Angelina Jolie's daughter "wants to be called John"

[mcoop 628]

Nah, not supporting this

 

she's 8, this is clearly them taking one thing and going LOOK HOW ACCEPTING WE ARE.

 

Heck I fecking played with barbies at one point, doesn't mean my parents had to start calling me a girl and buying me girl things.

 

Let her grow up before you do something so dramatic as to change her gender before she's even at an age to know the concept, it's another example of someone trying to be over tolerant.

 

I didn't know I was bi until I was about 15, does that mean the whole time when I was 6-10 saying how much I loved girls I should automatically just get married to one, because that's what I said I liked when I was an infant right?

 

Anyone who thinks i'm being transphobic re-read what i'm saying with logic...she's too young to have this forced upon her

Why don't you practice what you preach and RE-READ THE ARTICLE. It mentions nothing about "changing her" or being "forced to do something". She prefers to be called John. THAT IS IT. It does NOT say anything about him being transgender, only the possibility. It also mentions him wanting to be called John because of  him possibly wanting to fit in with his brothers.

 

Take a Xanax and relax. 

[doveve 526]

i dont get offended. some people just arent educated and there is nothing wrong with that because you can always learn

 

first lesson: use the right pronoun. this kid is a "he".

.

I think I know enough about trans kids. I've watched documentaries on youtube about it, that's why I said I didn't want anyone to be offended by my opinion. I know it's a huge struggle for those kids. I am sure I could never understand what it means to be transgender as I never in my life experienced it. But at least I'm accepting and open-minded about that. I am just saying that Shiloh would be an outstandingly beautiful girl... But it's her/his choice. 

[Robotboy 1,700]

Nah, not supporting this

 

she's 8, this is clearly them taking one thing and going LOOK HOW ACCEPTING WE ARE.

 

Heck I fecking played with barbies at one point, doesn't mean my parents had to start calling me a girl and buying me girl things.

 

Let her grow up before you do something so dramatic as to change her gender before she's even at an age to know the concept, it's another example of someone trying to be over tolerant.

 

I didn't know I was bi until I was about 15, does that mean the whole time when I was 6-10 saying how much I loved girls I should automatically just get married to one, because that's what I said I liked when I was an infant right?

 

Anyone who thinks i'm being transphobic re-read what i'm saying with logic...she's too young to have this forced upon her

dont compare your own life with this lol. clearly you dont relate to this and you dont have to. and they did not force anything on him thats the whole point. they let him decide. unlike so many others who force their gender ideas on their children.

 

sometimes its ok to just stay silent :)

[swine killer 0]

 

Nah, not supporting this

 

she's 8, this is clearly them taking one thing and going LOOK HOW ACCEPTING WE ARE.

 

Heck I fecking played with barbies at one point, doesn't mean my parents had to start calling me a girl and buying me girl things.

 

Let her grow up before you do something so dramatic as to change her gender before she's even at an age to know the concept, it's another example of someone trying to be over tolerant.

 

I didn't know I was bi until I was about 15, does that mean the whole time when I was 6-10 saying how much I loved girls I should automatically just get married to one, because that's what I said I liked when I was an infant right?

 

Anyone who thinks i'm being transphobic re-read what i'm saying with logic...she's too young to have this forced upon her

 

 

I wouldn't call you transhphobic, but hell yeah ignorant and self-absorbed. Calm down, sis  :thirst:

[Pandora 162]

:udidnt:

[Rollercoaster 2]

The members saying "he", calm down. The kid wanted to use a different name and to fit in with her peers (brothers) not to grow a beard and go boxing (yet). Let's not get ahead of ourselves.

[Cersei 56]

Why don't you practice what you preach and RE-READ THE ARTICLE. It mentions nothing about "changing her" or being "forced to do something". She prefers to be called John. THAT IS IT. It does NOT say anything about him being transgender, only the possibility. It also mentions him wanting to be called John because of  him possibly wanting to fit in with his brothers.

 

Take a Xanax and relax. 

 

Calling her whatever they are called is fine, but she didn't go down to the stores and buy those male clothes themselves did they?

 

 

dont compare your own life with this lol. clearly you dont relate to this and you dont have to. and they did not force anything on him thats the whole point. they let him decide. unlike so many others who force their gender ideas on their children.

 

sometimes its ok to just stay silent :)

 

 

Yes let them decide, you're forcing a ****ing pronoun on them at a young age

 

what if this kid grows up, realises what's happened in their childhood and is traumatised at the fact that they now will be forever mis-gendered as a boy when they actually were a girl who was young and unaware?

 

 

 

 

I wouldn't call you transhphobic, but hell yeah ignorant and self-absorbed. Calm down, sis  :thirst:

 

Has a rational viewpoint - ignorant and self absorbed

 

I'm the only one actually giving real support for this child, you're pushing you're own agenda by trying to put a ****ing child in the trans box before they are even able to form their own decisions. IT'S ABUSE

[Robotboy 1,700]

I think I know enough about trans kids. I've watched documentaries on youtube about it, that's why I said I didn't want anyone to be offended by my opinion. I know it's a huge struggle for those kids. I am sure I could never understand what it means to be transgender as I never in my life experienced it. But at least I'm accepting and open-minded about that. I am just saying that Shiloh would be an outstandingly beautiful girl... But it's her/his choice. 

im sorry thanks for explaining

[doveve 526]

Nah, not supporting this

 

she's 8, this is clearly them taking one thing and going LOOK HOW ACCEPTING WE ARE.

 

Heck I fecking played with barbies at one point, doesn't mean my parents had to start calling me a girl and buying me girl things.

 

Let her grow up before you do something so dramatic as to change her gender before she's even at an age to know the concept, it's another example of someone trying to be over tolerant.

 

I didn't know I was bi until I was about 15, does that mean the whole time when I was 6-10 saying how much I loved girls I should automatically just get married to one, because that's what I said I liked when I was an infant right?

 

Anyone who thinks i'm being transphobic re-read what i'm saying with logic...she's too young to have this forced upon her

Playing with barbies is not the same as wanting to be a girl all the time and wear girl clothes and be called 'she'. I am a girl and I played with cars all my childhood. I hated barbies and skirts. I still don't like doing many things girl do. However, I never, never in my mind even thought about wanting to be a boy! I always knew I'm a girl and was ok with it. These are totally different things. 

[Stefani328 321]

dont compare your own life with this lol. clearly you dont relate to this and you dont have to. and they did not force anything on him thats the whole point. they let him decide. unlike so many others who force their gender ideas on their children.

 

sometimes its ok to just stay silent :)

I wouldn't say he because her parents don't say he. In interviews Angelina has said Shiloh likes being like her brothers and dressing like them but she still addresses her daughter as she or Shiloh. I've never heard her say John or he in interviews. If her parents are comfortable with her being like her brothers and they still use the pronoun she, why would complete strangers use he or call her John.

[swine killer 0]

Has a rational viewpoint - ignorant and self absorbed

 

I'm the only one actually giving real support for this child, you're pushing you're own agenda by trying to put a ****ing child in the trans box before they are even able to form their own decisions. IT'S ABUSE

 

 

First and foremost, it doesnt seem that you have read article properly, and you seem to not want to accept another person's situation and feelings. - Ignorant

 

That you base everything on your experiences are just ridiculous, everyone doesnt grow up like you just because you played with "girly" stuff. Self-absorbed.

 

 

And children have never own choices, we put them in foldes because they are born with a gender that is actually an identity and not something biologicaly. (Physically yes, but gender is what's inside us, what we feel that we are) If you are agree, then I can call you transphobic.

[Chic 20,830]

Calling her whatever they are called is fine, but she didn't go down to the stores and buy those male clothes themselves did they?

 

 

 

 

Yes let them decide, you're forcing a ****ing pronoun on them at a young age

 

what if this kid grows up, realises what's happened in their childhood and is traumatised at the fact that they now will be forever mis-gendered as a boy when they actually were a girl who was young and unaware?

 

 

Has a rational viewpoint - ignorant and self absorbed

 

I'm the only one actually giving real support for this child, you're pushing you're own agenda by trying to put a ****ing child in the trans box before they are even able to form their own decisions. IT'S ABUSE

How about the real abuse is that they aren't having this child sent to a therapist to be diagnosed officially if he really is transgender so he can start puberty blockers before feminizing effects start to occur?

Children know, they ****ing do. I knew. I knew 7 years ago and I know now and I ****ing wish I could have been put on puberty blockers the day I turned 10.

What age are people allowed to be taken seriously when they make decisions like this? There is no official age. Puberty blockers exist for a reason and if he is indeed transgender then he needs to start taking them immediately.

[Cersei 56]

. I've never heard her say John or he in interviews. If her parents are comfortable with her being like her brothers and they still use the pronoun she, why would complete strangers use he or call her John.

 

Because they want to push their agenda for their own selfish beliefs and force a trans image upon a child which isn't even at an age of consent.

 

Selfish selfish selfish, this a child's life and identity we are talking about here.

[boobtank 9,090]

Omg , stop it, She's 8

bye a lot of kids know by this age

[Cersei 56]

How about the real abuse is that they aren't having this child sent to a therapist to be diagnosed officially if he really is transgender so he can start puberty blockers before feminizing effects start to occur?

Children know, they ****ing do. I knew. I knew 7 years ago and I know now and I ****ing wish I could have been put on puberty blockers the day I turned 10.

What age are people allowed to be taken seriously when they make decisions like this? There is no official age. Puberty blockers exist for a reason and if he is indeed transgender then he needs to start taking them immediately.

 

Maybe at the age where they are a ****ing adult

 

You aren't at a legal age of consent as a child EVER that's how as a law for a multitude of cases

 

By that argument you can say "A child at 8 knows they want to have s-x, so it's fine". As a child you know jack **** about yourself, you shame me for using my personal experiences but when you use yours it's fine?

 

Literally stop it, you are abusing this ****ing child and you've convinced yourself you're being tolerant. Let them live their life how they want and stop trying to put them in the trans box because you want to push your own agenda.