What's the obsession with Mark Ronson?

[ARTGOD 3,266]

Y'all give Gaga too little credit, like RedOne was the reason for her success, like she needs to be tied to him forever to keep making good music, like she can't experiment and work with anyone she wants in HER album .

[luckythisway 2,602]

1 minute ago, Harry said:

You honestly believe that out of the thousands of producers Gaga can have access to, he's the only one she can create magic with?

Y'all need to give her more credit, honestly.

Personally, out of those thousand producers, I think she can make the most magic with Max Martin.

Out of all the producers she's worked with, RedOne has made the best songs with her. This is a fact. Second is Garibay, and she likes to forget his existence too. Anyway, that's another meltdown. I'm just going by what Gaga has already done. Not what she "could make," what she "has made." 

I love Back to Black (the whole album) but I like The Fame Monster better!

Finally, again out of the thousand producers, Tame Impala excites me. Same Ol Mistakes is the best song on Anti, so I know she can make some magic. But she has a long way to go if she wants to top Bad Romace. 

[MaryJaneHolland 77,348]

24 minutes ago, Phoenix said:

it's a joke you pressed slut

[luckythisway 2,602]

2 minutes ago, Jed said:

Actually if you read his interview he says he hasn't heard art pops gypsy and then she went another direction with it with different producers. So his version of gypsy wasn't even good enough to make ARTPOP, doesn't really help your case.

I don't think it's a coincidence that the best song on AP originated from RedOne. And I'm sure it was better than the final version, but Gaga enjoys changing things too much & ultimately makes them worse.

[Harry 26,836]

2 minutes ago, luckythisway said:

Personally, out of those thousand producers, I think she can make the most magic with Max Martin.

Out of all the producers she's worked with, RedOne has made the best songs with her. This is a fact. Second is Garibay, and she likes to forget his existence too. Anyway, that's another meltdown. I'm just going by what Gaga has already done. Not what she "could make," what she "has made." 

I love Back to Black (the whole album) but I like The Fame Monster better!

Finally, again out of the thousand producers, Tame Impala excites me. Same Ol Mistakes is the best song on Anti, so I know she can make some magic. But she has a long way to go if she wants to top Bad Romace. 

No it's not... That's the definition of an opinion. Most successful? Yes. Best? No definitive answer.

[Jed 7,716]

1 minute ago, luckythisway said:

I don't think it's a coincidence that the best song on AP originated from RedOne. And I'm sure it was better than the final version, but Gaga enjoys changing things too much & ultimately makes them worse.

Uh DWUW was well received by a lot of people that weren't even monsters. You aren't the be all end all decider of what is quality and what isn't, especially when I'm sure you're not familiar with Marks music with Gaga

[NewYorkCity 10,515]

52 minutes ago, Creyk said:

IKR it's a mystery to me

He can't produce a good song to save his life

Don't come at me with Back to Black because that album was whack, I listened because people on here praised it and it was such a bore

yeah, because without Gaga RedOne produces magic. Oh wait... no, he doesn't. 

[Mister Gaga 22,035]

4 hours ago, Phoenix said:

he looks good i guess

 

he doesn't 

[petty 9,412]

it's the people like you who will make LG5 fail. her own fanbase has no faith in the work she's doing. going into it w/ that mindset, you're bound to be disappointed.

 

[Guille 839]

14 hours ago, ARTGOD said:

Y'all give Gaga too little credit, like RedOne was the reason for her success, like she needs to be tied to him forever to keep making good music, like she can't experiment and work with anyone she wants in HER album .

We give her credit, we let her experiment, whatever you want - but look at ARTPOP.  I think no other comments are needed

13 hours ago, NewYorkCity said:

yeah, because without Gaga RedOne produces magic. Oh wait... no, he doesn't. 

RedOne produces crap without Gaga, but with her he makes magic. What's the deal?

[NewYorkCity 10,515]

7 minutes ago, Guille said:

We give her credit, we let her experiment, whatever you want - but look at ARTPOP.  I think no other comments are needed

RedOne produces crap without Gaga, but with her he makes magic. What's the deal?

the deal is that you haven't listened to what Mark Ronson can do with her, so all the meltdowns are unnecessary.

[Guille 839]

Just now, NewYorkCity said:

the deal is that you haven't listened to what Mark Ronson can do with her, so all the meltdowns are unnecessary.

Have you read the OP? 

I don't like his footprint, sound, essence, trademark at all

[NewYorkCity 10,515]

1 minute ago, Guille said:

Have you read the OP? 

I don't like his footprint, sound, essence, trademark at all

Again, and you like the sound and essence of what RedOne does without Gaga? Because it is pure trash.

[Jenniferella 2,774]

14 minutes ago, Guille said:

We give her credit, we let her experiment, whatever you want - but look at ARTPOP.  I think no other comments are needed

Are you implying ARTPOP is experimental ? Because it's not. At all.

[AJH219 4,448]

Because most of us don't have basic taste in music and want to hear Gaga's sound evolve. She can't do that running back to her old producers. Get the hell out of 2009, ffs.