Why do people think RedOne was scrapped from LG5?

[giskardsb 12,565]

13 minutes ago, Haroon said:

Why do you think she doesn't?

I don't, but we keep hearing some people say that Gaga "knows" what fans want and is doing that. But fans have different opinions and we have no idea what her plans are. There is alot of wishful thinking and projection going on. 

[AlexanderLevi2 5,849]

I just want something completely different to her formula. I hope it just blows my mind... And I'm sure she will deliver.

[migamiga 12,102]

I agree- monsters always jump to conclusions. What else is new. 

Just a slight correction though, she didn't hire redone. It's not a work-for-hire situation. A session for writers is more like a collaborative meeting 

[XoXoJoanneGaga 629]

3 hours ago, ChasingGhosts said:

Well RedOne produced songs for AP, but in the end he only co-wrote one song. Knowing her she's changed the sound and style of LG5 fifty times in the past week. Personally, I would rather have more Mark Ronson and less ReDone.

He actually only sent her reference beats for AP, they were never in the same room even. Given that they had tons of sessions in 2015 both at the start and end of the year I'd say he's the second most likely producer to make the album behind Mark of course, but we don't know much.

At the very least I assume he'll have a number of writing credits, which would probably be the strongest thing he could contribute to the record. On the production front, the more new blood the better.

 

[monketsharona 81,676]

I don't think he has been scrapped from LG5. She has worked with him for more than a year. They recorded like +40 songs together for LG5. I don't think Gaga will scrap more than a year of work with RedOne (and other producers) because Ronson is there. Though I could see Ronson reworking some demos already done.

And honestly I'm not here for getting a Mark Ronson album. I want LG5 as a Gaga album with several producers, with different visions on it. Like she did on her previous albums. 

 

[StarstruckIllusion 52,790]

7 hours ago, giskardsb said:

why do you think Gaga actually cares that SOME of her fans want a TF/M repeat?

*readies up the receipt printer*

http://popcrush.com/lady-gaga-bad-romance-interview/

 

[Noam Zioni 1,196]

You're right 

they could meet without notifying us

[Chelseaaaaaa 1,453]

The denial is real.

[Illuminati 15,922]

Remember when gaga first started posting photos of her and Redone in the studio after she ended ARTPOP era and everyone was like "yas daddy redone is here to produce huge hits, tfm era is upon us"  and everyone was hyped. now it's like 50/50 everyone switched to Ronson because he had a couple of huge hits with other artists. We don't really know what will come out of their collaboration with Gaga though. I'd say just be happy, try for once regardless of who she works with. Idk judge the collaborations afterwards, when you get to hear the material she puts out. 

[Decodekid 28,268]

LG5 has been in the making process since 2014, so at the begining we used to see many pics and info about RedOne, two years later now we got Mark Ronson by Gaga's side 24/7 which seems as she is so inspired by him she gave up the whole LG5 concept and started again, that's why is taking so long i think.

And we've seen that also her style has changed, back when she was with RedOne we used to see normal guitars on the studio now we see electric guitars and this rock funk punk persona.

[Solitaire 902]

Wasn't there a member here that did a tarot reading for Gaga in 2016 and he/she predicted that there would be RedOne sessions but that they wouldn't make it onto the album? 👀

I think their name was Tokyo Rose or something like that??

[giskardsb 12,565]

12 hours ago, ROARyals said:

*readies up the receipt printer*

 

http://popcrush.com/lady-gaga-bad-romance-interview/

 

 

it's a far reach from the quote below to assuming that she is trying to make fans happy with another Bad Romance on LG5.  In fact the way I read that quote I don't think she's exactly complimenting the fans that just want "sweet, delightful, or perfect" pop songs.

 

“I have actually found a place to put so much pain and anguish that I have nowhere to put,” she said. “You can put it in your music but that’s not always what people want from me in my music. They want a sweet, delightful, ‘Just Dance’ kind of girl or they want ‘Bad Romance’ and that’s fine.”

“I am happy to give people that, but maybe with my song ‘Dope’ or some of the things I did on ARTPOP, you saw a kind of dark side, wrapped up in colors,” she continued. “But maybe that was not always what people want to see. They want to see the perfection. Here [on AHS], it’s the imperfection that is the win. So it’s very liberating.”

Read More: Lady Gaga Loves 'Bad Romance,' But Hopes You Enjoy Her Dark Stuff, Too | http://popcrush.com/lady-gaga-bad-romance-interview/?trackback=tsmclip

[Judas Oyster 1,915]

Many people were thinking he is/was gonna be all over LG5. After how little input he had on ARTPOP I've always thought that he somewhat would have a little less or more on LG5, but not as much as in her previous albums. I still think he'll get some credit in there but not as much as Ronson for example.

[HighlandHeart 993]

21 hours ago, Seeka said:

I honestly kind of want all the fame hungry idiots to go away until they mature to know Gaga should be a happy person as an artist and that she should feel free to do what she wants.

This. Thank you. Finally someone with sense. 

I obviously love TF/M, but I love BTW, and I love AP too. Yes I fell in love with Gaga through TF/M and as in music as in relationships, you never forget your first love, but I also fell in love with Gaga through simply watching and listening to her as a person. I knew from 2009 that one day she would become an actress too, just as I knew (it's impossible not to know with someone as beautiful and talented and transformative as her) that both she and her work would grow and change and mature over time. That is the same with everyone. She always looks forward, not back. People may know it but they need to start accepting it for their own good. Gaga will never create based on what people tell her to do, if people don't know that then they don't know her. Mourn TF/M by all means but stop being whiney and bratty and trying to stifle her evolution because it's just ridiculous. And have ****ing faith in her that her upcoming album is going to blow **** up. This is Lady ****ing Gaga we're talking about. 

[HighlandHeart 993]

If anything it's just an insult to Gaga. Do you really think she would have posted a photo with herself in the studio with him if she wasn't 100% happy with the work he's doing and if that he isn't definitely on the album, and let all the press write about how she enlisted the guy who helped her write record-breaking hits?

The assumption that "she has scrapped him from the record" is so ridiculous and annoying. Does she have to post a picture with him every time they're in the studio to keep you happy? Oh no, then you'd just whine about how she's not working hard enough on LG5 because she's too busy taking pictures. One photo was enough to confirm it. They looked so happy together in the pics. I'm pretty sure the reason she hasn't posted anymore is because a) she shouldn't ****ing have to and b) their work together for this album is probably finished and finalised.