Perfect Illusion or Perfect Celebrity?

[NUTELLA 27,423]

11 minutes ago, Ladle Ghoulash said:

A.) Absolutely does. Top 15 versus Top 60 LG track.

B.) *see below*

Technically I didn't throw the first brick by bringing up Perfect Illusion...

Notorious Bean merely ASKED me where to aim a brick

Leave LoveDrug (a better song than Perfect Illusion in every possible way) out of this, harlot! 

Edited 13 hours ago by NUTELLA

[Ilia Malinin 2,934]

19 hours ago, NUTELLA said:

one of LG's best songs

i know that's right.  perfect celebrity CLEARS.

[NUTELLA 27,423]

6 minutes ago, Ilia Malinin said:

i know that's right.  perfect celebrity CLEARS.

Say it again into this megaphone, sir 📢

I'll concede this much, though: the first 7 seconds of Perfect Illusion are more intriguing/exciting/hype than the first 7 seconds of Perfect Celebrity

After that? ...any illusion of it being a good song is utterly shattered lol

The production on the verses of Perfect Celebrity are like a drug (to say nothing of the outro 🤩)

Edited 11 hours ago by NUTELLA

[Cherry Blues 383]

I'm surprised that Perfect Illusion has more than 20% - i thought the song was more unpopular. 

I just heard it yesterday and Joanne is so organic and soulful, i love it. 

Edited 11 hours ago by Cherry Blues

[PartySick 172,848]

2 hours ago, Ladle Ghoulash said:

The way PI mops the everloving **** out of LD lmao

It's like you've picked up one of my children by the ankles and used them to bludgeon the other

[NUTELLA 27,423]

1 minute ago, PartySick said:

It's like you've picked up one of my children by the ankles and used them to bludgeon the other

Ban her

[Ladle Ghoulash 53,728]

Just now, PartySick said:

It's like you've picked up one of my children by the ankles and used them to bludgeon the other

Tbf that’s how I feel in this thread, given that when I did a power ranking of Gaga’s discog, both PI and PC were right next to each other as 14 and 13 

I genuinely don’t get the PI hate, tbh. A song about deep seated disillusionment and failure to achieve catharsis that feels like vomiting up your soul is, imo, not only one of the most ambitious and nuanced vibes she’s gone for, but it also just rips. 

[Ladle Ghoulash 53,728]

1 minute ago, NUTELLA said:

Ban her

Uh huh. Anyway, your noodles are getting cold, sister.

[NUTELLA 27,423]

@PartySick shall we share a plate of The Right Stuff?

[PartySick 172,848]

28 minutes ago, NUTELLA said:

Ban her

But then who will you have an unrequited crush on?

[PartySick 172,848]

27 minutes ago, Ladle Ghoulash said:

Tbf that’s how I feel in this thread, given that when I did a power ranking of Gaga’s discog, both PI and PC were right next to each other as 14 and 13 

I genuinely don’t get the PI hate, tbh. A song about deep seated disillusionment and failure to achieve catharsis that feels like vomiting up your soul is, imo, not only one of the most ambitious and nuanced vibes she’s gone for, but it also just rips. 

Ironically, what I said about LoveDrug in that safe thread is also how I feel about PI  

"It wasn't love" x57 but it slaps the whole time and kinda sends you into a spiral if you think about it too much  

[DESTROY UR DISEASE 20,190]

1 minute ago, PartySick said:

But then who will you have an unrequited crush on?

you can always ban both of them

[NUTELLA 27,423]

1 minute ago, PartySick said:

But then who will you have an unrequited crush on?

Like ripping off a band-aid, I'm removing this pic from my wallet & ripping it up

[PartySick 172,848]

Just now, DESTROY UR DISEASE said:

you can always ban both of them

Yeah but I think the arguments the two of them get into (with each other or others) basically consists of half the content on this site now and we need the ad payola 🤑 

[Bronco 25,558]

2 minutes ago, PartySick said:

Yeah but I think the arguments the two of them get into (with each other or others) basically consists of half the content on this site now and we need the ad payola 🤑 

Even here ragebait sells 

Now let me do my bit for my country and go fight a b*tch