fan of rock music... So if that's where she's going, then so be it.

[Miel 15,009]

No. I'm a lil classic rock hoe because of my father, so I'm down.