Better Video: Yoü and I vs Disease

[BELLYACHE 1,856]

4 hours ago, RenegAde said:

Still gagged at this choreo. Boomkack never misses !!!

Miles better than any other of her choreographers MILESSS

[JohnWayne92 2,388]

Disease - its the perfect mixture of a rock/metal video and a pop video. 

Her walking on herself will be unmatched for me. 

[JustTea 6,983]

Disease choreo and cinematography are tragic compared to You and I 

Edit. And looks ofc, it's not even close...

Edited 19 hours ago by JustTea

[VOLANTIS 16,506]

The choreo alone in You and I clears actually. Massively underrated too btw. When it comes to the song though, I'd pick disease. 

[Hadrian 2,751]

Disease. She's THAT BITCH.

[ALGAYDO 35,484]

Love Y&I down, but Disease takes the cake for me tbh 

[Sneaky Oliver 23,085]

I think these are two of her most underrated videos !! Both of them are great but I love You and I lore/narrative so much

[shape of a rvfzme 1,975]

Disease

[Sneaky Oliver 23,085]

14 hours ago, Cherry Blues said:

The claustrophobic feeling of Disease is already artistic, it makes you catch your breath. This small suburb that seems so idyllic and where such psychotic scenes take place. Everyone lives their lifes there, getting up for work in the morning while Lady Gaga fights against her inner demons and against the biting sun and idyll. Also find the scenes in the abandoned room very intense, also the atmosphere with the wind - that's where the atmosphere turns around. 

Love the claustrophobic atmosphere where she dances between the houses and the background there. 

You and I is a pure route 66 fantasy video - strange but humorous. I like it also very much - but Disease is very intense. They are to different for to choose spontaneous. 

 

I see some comments about how the video should have been shot at night but I completely disagree!! The sunlight makes it so eerie, as you said, life is happening all around her but she’s stuck with this endless battle 

My only wish for the MV is that it would end with a scene of her getting hit by the car, emphasizing the whole cycle theme

[princedeeblebleble 3,860]

Kinda wish Disease got the BUDGET of you and I. The fashion, cinematography, special effects, storytelling and everything else is so much better in you and I. Love the horrory vibes of Disease and the things happening, especially the her walking on herself scenes were cvnt as fvck, but I wish we got some more iconic looks like the mistress purse face look. 

[Bradley 60,454]

I voted for Disease but Taylor Kinney makes You and I special

Edited 10 hours ago by Bradley

[HermesG 1,724]

If Disease have one problem its the video.

[Head Empty 27,309]

To me both videos are a little sloppy and lack cohesion. Both in terms of storyline as well as production. I'd say there wasn't enough budget to properly execute all of the concepts that are in these videos, and it shows in the execution.

I would give Disease a slight edge, because at least the concepts match the vibe and themes of the song. For Yoü & I she went a little overboard and completely lost the meaning of the song.

[loveandpeace 2,153]

I love “Yoü and I” but it has so many different concepts crammed into one video that there are moments when you don’t even know what you’re watching. “Disease,” on the other hand, has one clear goal and executes it really well.

[StarstruckIllusion 53,718]

…are yall CRAZYYY?? Disease WIPES You and I’s vid with it’s ass