Gaga replies to a tweet about her weight

[Zoey Brooks 0]

As a woman i think she can do whatever she wants to do with her body.

But as a pop performer (dancer + singer) I'd rather see her fit. I find her excuses...lame. Sorry.

But that's just me. Don't come puking your feminist/Beyoncé bull**** on me.

Edit: I'm sorry i didnt know i am not allowed to have an opinion. :roll:

Then it's really ****ing fantastic that no one cares how you'd "rather see her". Her being a pop performer doesn't mean her body is suddenly public property; she shouldn't have to justify why she looks the way she does to anyone, especially not to people who claim to be fans. I'm sick of this mentality that places more importance on success to a mainstream audience than Gaga's mental and physical health. It's just immature.

[Rat Boy 43,495]

As a woman i think she can do whatever she wants to do with her body.

But as a pop performer (dancer + singer) I'd rather see her fit. I find her excuses...lame. Sorry.

But that's just me. Don't come puking your feminist/Beyoncé bull**** on me.

Edit: I'm sorry i didnt know i am not allowed to have an opinion. :roll:

Nash Grier is dat U?

[RAMROD 109,386]

Why you gotta be be so rude?

Don't you know that she's human too?

 

[somechick 1]

Then it's really ****ing fantastic that no one cares how you'd "rather see her". Her being a pop performer doesn't mean her body is suddenly public property; she shouldn't have to justify why she looks the way she does to anyone, especially not to people who claim to be fans. I'm sick of this mentality that places more importance on success to a mainstream audience than Gaga's mental and physical health. It's just immature.

 

I think some guys just really do not understand how womens weight can fluctuate. Doesn't mean they should be rude about it though.

[Mama Ru 994]

As a woman i think she can do whatever she wants to do with her body.

But as a pop performer (dancer + singer) I'd rather see her fit. I find her excuses...lame. Sorry.

But that's just me. Don't come puking your feminist/Beyoncé bull**** on me.

Edit: I'm sorry i didnt know i am not allowed to have an opinion. :roll:

Of course you're allowed to have an opinion, and other people are allowed to have an opinion about your opinion.

[healme 83]

As a woman i think she can do whatever she wants to do with her body.

But as a pop performer (dancer + singer) I'd rather see her fit. I find her excuses...lame. Sorry.

But that's just me. Don't come puking your feminist/Beyoncé bull**** on me.

Edit: I'm sorry i didnt know i am not allowed to have an opinion. :roll:

 

She is fit though. She's on a world tour where she dances and runs about the stage every night. How could she not be fit doing that? Your physical size is, in a lot of cases, not really related to your fitness level, especially when her weight gain between then and now is as trivial as this.

 

She's nearing 30 now so her metabolism is slowing, she's settled with a long-term boyfriend, and, crucially, she doesn't have an eating disorder. She is a perfectly healthy weight considering her circumstances.

[HOTRODSGAGA 81]

Then it's really ****ing fantastic that no one cares how you'd "rather see her". Her being a pop performer doesn't mean her body is suddenly public property; she shouldn't have to justify why she looks the way she does to anyone, especially not to people who claim to be fans. I'm sick of this mentality that places more importance on success to a mainstream audience than Gaga's mental and physical health. It's just immature.

actually this is a forum. By making a thread about something you are asking people to give their opinion. If you don't want people to give their opinion just write an article and disable the comments section.

Oh and giving an opinion doesnt mean always agreeing at all. Am i ****ing supposed to be a yesman so yall can sleep Better at night?

And i used "rather see her" not "want to see her" pr "have to see her" because i am giving her the freedom to do whatever she wants with her body. I am ALLOWED to have my opinion. You are ALLOWED to disagree but if theres one thing you're not allowed to do is call me immature because i don't agree with everything gaga or you have to say.

I will not answer to any quote anymore. I don't see I've done anything wrong by giving my opinion. This place was meant for people giving their opinion. You want yes-fans? Go to ****ing Twitter.

[gagaconvert 68]

As a woman i think she can do whatever she wants to do with her body.

But as a pop performer (dancer + singer) I'd rather see her fit. I find her excuses...lame. Sorry.

But that's just me. Don't come puking your feminist/Beyoncé bull**** on me.

Edit: I'm sorry i didnt know i am not allowed to have an opinion. :roll:

She IS fit though. A bit of extra weight doesn't mean she's unfit. She's in the middle of a world tour, dancing and singing basically every other night, and performing with consistently high energy...pretty sure an unfit person couldn't manage that.

She is fit though. She's on a world tour where she dances and runs about the stage every night. How could she not be fit doing that? Your physical size is, in a lot of cases, not really related to your fitness level, especially when her weight gain between then and now is as trivial as this.

Haha we basically just posted the exact same respose!

[MonsterMum 2,532]

actually this is a forum. By making a thread about something you are asking people to give their opinion. If you don't want people to give their opinion just write an article and disable the comments section.

Oh and giving an opinion doesnt mean always agreeing at all. Am i ****ing supposed to be a yesman so yall can sleep Better at night?

And i used "rather see her" not "want to see her" pr "have to see her" because i am giving her the freedom to do whatever she wants with her body. I am ALLOWED to have my opinion. You are ALLOWED to disagree but if theres one thing you're not allowed to do is call me immature because i don't agree with everything gaga or you have to say.

I will not answer to any quote anymore. I don't see I've done anything wrong by giving my opinion. This place was meant for people giving their opinion. You want yes-fans? Go to ****ing Twitter.

 

So you just casually ignore the FACT that being bloated is something common for a woman during her menstrual cycle and has nothing to do whether she's fit or not.

You rather throw a hissy fit about non factors and "giving her freedom to do whatever she wants with her body", well thank you, so generous of you! Didn't know she had to get your approval.

[healme 83]

 

Haha we basically just posted the exact same respose!

 

great minds think alike :)

[Zoey Brooks 0]

actually this is a forum. By making a thread about something you are asking people to give their opinion. If you don't want people to give their opinion just write an article and disable the comments section.

Oh and giving an opinion doesnt mean always agreeing at all. Am i ****ing supposed to be a yesman so yall can sleep Better at night?

And i used "rather see her" not "want to see her" pr "have to see her" because i am giving her the freedom to do whatever she wants with her body. I am ALLOWED to have my opinion. You are ALLOWED to disagree but if theres one thing you're not allowed to do is call me immature because i don't agree with everything gaga or you have to say.

I will not answer to any quote anymore. I don't see I've done anything wrong by giving my opinion. This place was meant for people giving their opinion. You want yes-fans? Go to ****ing Twitter.

I didn't say you weren't allowed to give your opinion. But being allowed to give an opinion isn't the same thing as having the right to say whatever you want without it being challenged. You have an opinion, and it just so happens that I believe that opinion is cruel.

 

I said it was immature to value success over health, which it is. You've repeatedly ignored people who say that Gaga is clearly fit - which, let's be real, she is - which implies that you have some other reason for not liking the way her figure looks today. I don't know what your specific reason is, but there's a worryingly large group of fans who complain about Gaga's image because it's not the way it was during TFM era. Those are the people I was calling immature.

 

But the fact still remains that it's not your job to police Gaga's body. You're free to offer an opinion, but having an opinion in the first place other than "Whatever Gaga's comfortable with is fine by me" is, in my opinion, acting as though you have some right to control what she looks like. 

[HOTRODSGAGA 81]

So you just casually ignore the FACT that being bloated is something common for a woman during her menstrual cycle and has nothing to do whether she's fit or not.

You rather throw a hissy fit about non factors and "giving her freedom to do whatever she wants with her body", well thank you, so generous of you! Didn't know she had to get your approval.

I knew you would turn it into something feminist.

Oh and it was just a way of saying it. I didnt mean it that way. She doesnt need anyones permission to be the way she is.

But when I'm paying money to see her dance + sing i better not see someone struggling/breathless after 15 minutes on stage. Maybe she can't help it during her cycles. Okay. I didnt know that. Thanks gaga + u for letting me know. But that's not an excuse when the problem has been going on for months now.

[lego 44,165]

So you just casually ignore the FACT that being bloated is something common for a woman during her menstrual cycle and has nothing to do whether she's fit or not.

You rather throw a hissy fit about non factors and "giving her freedom to do whatever she wants with her body", well thank you, so generous of you! Didn't know she had to get your approval.

 

This. So. Much.

 

[HOTRODSGAGA 81]

I didn't say you weren't allowed to give your opinion. But being allowed to give an opinion isn't the same thing as having the right to say whatever you want without it being challenged. You have an opinion, and it just so happens that I believe that opinion is cruel.

I said it was immature to value success over health, which it is. You've repeatedly ignored people who say that Gaga is clearly fit - which, let's be real, she is - which implies that you have some other reason for not liking the way her figure looks today. I don't know what your specific reason is, but there's a worryingly large group of fans who complain about Gaga's image because it's not the way it was during TFM era. Those are the people I was calling immature.

But the fact still remains that it's not your job to police Gaga's body. You're free to offer an opinion, but having an opinion in the first place other than "Whatever Gaga's comfortable with is fine by me" is, in my opinion, acting as though you have some right to control what she looks like.

Actually I'm not saying i can control gagas body. I clearly said she's free to do whatever she wants many times.

And tbh, I'm kind of worried about gaga because her weight is so fluctuant. Had she always been that way I'd have called her fit. But going from a size 0 to a size 3 back and and forth in a couple months isn't exactly what id call fit.

And concerning The Fame Monster era, i don't think her body back then is.....anything I'd like to see gaga flaunting EVER again. Weight has nothing to do with success I'm just talking about the way it doesnt really help her on stage when the dance routine is harsh.

And at last tbh I don't care if people want to challenge my opinion but i hate the way people start attacking the poster. That's just sad. You don't have to attack me bc i don't agree with you. Attack my post instead.

Sorry for my rotten english.

[Schwerk 7,244]

Gaga and her comebacks

 

Love this woman.