Who choreographed Scheisse better?

[bpmMonkey 5,364]

imo what Paris does so so well is the theatrics of it all, which we saw in disease mv and a lot of y'all said was not choreographed. The second Gaga hits the stage it's pure joy to look at her, the dancers behind the table and all of that. Where she lacks for me in comparison to Richy is the actual dance portion (and she slayed Abra mv, but partially because it was a blank page to work with) 

edit: it's the tentacle arms of it all, i don't like them. OG choreo is so much tighter and closer to the body, it just works better for me. 

Edited Wednesday at 03:33 PM by bpmMonkey

[vmpiregrn 869]

BTWB choreo is better but we obviously can’t expect Gaga to ever do that choreo again, it’s what broke her (in tandem I’m sure with her schedule and not treating her body well enough between performances)

[Borislshere 52,888]

Not even gonna lie but I prefer 90% of Ricky’s choreo to Paris. That’s not me picking him as a person cause f*ck him

[MACATL 1,323]

I LOVE the feathers and overall creative staging of Paris’ better.  It’s more interesting and surprising.    I like the actual dance choreo if Richy’s  better. 

[SEANGT 5,176]

lord watching that back instead of relying on memory, Parris did waYYYYY better like I was actually entertained the whole time. Richy's got boring with so many weird little movements. 

[VOLANTIS 16,374]

The production for the new version does it so well though and compliments the new choreo so well.

 

While I always appreciated the BTWB version and the breakdown, there's little to no production for that number besides the richy choreo. And I always found that weird considering so many numbers from BTWB are very well thought out and not heavily reliant simply on complex choreo. 

[princedeeblebleble 1,327]

I prefer Paris, its more theatre and a pure wow factor overall. And she looks far more comfortable and confident during this choreography than with the other *persons* choreo, where she looks lost most the time

[Plastic Flower 4,495]

Depends on the context. Paris' works great for the MAYHEM show, same for the OG on the BTWB. 
To be completely honest, the original BTWB performance isn’t as great imo.  It gets a bit boring. Better lightning could’ve done wonders but that’s my opinion on the entire show anyway. 

[elijahfan 25,871]

As much as it pains me to say, I absolutely loved the military, Janet inspired OG choreo  But I do love Parris’ featherography, one of my favorite parts of the show.

[PartySick 155,212]

We can all admit Parris > Richy

But also the classic choreo > the new one

[lastpopicon 21,849]

Coachella, much more iconic, not even close.

[Killa 17,163]

The beggining It gives a certain riverdance feel that i really love the ensemble effect but besides the singular movements.. the actual dancing, the Little steps the  complicated geometry, is so schematic and flows so bad. The dancing Is sooo much more amatorial. I knew It from Watching madonnas tours, Gagad dancing was so subpar. But now i really see the difference. Like they are counting and Watching where tò go. Its due tò the choreograher not doing something a bit more elegant and logical. Even if he wanted to be sort of militar. Its trchnically bad