Very Similar Songs: Did BoA plagiarize Ashley Tisdale? Listen and judge please!

[Okinawa 1,277]

I discovered that song by BoA and I like it very much....

 

 

 

Some time later I started to realize... "wait..! that beat! that vibe! that song! I've heard it before..."

It reminds me of Ashley Tisdale's Crank It Up.

 

 

 

 

Do you think that Crank It Up and Energetic are extremely similar songs and would you go so far to say that BoA's producer plagiarized it, yes or not?

Or do you think that there are big differences?

 

[Bloody 64,631]

Listen to California Gurls & Tik Tok. They're more than similar.

[Zsolti 2,688]

that song is tragic

[Ray of Light 8,134]

Wow Ashley Tisdale is truly an ICON of our generation, ready for her songwriting award next year. Queen of Pop. Miss my Ashley era.

[Andreyw 4,285]

Wow Ashley Tisdale is truly an ICON of our generation, ready for her songwriting award next year. Queen of Pop. Miss my Ashley era.

​Not when her best song (a.k.a. How Do You Love Someone) was written by Porcelain Black

[Bio 23,538]

BoA's album was released three months before Ashley's tho:

BoA: March 2009

Guilty Pleasure: June 2009

[Okinawa 1,277]

BoA's album was released three months before Ashley's tho:

BoA: March 2009

Guilty Pleasure: June 2009

​

Interesting. According to Spanish-speaking wikipedia Crank It Up was produced in 2008 and an untraceable link states it already existed in 2007. BoA's production began in 2008. 

The similarities astound me. Who else think it is similar?

 

Coincidence or fraud, what does gagadaily think?