Which 20 songs should be on Gaga's Greatest Hits if released today?

[Controversiaga 15,660]

9 hours ago, princedeeblebleble said:

I'd maybe swap Judas or You and II for Marry the night and I'll never Love again for Disease :P 

Marry the night and Disease is a “greatest hit” ?????? Gurl 

[Controversiaga 15,660]

9 hours ago, Blackout19 said:

1. Just Dance
2. Poker Face
3. Bad Roamnce 
4. Telephone
5. Alejandro
6. Born This Way
7. Heavy Metal Lover
8. Applause
9. Perfect Illusion
10. Milion Reasons
11. Shallow
12. Rain On Me
13. Free Woman
14. 911
15. Abracadabra
16. Vanish Into You
17. Die With A Smile
18. Runway
19. new song
20. new song

PERFECT ILLUSION IS A “GREATEST HIT” ????

Free woman???????  
 

yall 

[Controversiaga 15,660]

2 hours ago, Anderson123 said:

1. Just Dance
2. Poker Face
3. Paparazzi
4. Bad Romance
5. Telephone
6. Alejandro
7. Born This Way
8. Judas
9. You and I
10. The Edge of Glory
11. Applause
12. Million Reasons
13. Stupid Love (or Bloody Mary)
14. Rain On Me
15. Shallow
16. Always Remember Us This Way
17. Hold My Hand
18. Disease
19. Abracadabra
20. Die With A Smile

Expanded Edition:

Lovegame, GUY, Perfect Illusion, 911, Vanish Into You, Marry The Night.

STUPID LOVE ??????!!!!!!!!!? A GREATEST HIT ????

 

WTF IS GOING ON HERE

[Controversiaga 15,660]

Okay how about we do GREATEST FLOPS EP - cause seems like yall don’t know the different between a FLOP and a HIT:

 

Judas

Marry The Night

GUY

Perfect Illusion

AYO

The Cure

Stupid Love

Disease

The Dead Dance

Runway

Edited 3 hours ago by Controversiaga

[Ivy 13,686]

Just Dance 

LoveGame 

Paparazzi 

Poker Face 

Bad Romance 

Alejandro 

Telephone 

Born This Way 

Judas 

Bloody Mary (still feels weird to add it)

You And I 

The Edge Of Glory 

Applause 

Million Reasons 

Shallow 

Always Remember Us This Way

Rain On Me

Die With A Smile 

Abracadabra 

Vanish Into You  

[Ivy 13,686]

12 minutes ago, Controversiaga said:

Okay how about we do GREATEST FLOPS EP - cause seems like yall don’t know the different between a FLOP and a HIT:

 

Judas

Marry The Night

GUY

Perfect Illusion

AYO

The Cure

Stupid Love

Disease

The Dead Dance

Runway

But Judas has over 1B spotify streams? It's in her 10 most popular there 

[Controversiaga 15,660]

8 minutes ago, Ivy said:

But Judas has over 1B spotify streams? It's in her 10 most popular there 

Fair. But Was a flop in its day tho 

[Ladle Ghoulash 50,501]

40 minutes ago, TheFrenchGuy said:

Included for the sake of variety in the tracklist, but I honestly wouldn’t want to put either Applause or SL on here and was even on the fence about LG lol

[Ladle Ghoulash 50,501]

37 minutes ago, Controversiaga said:

Marry the night and Disease is a “greatest hit” ?????? Gurl 

You know artists often put either minor hits or deep cuts in their greatest hit collections, right? Lol

[Controversiaga 15,660]

34 minutes ago, Ladle Ghoulash said:

You know artists often put either minor hits or deep cuts in their greatest hit collections, right? Lol

Sure but we’re limited to 20 and sadly none of those songs would make her top 20 greatest hits, as the other songs outperformed them so it wouldn’t make sense to leave them out in place of flop singles 

Edited 2 hours ago by Controversiaga

[Ilia Malinin 2,786]

10 hours ago, Blackout19 said:

3. Bad Roamnce 

[TEANUS 16,139]

Poker Face

Bad Romance

Just Dance

Telephone

Born This Way

LoveGame

Paparazzi

Alejandro

The Edge of Glory

Yoü and I

Judas

Applause

Shallow

Million Reasons

Die With A Smile

Always Remember Us This Way

Stupid Love

Bloody Mary

Rain On Me

Abracadabra

[TheFrenchGuy 5,399]

1 hour ago, Ladle Ghoulash said:

Included for the sake of variety in the tracklist, but I honestly wouldn’t want to put either Applause or SL on here and was even on the fence about LG lol

What about Shape of a Woman 

[SevenWonder 4,729]

13 hours ago, SimonBaetens said:

Mine would go:

1. Just Dance
2. Poker Face
3. Paparazzi
4. LoveGame

5. Bad Romance
6. Telephone
7. Alejandro

8. Born This Way
9. Bloody Mary
10. Judas
11. Yoü and I
12. The Edge Of Glory

13. Applause

14. Million Reasons

15. Shallow
16. Always Remember Us This Way
17. I'll Never Love Again

18. Rain On Me

19. Abracadabra
20. Die With A Smile

(not necessarily in this order, did this to be comprehensible) 

This is actually a perfectly curated Greatest Hits list. It's not Our Favorite Songs List. (Not having Marry the Night hurts, but it's the right choice given the assignment.)