If Gaga's new song/video isn't good, would you still hope for it's success?

[RadioIsOurs 13,876]

Just now, Drunk Poet said:

I'm confused about your statement and the options you give. 

The higher a song charts, it's not as if it's artistic integrity increases too. I don't know how many times I have to say that commercial success does not = artistic merit. And the more you insist this blatant lie, the more you're giving cringeworthy and overrated credit to the formulaic regurgitated bubblegum trend-following repetitive morally reprehensible migrane-inducing intellectually deficient garbage. This is the poison in pop culture.  

I am being partially sarcastic 

[HighlandHeart 993]

9 minutes ago, RainbowBlonde said:

I am being partially sarcastic 

And that's always the reply I hear. Funny that. Slightly sad, really. And that's not shade or meant for offence, that's my genuine opinion.  

Please don't insult my intelligence and expect I'll fall for that. You requested that people be objective. Where is the sarcasm in that?

[Bradley 59,031]

The thing is will it suck in the first place?

I don't think Work is a great song but I enjoy it in its way, also Desiigner just got a #1 song for a tragic song so I think she deserves the #1 spot too, I don't think she'll make something worse than Panda.

[RadioIsOurs 13,876]

20 minutes ago, Drunk Poet said:

And that's always the reply I hear. Funny that. Slightly sad, really. And that's not shade or meant for offence, that's my genuine opinion.  

Please don't insult my intelligence and expect I'll fall for that. You requested that people be objective. Where is the sarcasm in that?

I really do hope you find more joy in life and be less uptight about everything... 

[HighlandHeart 993]

6 minutes ago, RainbowBlonde said:

I really do hope you find more joy in life and be less uptight about everything... 

Hahaha funny how I hear that a lot in replace of valid arguments too. Patronise me all you want dear, I love my life and I feel great. God forbid you criticise incorrect logic or you're suddenly an uptight manic depressive. Nice try, but if you're going to present fallacies, expect them to be criticised, even by the happiest of people. It's called taking something seriously, as in sincerely, as in earnestly, instead of flippantly. In no way am I going to collude with a blatant lie. Your attempt to cast me as uptight because of that is truly sad, and only further reinforces that you're wrong. Like I said before, don't insult my intelligence. 

[RadioIsOurs 13,876]

2 minutes ago, Drunk Poet said:

Hahaha funny how I hear that a lot in replace of valid arguments too. Patronise me all you want dear, I love my life and I feel great. God forbid you criticise incorrect logic or you're suddenly an uptight manic depressive. Nice try dear, but if you're going to present fallacies, expect them to be criticised, even by the happiest of people. It's called taking something seriously, as in sincerely, as in earnestly, instead of flippantly. In no way am I going to collude with a blatant lie. Your attempt to cast me as uptight because of that is truly sad, and only further reinforces that you're wrong. Like I said before, don't insult my intelligence. 

Wow. You are so hell bent on putting down others aren't you? Who do you think you are? You act like your 'intelligence' is so precious. Talking to you was such a pleasure indeed...

[My Little Phoney 658]

I do not care about sales at all, I want her to make good, progressive music that she stands behind.

[HighlandHeart 993]

Just now, RainbowBlonde said:

Wow. You are so hell bent on putting down others aren't you? Who do you think you are? You act like your 'intelligence' is so precious. Talking to you was such a pleasure indeed...

And now you're playing the victim. Wow. I don't put anyone down, who do you think you are, daring to accuse me of it? You put out a lie, I criticised it. You're clearly hypersensitive to any kind of criticism and are one to shout 'bully!' when it comes to you. I don't think my intelligence is any more precious than the next person's, certainly. But the fact that you put out a lie and not only expect zero criticism for it, but start playing the victim when you're met with some, yes, that is insulting people's intelligence. That's a simple fact. 

I criticised it, giving you an opportunity to argue your case. Instead you lied again and said you were being sarcastic to wriggle out of it. And you think I'm putting you down? Please. 

[RadioIsOurs 13,876]

Just now, Drunk Poet said:

And now you're playing the victim. Wow. I don't put anyone down, who do you think you are, daring to accuse me of it? You put out a lie, I criticised it. You're clearly hypersensitive to any kind of criticism and are one to shout 'bully!' when it comes to you. I don't think my intelligence is any more precious than the next person's, certainly. But the fact that you put out a lie and not only expect zero criticism for it, but start playing the victim when you're met with some, yes, that is insulting people's intelligence. That's a simple fact. 

I criticised it, giving you an opportunity to argue your case. Instead you lied again and said you were being sarcastic to wriggle out of it. And you think I'm putting you down? Please. 

Please, I'm really tired. I don't want to argue. Don't make this a battle of egos. All I know is, you are seriously being so uptight to the point where people around you just can't feel happy at all. All I wish is that you let go of that ego and let loose. Good day.

[jezze0410 393]

Many songs that top the charts/are "successful" by some measure are horrible... any song by Gaga, however unpleasant it may be, still features her, and as such will still be an improvement. That woman can sing a transcribed episode of KUWTK to the tune of the leek spinning song and make it sound bearable. 

[heavymetall0v3r 910]

This one time i was at a party and I had the aux cord, and I put J&D on and all the straight boys were going "Man Lady Gaga is actually really cool!!!!!" Then I played G.U.Y

and well

 

EDIT: I only put it on for the social experiement about J&D's impact on straights

[mikedu24 706]

Are we all pretending to forget how many weeks work spent on the chart. And to think Rhi hyped flopti like it was some Life changing event. All those event cancellations starting from October last year and at the end we got WORK.

[Addison Rae 16,639]

Of course everyone wants their favourite artist to be successful. I want Gaga to be successful and have her best interest at heart.  It's not just about the music to me, it's more about her as a person.

And I will still be standing by her side no matter what her chart position says.

[Impostor 4,114]

I'm not a hardcore bitch fan and I think Gaga will only have a new hit if she deserves it (by making good music). So no, I won't be here for her if the song isn't good. But I would still hope good stuff later in the album.

In the other hand, I think only the fact that a song is written/sung by Gaga makes it good (most of the time) 

[Addison Rae 16,639]

6 minutes ago, heavymetall0v3r said:

This one time i was at a party and I had the aux cord, and I put J&D on and all the straight boys were going "Man Lady Gaga is actually really cool!!!!!" Then I played G.U.Y

and well

 

EDIT: I only put it on for the social experiement about J&D's impact on straights

NNN they kicked you out when G.U.Y started playing???