A Big Difference Between Gaga and Katy

[RAMROD 103,619]

Gaga choose to put a ball between her legs.

Katy choose to put gigantic cube on her head.

[Giorgiii 0]

she is female MJ that's all 

[tristessa 0]

How is this a shade when I am just stating what I see from Katy?

I said it could just easily go that direction when comparing the two, that's all. I didn't say you were shading her

[MyQueen 2,409]

One's the female MJ and the other is the male Madonna.

And who is who?

 

Non of them can dance like Queen M and MJ?

[Quark 7,035]

 Madonna can't sing or play instruments like Gaga, and MJ can play instruments like Gaga.

And who is who?

 

Non of them can dance like Queen M and MJ?

 

[calmar 22,030]

Also, I'm disappointed that Katy would so carelessly combine Mesopotamian and Egyptian cultures under one roof and then call herself "Katypatra" (when Cleopatra lived 2200 years after Babylon, and was of Greek ancestry). I would hope that Gaga would make sure her allusions don't conflate, distort, and simplify history like the MV for Dark Horse appears to be doing.

[shaneybaby 450]

i always think that.. like katys video was like tarzan and now like egyptian themed... gagas can never be classified as anything other than its GAGA 

[Mills 446]

Imagery is obviously their difference, but simply because the magnitude of their mass appeal is clearly another one. 

[grenziel 538]

Except Katy doesn't have enought talent to be the female MJ, and Madonna doesn't have enought talent to be the female Gaga.

I think he's referring to the end of BTW MV tho ..

[Scarlet Witch 1,057]

[miroe 24]

I hear what you're saying but their intention is the same in my opinion. Gaga just does it better.

[grenziel 538]

Also, I'm disappointed that Katy would so carelessly combine Mesopotamian and Egyptian cultures under one roof and then call herself "Katypatra" (when Cleopatra lived 2200 years after Babylon, and was of Greek ancestry). I would hope that Gaga would make sure her allusions don't conflate, distort, and simplify history like the MV for Dark Horse appears to be doing.

THIS. She wouldn't treat us like were all ignorant and feed on everything she will give us.

[Ladle Ghoulash 15,965]

big difference: one is a cultural icon and the other is a marketing machine.

Also, I'm disappointed that Katy would so carelessly combine Mesopotamian and Egyptian cultures under one roof and then call herself "Katypatra" (when Cleopatra lived 2200 years after Babylon, and was of Greek ancestry). I would hope that Gaga would make sure her allusions don't conflate, distort, and simplify history like the MV for Dark Horse appears to be doing.

not to mention her carelessly presenting a mish-mosh of japanese and chinese imagery and s-xualized and appropriated version of a kimono at the AMAs.

also one is an innovator and the other shamelessly panders the pop market.

[Mr Josh 3]

Gaga can sing. Katy can't.

[Anthagio 113]

I think Gaga is much more involved in what she does. I think Katy is involved as well, but she takes a step back and lets her creative team do what creative teams do. Gaga on the other hand likes to sit at the table with her creative team and be like, "let's do this, this, and this". I don't think one is necessarily better than the other but I do respect Gaga's way of working more.