Better Song: Replay vs Disease

[GAGASEXUAL 3,891]

Disease might even be her best song ever ngl

[REALITY 78,380]

I’m kinda shocked that so many of y’all are saying Disease “easily” clears Replay  I love both songs, but I gotta go with Replay on this one 

[Gagaism 12,353]

I’m sorry but I’ll never understand the appeal for Replay. It’s not a bad song but like, often overrated? 

[nATAH 52,615]

Disease effortlessly clears not even her own discography, but the discography of many other great legends and flops

shame on you interscope for not pulling out all the stops for this masterpiece, you WILL be dealt with

[nATAH 52,615]

9 minutes ago, Gagaism said:

I’m sorry but I’ll never understand the appeal for Replay. It’s not a bad song but like, often overrated? 

for sure overrated, one of chromatica's best but like... far from the best compared to her other albums

Edited August 6, 2025 by nATAH

[LauraPalmer 1,772]

Disease clears 

[BellaFahmi 1,005]

Replay is easily my favorite from Chromatica and one of my fav Gaga songs but Disease is just otherworldly. I truly believe it's the best song she's ever made.

[Murakami27 6,462]

Replay is overrated. 
 

Disease is literally one of her best ever. 

[Horny Chicken 9,832]

The problem is that Replay was so good live but Disease is better on streaming. 

[nodandsmile 11,351]

this is kinda the toughest one of these "better song" threads

 

[Gorehound 4,950]

Those picking Replay over Disease is kinda concerning lol 

I get that Replay might be your preferred taste, but it's pretty obvious to anyone with half a brain that Disease is a far more sophisticated and well crafted piece of music, regardless of personal preference. 

[Starmie25 20,544]

Oooh lyrically it has to go to RESLEIGH

[BLOODANDSEMEN 351]

no.

[Nicklev 1,086]

Disease is such a great song. I remember everybody going crazy about it when it got released. Then a lot disappointed on Mayhem not being like it. 

Replay is just Replay. 

You can't compare impact or quality.

[REALITY 78,380]

The revisionist history with Replay is kinda wild 

What’s next, y’all are gonna say Vanish Into You and Abracadabra are overrated pieces of sh*t next era??

Edited August 6, 2025 by REALITY