First AHS Review In: Episode #1 praised, but Gaga noted as weak point

[jojo Freud 653]

Wondering how this reviewer has already seen it though when the official premiere for Reviewers and critics isn't until a few hours....

Actually yeah good point, I thought the airing for critics hasn't occurred yet

[Stef 60,179]

This whole reviews feels dodgy, I mean the San Francisco chronicle (of ALL media outlets) getting the exclusive first look?

Idk  

Murphy has hyped Gaga and apparently will "blow us away" so Imma believe it when I see it with my own eyes  

[Jase 12,118]

lol I knew we'd get a bunch of "FAKE" comments if the review about Gaga was negative in any way.

It is what it is. I was never expecting a Meryl Streep performance but here's hoping she isn't too bad.

[Evan Peters 10,331]

we'll see when it actually comes on

[Bitter 3,640]

Guys it's not fake.

He is an editor and a tv critic. 

http://www.sfchronicle.com/author/david-wiegand/

[lego 44,165]

little monsters 

this is his twitter

https://mobile.twitter.com/waitwhat_tv

 

ask him does he like Madonna?  

[RBNLM 1,640]

i'll judge by myself thx 

[Davidsonary 925]

Calm down guys. Just judge it yourself when you actually watch it on Wednesday. If you let a review affect you, there's no way you'll be able to enjoy this season. :)

[HANZ 4,380]

I NEVER read reviews, like who has the time to read them

[OBEY 57,107]

Angela Chang is back under a new identity  

[Evan Peters 10,331]

It's not even out for critics yet though. I don't get it  

edit: we didn't get any critic reviews for freakshow until after the premiere so unless they changed that rule then...

[thierryrreiht 20,001]

[Americano 31,061]

little monsters 

this is his twitter

https://mobile.twitter.com/waitwhat_tv

 

ask him does he like Madonna?  

 

[Nicole 1,809]

Honestly, I can see this being the case (the thing about her speaking in the show). But seeing as people aren't sure this is a legit review, we should wait to see it for ourselves.

[Stef 60,179]

It's not even out for critics yet though. I don't get it  

MTE - I'm waiting for the reviews AFTER the premiere happens, they're the ones to take seriously