Would you replace Marry the Night with ScheiBe as the fifth single?

[Bradley 54,988]

It probably wouldn't have made a difference at that point, and I could not emotionally handle Scheisse flopping because it is perfection.  Would I swap Scheisse for Judas? HELL YES. 

Judas shall never be replaced.

[Bradley 54,988]

Marry the Night at least got a little airplay. 

Scheiße would have been a terrible choice

ScheiBe is more radio friendly tho

[Bradley 54,988]

Let's be real, could you really see radio stations playing Scheiße?

Definitely, in fact I see it as one of the most radio friendly songs on Born This Way.

[Creyk 16,836]

Yes we would have televised HQ performances of the song. Although IDK...would she have sung an acoustic rendition of Scheisse if it was a single? (she did it with MTN), like can scheisse be turned into a piano ballad....

[Jesse Pinkman 4,660]

No. I would switch out Judas for TEOG. As much as I love the video.

[DIVA 666]

Never. As much as I love Scheiße, the MTN video remains my ALL TIME favorite Gaga video and the song itself slayed me to tiny little bits since I first listened to it after unlocking it on Gagaville.

Haha, Gagaville! How iconic! I miss those days!  

[retroglamx 5,087]

Haha, Gagaville! How iconic! I miss those days! 

Gaga was the only one who got me to play that silly game and as soon as I got the songs I never looked back. 

[DIVA 666]

Gaga was the only one who got me to play that silly game as soon as I got the songs I never looked back. 

Same 

I remember getting Electric Chapel too and loving every second of it. I wonder if my town still exists somewhere out there in the internet. Maybe it's become a ghetto by now.  

[monsterdreams 1,529]

No, I wouldn't replace anything with it singles wise (You And I if I had to choose)

[Staryu 6,162]

Hell no. Marry The Night is my favorite Gaga song and my favorite Gaga music video.  

It should have replaced TEOG imo.

[Bad Bromance 5,809]

I love "Scheiße", but no. "Marry the Night", in my opinion, is the track on Born This Way that deserved to have a full video and be sent out for maximum exposure.

This right here.  Besides, as much as I love Scheiße, I am not totally convinced radio would have supported it.  There's a chance it would have gotten very little airplay because of the German gibberish and that would have been such a shame since it's an amazing dance track.  

[Bette Davis 12,742]

Definitely, in fact I see it as one of the most radio friendly songs on Born This Way.

I disagree, but that's just my opinion  I personally love the song but I cannot imagine it being on the radio (American at least, can't speak for European) or your average person, who generally likes safe, boppy stuff by Katy and Taylor, understanding/getting into Scheiße. 

[The Child 18,994]

Yes we would have televised HQ performances of the song. Although IDK...would she have sung an acoustic rendition of Scheisse if it was a single? (she did it with MTN), like can scheisse be turned into a piano ballad....

Never ever doubt Gaga, she can turn any song into an acoustic one.

[Creyk 16,836]

Never ever doubt Gaga, she can turn any song into an acoustic one.

I kinda agree. Applause is a very fast song just like Scheisse and she made an amazing piano version out of it.

[Mister Gaga 21,891]

No! Born This Way single choices were perfect imo. The order was messy (TEOG should have been the second single, Judas the third). Marry The Night and it's video are both flawless