17-track Born This Way vs 17-track MAYHEM

[Taumaturg0 587]

1. Marry the Night vs. Disease
2. Born This Way vs. Abracadabra
3. Government Hooker vs. Garden of Eden
4. Judas vs. Perfect Celebrity
5. Americano vs. Can't Stop the High
6. Hair vs. Vanish Into You
7. Scheiße vs. Killah
8. Bloody Mary vs. Zombieboy
9. Black Jesus + Amen Fashion vs. The Dead Dance (recency bias ? maybe)
10. Bad Kids vs. LoveDrug
11. Fashion of His Love vs. How Bad Do U Want Me
12. Highway Unicorn vs. Don't Call Tonight
13. Heavy Metal Lover vs. Kill for Love
14. Electric Chapel vs. Shadow of a Man
15. The Queen vs. The Beast
16. Yoü and I vs. Blade of Grass
17. The Edge of Glory vs. Die With a Smile

BTW: 7

Mayhem: 10

[The Fame Monster 4,388]

1. Marry the Night vs. Disease
2. Born This Way vs. Abracadabra
3. Government Hooker vs. Garden of Eden
4. Judas vs. Perfect Celebrity
5. Americano vs. Can't Stop the High
6. Hair vs. Vanish Into You
7. Scheiße vs. Killah
8. Bloody Mary vs. Zombieboy
9. Black Jesus + Amen Fashion vs. The Dead Dance
10. Bad Kids vs. LoveDrug
11. Fashion of His Love vs. How Bad Do U Want Me
12. Highway Unicorn vs. Don't Call Tonight
13. Heavy Metal Lover vs. Kill for Love
14. Electric Chapel vs. Shadow of a Man
15. The Queen vs. The Beast
16. Yoü and I vs. Blade of Grass
17. The Edge of Glory vs. Die With a Smile

Born This Way (2) | MAYHEM (15)

I think I’ve listened to Born This Way so much that most of its songs have lost their appeal compared to MAYHEM.

[brizoda 3,869]

Senior Member

 7,863

Posted 1 hour ago (edited)

Now that we have 17 tracks for two of Gaga's best alberms I think it's only natural we celebrate with another poll 

Choose the better track of the two based on their appearance on the track list 

1. Disease
2. Abracadabra
3. Garden of Eden
4. Judas
5. Americano
6. Vanish Into You
7. Scheiße
8. Zombieboy
9. The Dead Dance
10. LoveDrug
11. How Bad Do U Want Me
12. Don't Call Tonight
13. Kill for Love
14. Shadow of a Man
15. The Queen
16. Blade of Grass
17. Die With a Smile

My rihsults: BTW: 4 vs. MAYHEM: 13

[dynamite 59,894]

1. Marry the Night vs. Disease

2. Born This Way vs. Abracadabra

3. Government Hooker vs. Garden of Eden

4. Judas vs. Perfect Celebrity

5. Americano vs. Can't Stop the High

6. Hair vs. Vanish Into You

7. Scheiße vs. Killah

8. Bloody Mary vs. Zombieboy

9. Black Jesus + Amen Fashion vs. The Dead Dance - haven't heard it yet idk

10. Bad Kids vs. LoveDrug

11. Fashion of His Love vs. How Bad Do U Want Me

12. Highway Unicorn vs. Don't Call Tonight

13. Heavy Metal Lover vs. Kill for Love

14. Electric Chapel vs. Shadow of a Man

15. The Queen vs. The Beast

16. Yoü and I vs. Blade of Grass

17. The Edge of Glory vs. Die With a Smile

[Prigari 902]

1. Marry the Night vs. Disease
2. Born This Way vs. Abracadabra
3. Government Hooker vs. Garden of Eden
4. Judas vs. Perfect Celebrity
5. Americano vs. Can't Stop the High
6. Hair vs. Vanish Into You
7. Scheiße vs. Killah
8. Bloody Mary vs. Zombieboy
9. Black Jesus + Amen Fashion vs. The Dead Dance
10. Bad Kids vs. LoveDrug
11. Fashion of His Love vs. How Bad Do U Want Me
12. Highway Unicorn vs. Don't Call Tonight
13. Heavy Metal Lover vs. Kill for Love
14. Electric Chapel vs. Shadow of a Man
15. The Queen vs. The Beast
16. Yoü and I vs. Blade of Grass
17. The Edge of Glory vs. Die With a Smile

BTW : 10

Mayhem : 7

[palma 8,001]

2 minutes ago, dynamite said:

9. Black Jesus + Amen Fashion vs. The Dead Dance - haven't heard it yet idk

Well it ain't gonna play itself 

Do the dead dance! 

[NemoMyName 865]

I know is not the point of this thread but the extra tracks of BTW never did anything to me.

[Blackout19 12,132]

1. Marry the Night vs. Disease
2. Born This Way vs. Abracadabra
3. Government Hooker vs. Garden of Eden
4. Judas vs. Perfect Celebrity
5. Americano vs. Can't Stop the High
6. Hair vs. Vanish Into You
7. Scheiße vs. Killah
8. Bloody Mary vs. Zombieboy
9. Black Jesus + Amen Fashion vs. The Dead Dance
10. Bad Kids vs. LoveDrug
11. Fashion of His Love vs. How Bad Do U Want Me
12. Highway Unicorn vs. Don't Call Tonight
13. Heavy Metal Lover vs. Kill for Love
14. Electric Chapel vs. Shadow of a Man
15. The Queen vs. The Beast
16. Yoü and I vs. Blade of Grass
17. The Edge of Glory vs. Die With a Smile

[Luke78619 23,384]

I expect to be surprised by my opinion here  

1. Marry the Night vs. Disease
2. Born This Way vs. Abracadabra
3. Government Hooker vs. Garden of Eden
4. Judas vs. Perfect Celebrity
5. Americano vs. Can't Stop the High
6. Hair vs. Vanish Into You
7. Scheiße vs. Killah
8. Bloody Mary vs. Zombieboy
9. Black Jesus + Amen Fashion vs. The Dead Dance
10. Bad Kids vs. LoveDrug
11. Fashion of His Love vs. How Bad Do U Want Me
12. Highway Unicorn vs. Don't Call Tonight
13. Heavy Metal Lover vs. Kill for Love
14. Electric Chapel vs. Shadow of a Man
15. The Queen vs. The Beast
16. Yoü and I vs. Blade of Grass
17. The Edge of Glory vs. Die With a Smile

10 BTW, 7 Mayhem, was actually what I was expecting  some of these were hard, I kept switching tracks 4 and 17 

[Lucas 27,207]

1. Marry the Night vs. Disease
2. Born This Way vs. Abracadabra
3. Government Hooker vs. Garden of Eden
4. Judas vs. Perfect Celebrity
5. Americano vs. Can't Stop the High
6. Hair vs. Vanish Into You
7. Scheiße vs. Killah
8. Bloody Mary vs. Zombieboy
9. Black Jesus + Amen Fashion vs. The Dead Dance
10. Bad Kids vs. LoveDrug
11. Fashion of His Love vs. How Bad Do U Want Me
12. Highway Unicorn vs. Don't Call Tonight
13. Heavy Metal Lover vs. Kill for Love
14. Electric Chapel vs. Shadow of a Man
15. The Queen vs. The Beast
16. Yoü and I vs. Blade of Grass
17. The Edge of Glory vs. Die With a Smile

Born This Way 16 - 1 Mayhem 

I love Mayhem but Born This Way truly is the definition of a masterpiece

[Controversiaga 11,466]

Wait dead dance is track number 9?? How do we know this

[qoqo 3,746]

1. Disease

2. Abracadabra

3. Garden Of Eden

4. Judas

5. Can’t Stop The High

6. Vanish Into You

7. Killah

8. I can’t choose between Blood Mary and Zombieboy, sorry

9. The Dead Dance

10. Bad Kids

11. Fashion Of His Love

12. Don’t Call Tonight

13. Heavy Metal Lover

14. Shadow Of A Man

15. The Beast

16. Yoü And I

17. Die With A Smile

 

Born This Way 6

Mayhem 12

[Ladle Ghoulash 26,099]

55 minutes ago, Controversiaga said:

Wait dead dance is track number 9?? How do we know this

[pratz 1,440]

1. Marry the Night vs. Disease
2. Born This Way vs. Abracadabra
3. Government Hooker vs. Garden of Eden
4. Judas vs. Perfect Celebrity
5. Americano vs. Can't Stop the High
6. Hair vs. Vanish Into You
7. Scheiße vs. Killah
8. Bloody Mary vs. Zombieboy
9. Black Jesus + Amen Fashion vs. The Dead Dance
10. Bad Kids vs. LoveDrug
11. Fashion of His Love vs. How Bad Do U Want Me
12. Highway Unicorn vs. Don't Call Tonight
13. Heavy Metal Lover vs. Kill for Love
14. Electric Chapel vs. Shadow of a Man
15. The Queen vs. The Beast
16. Yoü and I vs. Blade of Grass
17. The Edge of Glory vs. Die With a Smile

Mayhem = 9
BTW = 8
Tie = 1

[Wombat 109]

1. Marry the Night vs. Disease
2. Born This Way vs. Abracadabra
3. Government Hooker vs. Garden of Eden
4. Judas vs. Perfect Celebrity
5. Americano vs. Can't Stop the High
6. Hair vs. Vanish Into You
7. Scheiße vs. Killah
8. Bloody Mary vs. Zombieboy (oml this is impossible)
9. Black Jesus + Amen Fashion vs. The Dead Dance
10. Bad Kids vs. LoveDrug
11. Fashion of His Love vs. How Bad Do U Want Me
12. Highway Unicorn vs. Don't Call Tonight
13. Heavy Metal Lover vs. Kill for Love
14. Electric Chapel vs. Shadow of a Man
15. The Queen vs. The Beast
16. Yoü and I vs. Blade of Grass
17. The Edge of Glory vs. Die With a Smile

BTW: 6

MAYHEM: 9

TIE: 1

wow MAYHEM eats as a whole project