Madonna's might get her first Billboard Hot 100 song since 2015

[JohnPokerface 162]

good for her (in my MC voice).

[Gagaplayer315 14,651]

But I thought a collab guaranteed a hit 

[Anderson123 42,047]

Everyone say Thank U Sabrina Carpenter.

[Lucas 30,544]

Y'all need to stop with the Madonna hate based on charts positions  she absolutely destroys Gaga in commercial success. Gaga won't be debuting in the hot 100 either when she's 67

Edited May 11 by Lucas

[Madame Goo Goo 4,127]

56 minutes ago, Bronco said:

Wasn't a Madonna release, it was a Weeknd release she was part of. 

Okay but that doesn’t change the fact that the title of this thread is still wrong lol

[juicyjuicy 2,004]

This song never really goes anywhere...disappointed tbh. Excited for the rest of her album though!

[Jarvin 1,428]

51 minutes ago, Lucas said:

Y'all need to stop with the Madonna hate based on charts positions  she absolutely destroys Gaga in commercial success. Gaga won't be debuting in the hot 100 either when she's 67

Well i like madonna but bieeeech. Im sure Gaga could still write fantastic ballads, rock songs or even Jazz tracks in case she may not find chartable succes in pop. Dont compare these two.  Let’s be real; Gaga has many many cards to play to get a hit at that age.

[monketsharona 89,939]

#71 for a collab the biggest hit girl of the moment is tragic though

[monstertoronto 11,386]

1 hour ago, Lucas said:

Y'all need to stop with the Madonna hate based on charts positions  she absolutely destroys Gaga in commercial success. Gaga won't be debuting in the hot 100 either when she's 67

Honestly. The fact people try to bully Madonna for not being as successful as brand new pop girls is insane. I would bet probably none of the acts that are popular today will even be trying to make new music when they’re 67. I actually think the only possible exception is Gaga tbh. She has music in her bones and I can see her doing jazz shows for example until she’s old and gray, and I could see a situation where she tries for a pop success too, but the hot 100 will be long gone by then 

Edited May 11 by monstertoronto

[Bronco 22,652]

1 hour ago, Madame Goo Goo said:

Okay but that doesn’t change the fact that the title of this thread is still wrong lol

I mean - all madonna fan sites are saying the same thing.

Because this is the first Madonna single to chart since Bitch I'm Madonna. 

Medellin, Crave, God Control, I Rise, I Don't Search I Find - none charted on the Hot 100. None of the remixes she released before the Celebration tour charted.

The only chart entry was a glorified feature. So yeah it is her first chart entry in 11 years. 

[Bronco 22,652]

53 minutes ago, Jarvin said:

Well i like madonna but bieeeech. Im sure Gaga could still write fantastic ballads, rock songs or even Jazz tracks in case she may not find chartable succes in pop. Dont compare these two.  Let’s be real; Gaga has many many cards to play to get a hit at that age.

I mean Gaga absolutely has a lot of things in her wheelhouse. 

But lets not use the Jazz as an example. Jazz barely charts now while the generation who liked it most are still here 😅 By the time we're all 60 Jazz fans will be as rare as dinosaurs.

[Brie Candy 18,650]

3 hours ago, Lucas said:

Y'all need to stop with the Madonna hate based on charts positions  she absolutely destroys Gaga in commercial success. Gaga won't be debuting in the hot 100 either when she's 67

Gaga probably won’t be debuting on the Hot 100 at 67 because at this rate Billboard itself won’t even survive its own unserious rules, radio payola, and random editorial gymnastics

Meanwhile Gaga will still be out there thriving, acclaimed, and recognized by the general public because talent and artistry age a lot better than chart discourse. She has actual artistic essence, insane versatility, and the ability to master different genres without looking forced. That’s why every generation connects with her

And before y’all start: Madonna is a legend, nobody’s denying that. But using her legacy to talk down on Gaga on a Gaga forum is very weird behavior, babe 

[Lucas 30,544]

7 minutes ago, Brie Candy said:

Gaga probably won’t be debuting on the Hot 100 at 67 because at this rate Billboard itself won’t even survive its own unserious rules, radio payola, and random editorial gymnastics

Meanwhile Gaga will still be out there thriving, acclaimed, and recognized by the general public because talent and artistry age a lot better than chart discourse. She has actual artistic essence, insane versatility, and the ability to master different genres without looking forced. That’s why every generation connects with her

And before y’all start: Madonna is a legend, nobody’s denying that. But using her legacy to talk down on Gaga on a Gaga forum is very weird behavior, babe 

"Babe", I'm not talking badly about Gaga and my point clearly flew over your head.

It's even weirder to think that "X is doing better than Gaga" is an attack on Gaga and that Gaga criticism is totally prohibited, it's straight up MAGA behaviour. Good luck!

[Brie Candy 18,650]

23 minutes ago, Lucas said:

"Babe", I'm not talking badly about Gaga and my point clearly flew over your head.

It's even weirder to think that "X is doing better than Gaga" is an attack on Gaga and that Gaga criticism is totally prohibited, it's straight up MAGA behaviour. Good luck!

You literally started by framing it as “Madonna destroys Gaga” in terms of chart success, and then acted surprised when that tone was read as competitive or dismissive.

It’s completely fine to discuss chart history or compare commercial trajectories. The issue is the inconsistency in framing: on one hand asking for respect toward Madonna’s legacy, and on the other using language that positions Gaga as inherently lesser in order to elevate that legacy.

Criticism of Gaga isn’t the point here; reducing her work to a hierarchy to assert superiority is. If the argument is about Madonna’s chart journey, it doesn’t need to be built on diminishing Gaga to make it valid.

So yes, it makes sense. It just needs consistency: you can respect Madonna’s achievements without turning Gaga into a rhetorical contrast piece

[holy scheisse 22,830]

I wouldn’t bully Madonna for her chart performance however it’s hilarious she collaborated with Sabrina carpenter so clearly in an effort to perform well on the charts lol