Abracadabra VS. Joanne & Chromatica Albums Combined

[Ophelia 5,378]

Abra is better and i usually rank it in the lower half/middle of my Mayhem ranking

[Ophelia 5,378]

48 minutes ago, Controversiaga said:

Jamaica is her best album

a lead single ft. adele? their minds! 

[Decodekid 30,401]

Inb4 abracadabra vs lady gaga herself

[Controversiaga 15,670]

1 hour ago, Decodekid said:

Inb4 abracadabra vs lady gaga herself

Omfg wait this is genius please make the thread 

[princedeeblebleble 3,413]

7 hours ago, AVeryGagaHolyDick said:

I feel you but I wouldn’t go that far 

ASIB is absolutely precious. Not only is it phenomenal and a pivotal point in Gaga’s career — it will be remembered by nearly everyone for a LONG time. And the soundtrack has won an Oscar, four GRAMMYs, has had two songs nominated for Song Of The Year and eventually has the most awarded song in history 

Still doesn't erase the fact that Shallow is one my least fave Gaga songs  the only songs I enjoyed off that soundtrack were Heal me, I'll never love again and Always remember us this way.

[KindnessPunk 2,459]

Abra is a really great song but I think I connect with more tracks on Joanne and Chromatica 

[Nagini 4,090]

Just now, princedeeblebleble said:

Still doesn't erase the fact that Shallow is one my least fave Gaga songs  the only songs I enjoyed off that soundtrack were Heal me, I'll never love again and Always remember us this way.

It's crazy how the fans hate her biggest GP hits (Shallow, DWAS). Those are not bad songs y'all. Of course we love the more creative tracks (Abra, Disease, VIY, etc.) but if there's one thing Gaga can do is write a ballad.

It's even more absurd to be that ARUTW wasn't sent to radio despite it having 1B+ streams... if that's any sign, it would've been bigger than DWAS. I've given up hope about her & her label's business choices tho lol. 

[Nagini 4,090]

I would take 1 Abracadabra over all of Chromatica and Joanne combined. Such a good song 

[TAIPEI 3,316]

ABRACADABRA IS THAT BI*CH
chromatica is great and I really love it, but joanne is dead weight (in this option)

Edited 1 hour ago by TAIPEI

[RochesterJoannster 4,017]

Do ARTPOP instead of Joanne and I’ll agree

Or The Fame actually. Debra also clears.

Edited 1 hour ago by RochesterJoannster

[Nagini 4,090]

I do want her to make another Joanne... but like for real this time with no stupid country bent. Straight ballads, acoustic, raw voice & instruments. 

[princedeeblebleble 3,413]

18 minutes ago, Nagini said:

It's crazy how the fans hate her biggest GP hits (Shallow, DWAS). Those are not bad songs y'all. Of course we love the more creative tracks (Abra, Disease, VIY, etc.) but if there's one thing Gaga can do is write a ballad.

It's even more absurd to be that ARUTW wasn't sent to radio despite it having 1B+ streams... if that's any sign, it would've been bigger than DWAS. I've given up hope about her & her label's business choices tho lol. 

I adore DWAS thou :p but with Shallow I just don't enjoy Bradley s voice, and I hate the bridge, she somehow managed to make it less pleasant than the Killah scream 

[Bloody Michael 169]

Make it Abra without the MV, the choreo, the bridge, the chorus and the post chorus so it is a fair discussion. 

[Chromanne 2,555]

I really love a lot of tracks from Joanne and Chromatica like Diamond Heart, A-YO, Joanne, Alice, Rain On Me, 911, Replay etc as much as Abracadabra. So if you combine all songs from Joanne and Chromatica against Abracadabra, I'll choose those pink albums.

Also. A-YO alone clears Abracadabra, Debra is just lucky that Gaga didn't release A-YO as a single.

Edited 6 minutes ago by Chromanne