Is Born This Way the best album ever released by a major pop girl?

[Psychedelic 1,098]

it's not fair to compare Gaga's solo albums to Madonna's at this moment. 

it's 4 against 13.

when Gaga will have 10+ albums under her belt, then we will talk about who had better albums between these two. 

I agree

[Benji 20,113]

once again, we will count female pop veterans when Gaga will have released at least dozen of solo albums. 

I didn't read the whole thread, no one's got time for that. Chill 

[Hauser 1,262]

firstly, I don't even think Blackout is that good and the only impressive songs from that album in my opinion are its singles.

secondly, I doubt Britney even had as much input in making Blackout as Gaga had with Born This Way 

Confessions on a Dance Floor is indeed one of the strongest albums by Madonna, however, I'm talking about major pop girls here, which don't include Madonna since the turn of the 21st century. 

I can believe that, except the question you asked in the op has nothing to do with who had more input int heir albums so that still makes Blackout a much better album than BTW. Im not trashing BTW I love the album but when compared to flawless pop albums Blackout takes the cake.

 

[Rino 5,120]

I can believe that, except the question you asked in the op has nothing to do with who had more input int heir albums so that still makes Blackout a much better album than BTW. Im not trashing BTW I love the album but when compared to flawless pop albums Blackout takes the cake.

okay. 

I just can't get Britney Spears albums seriously, because basically all that she does for recording them is providing her vocals. Almost all her albums could be sung by any other basic pop girl and that wouldn't make much difference 

[FGGrayson 9,670]

Not when Blackout and Confession on a Dance Floor exist

Really?

Blackout & COADF are sooooooooooooo overrated, tho COADF is a good album but, Blackout? really sis?

 

[Psychedelic 1,098]

okay. 

I just can't get Britney Spears albums seriously, because basically all that she does for recording them is providing her vocals. Almost all her albums could be sung by any other basic pop girl and that wouldn't make much difference 

While I agree with the first part of what you said, the second part is totally false. I can't imagine Selena Gomez or even Ariana with her great vocals, putting the same feeling to the songs in Blackout.

[Ladey Gagz 2,512]

TFM >  

[Hauser 1,262]

okay. 

I just can't get Britney Spears albums seriously, because basically all that she does for recording them is providing her vocals. Almost all her albums could be sung by any other basic pop girl and that wouldn't make much difference 

Still doesn't make Blackout any less of an amazing pop album, if you don't like the responses that go against BTW don't ask the question in the first place lol

[ryhanna 3,507]

It's better than anything by any of her contemporaries. 

[Hauser 1,262]

Really?

Blackout & COADF are sooooooooooooo overrated, tho COADF is a good album but, Blackout? really sis?

 

Oh no not another doubter, go listen to Blackout it is like the pop bible from start to finish, go get your life sis

[Rino 5,120]

While I agree with the first part of what you said, the second part is totally false. I can't imagine Selena Gomez or even Ariana with her great vocals, putting the same feeling to the songs in Blackout.

ok, I admit that I might have went too far with that statement, but, honeslty, I do think that Selena Gomez would have been capable to pull of most songs on Blackout. Ariana Grande is more of Mariah-esque kind of singer, so yeah, I can't imagine her singing Britney's albums. 

[Rino 5,120]

Still doesn't make Blackout any less of an amazing pop album, if you don't like the responses that go against BTW don't ask the question in the first place lol

I didn't say that I didn't like your response though  

I know I will get all sorts of responses in this thread, even more outrageous and totally wrong (in my humble opinion) than yours. 

[Guest ARTPOPSlays]

Of course 

[TimisaMonster 31,073]

No...BLUE by iamamiwhoami

 

[Fiona Apple 13,006]

The Fame Monster could be the #1 too