Better Album: MDNA vs 143

[Ladle Ghoulash 36,880]

1 minute ago, Economy said:

TTPD says hi 

I don’t even fw with Taylor like that, but all of the Aaron Dessner tracks on TTPD slap. Easily mops 143. 

[Economy 51,840]

5 minutes ago, Ladle Ghoulash said:

I don’t even fw with Taylor like that, but all of the Aaron Dessner tracks on TTPD slap. Easily mops 143. 

But 143 has:

 

Gimme Gimme

Gorgeous

Crush

Truth (my fav on 143) 

OK

 

At least those 5 songs I think are really good. I do not like 5 songs on Taylors last 2 albums

 

[PartySick 167,813]

The cackle I cookled when I clicked MDNA and the results showed

[ActualPatient 2,194]

11 hours ago, elsamars said:

Can you take your vote back?

if you change your pfp wtf miss maam

[Idefix1999 275]

MDNA is a solid album.

143 could have gone differently, calling if "Lifetimes" and make Lifetimes, Wonder, All The Love singles. Those are typical KP songs (although not on a lower level than her classics). Also MDNA would have been received better if she didn't start off with GMAYL, which seemed kinda desperare to somehow draw attention.

[Auralegends 7,902]

I voted for 143 since I don't know most of the songs on MDNA.

 

143 has some nice catchy songs like Crush (should've been a single), All the Love, Artificial, Nirvana (And No More Tears for New Year's on the 1432 album)

[ANVEEROY 62,663]

20 hours ago, Controversiaga said:

I don’t think a single person here will vote for 123

two people did 

[ANVEEROY 62,663]

20 hours ago, Bronco said:

I'm Addicted on the MDNA tour was ****ing epic. 

godly

[Chromanne 2,196]

I haven't listened to MDNA but I'm still voting for it. I trust my instincts that any album will be objectively better than 143 

[Ladle Ghoulash 36,880]

11 hours ago, Economy said:

But 143 has:

 

Gimme Gimme

Gorgeous

Crush

Truth (my fav on 143) 

OK

 

At least those 5 songs I think are really good. I do not like 5 songs on Taylors last 2 albums

 

Praying for you, sister.

[Agunimon 315]

I voted for MDNA based on overall quality alone, but I would rather listen to 143. It's a fun album to listen to at the gym.

Also please stop grouping 143 with TTPD. Certainly Showgirl can sit aside with 143, but TTPD has some amazing songs on it even if the entire thing may not be your thing. People making comments like that probably haven't even listened to that album in full. There is in no world where 143 is on the same level as Chloe or Sam or Sophia or Marcus, The Bolter, How Did It End, The Prophecy, Guilty As Sin, Fortnight, Fresh Out The Slammer, The Black Dog, The Albatross, etc. Please. 

Edited 21 hours ago by Agunimon

[Economy 51,840]

47 minutes ago, Agunimon said:

I voted for MDNA based on overall quality alone, but I would rather listen to 143. It's a fun album to listen to at the gym.

Also please stop grouping 143 with TTPD. Certainly Showgirl can sit aside with 143, but TTPD has some amazing songs on it even if the entire thing may not be your thing. People making comments like that probably haven't even listened to that album in full. There is in no world where 143 is on the same level as Chloe or Sam or Sophia or Marcus, The Bolter, How Did It End, The Prophecy, Guilty As Sin, Fortnight, Fresh Out The Slammer, The Black Dog, The Albatross, etc. Please. 

Im the one who mentioned TTPD and I DID listen to it in full

 

My comment was to say i have at least 5 songs on 143 I really like which I cant say the same for TTPD, in essance saying 143 is not THAT bad. Thats ultimately all my point was. Ur saying with TTPD "even if its not your thing", but personal taste is literally all I was commenting on because this thread OP is literally asking about preferance

 

It was not a technical analysis on which one is more proffesionally made. If u think thats what I was getting at, i think ur taking my comments too deep and too seriously. Im literally just saying I enjoy 143 more than a lot of albums out there and so i dont think its really that bad. Thats really all my main point was

[Controversiaga 12,619]

2 hours ago, ANVEEROY said:

two people did 

Well ban them 

[palma 8,666]

They are both terrible but MDNA has GGW and Masterpiece so 

[Killa 18,236]

Im voting and i think i haven't listened tò these two albums back tò back

Typical ex twink behaviour