What would you do if Gaga goes through a career destructive era in the future?

[Serendipity 7,821]

Would you be here for Gaga when the world world turns against her

I'm not talking about something like AP/4/Rated R

but something destructive era like Erotica/American Life/Glitter/Impossible Princess

when she has nothing......commercially, critically, personally

At the time if she is labeled a national villain, would you still be with her?

 

I would stand by her to the day she is good

[ViviLittleM 3]

with ARTPOP she had nothing too.

[Bio 23,538]

But none of those eras actually destroyed anyone's career 

[Serendipity 7,821]

with ARTPOP she had nothing too.

​she didn't become national villain like Madge during AL

[Tropico 4,145]

If the music is good, I'll remain unbothered.

I'm totally here for an era where's truly the embodiment of Creative Rebellion. 

[Serendipity 7,821]

But none of those eras actually destroyed anyone's career 

​trust me at that time, everybody was saying they were over

[Tropico 4,145]

with ARTPOP she had nothing too.

​Except good music

Which should be the reason people stan for an artist...

And her sales weren't too bad. 

[Swan Heart 7,382]

ARTPOP era was pretty bad, if you ask me.. Too bad, because the album was amazing and it deserved better..

But on topic, yes... I will always be here for Gagz.

 

[Serendipity 7,821]

If the music is good, I'll remain unbothered.

I'm totally here for an era where's truly the embodiment of Creative Rebellion. 

​best words ever

 

[Guest]

with ARTPOP she had nothing too.

​She had 2 huge hit, Applause (soon 3x platinum in US) and DWUW. And the album sold 2,3M only in 2013, so yeah she had "nothing"

edit: and ****ing amazing music

 

[Serendipity 7,821]

​Except good music

Which should be the reason people stan for an artist...

And her sales weren't too bad. 

​this, i think the 2012 version of AP was ruined by overproduction

[Serendipity 7,821]

​She had 2 huge hit, Applause (soon 3x platinum in US) and DWUW. And the album sold 2,3M only in 2013, so yeah she had "nothing"

​imagine if her lead single from an album performs like Through the Rain/Living for Love

[Bebe 17,093]

Impossible Princess was critically successful but a commercial failure.

If Gaga released something that was of a high caliber but not mainstream I would praise the heavens. A truly experimental and bold album from her would be incredible. Even better if she followed up with some truly avant garde performances and pushed herself even further.

If the album was a critical and commercial disappointment, I would support her still because I know she is truly talented. I would just have faith that she could rebuild and create something spectacular. (In this scenario, I also don't like the music, if I like the album but it was a commercial and critical failure then of course I will still be a fan).

[Guest]

​imagine if her lead single from an album performs like Through the Rain/Living for Love

​I only know LFL 

Well I think LG5 will have a huge success, but maybe after this album she'd like to explores new genres and she'll flop… As long as the music is good I'd be here for her! 

[bionic 50,107]

I wouldn't really call any of those albums 'destructive' considering that the artists singing them are still around now.

 

Erotica and Impossible Princess both spawned significant tours. IP was critically acclaimed and there was a lot else going on that effected it.