One unpopular opinion per album era

[JolP24601 5]

The Fame: I Like It Rough, Paper Gangster, and Starstruck are still so underrated! Also, a really good debut album but I don't revisit it as much as the other albums.

The Fame Monster: I have no unpopular opinions. This is a perfect album to me.

Born This Way: Not my favorite Gaga album (although, it's not at the bottom). It's not bad but I just find some songs to be filler and I feel like I skip around to specific songs. I think if I had been a die hard fan at the time and got to experience the era, maybe I would've liked it more. Also, I'd love another song that sounds like Electric Chapel or Heavy Metal Lover!

ARTPOP: I really wish Brooklyn Nights was on this! As an album, I really do enjoy it and I'm not ashamed to admit that I like Jewels N' Drugs.

Cheek to Cheek/Love For Sale: I'm just combining these but I like these albums. They may be my least played albums but I do like to listen to both the duets with Tony and solo songs from time to time. Do I Love You? is one of my favorite Gaga covers.

Joanne: So, for years I deemed this my all-time favorite Gaga album (it was the one that I started being a full-time fan) and I still enjoy it but I do feel like my love for it has worn off a little. I feel it's probably because I played it too much and I find some of the second half of the album to be a bit skippable. Still, I do like how Gaga took a risk and tried something new.

A Star Is Born: I'm not a hundred percent sure this counts but I will say that Before I Cry is such an underrated song and I'd love to hear Gaga do another song with that sound.

Chromatica: I still think this is a great album! It really got me through lockdown and I still frequently return to it. I think there are only two songs that I don't come back to all the time but I still enjoy them when I listen to the album in full. I'll also add that Enigma is a great song and I hope she brings it back on tour.

Harlequin: I really like this album! I think the covers are fun and Gaga is able to make each song her own without it feeling like karaoke. I will say that Happy Mistake is still growing on me but I did love the live performance. 

Edited 16 hours ago by JolP24601
Realized I forgot a song.

[Hydrangea 5,205]

The fame - I like disco heaven more than most of the album 

the fame monster - I think speechless is a bit overrated 

born this way - I really feel like songs like the queen and black Jesus could’ve been left off and nothing would be lost

ARTPOP - I preferred the iTunes ball versions of the songs so much more. That swine performance lives in my head forever and I prefer the aura demo

Joanne - sonically it feels like a mash to me, not really as cohesive as it could or should be 

Chromatica - I literally forget that love me right exists

HQ - oh when the saints and good morning are just annoying songs in general and she didn’t really fix that with her renditions

[HermesGr 1,194]

LG1 (The Fame): 

-So many mediocre songs. Eh eh is meh meh

+Poker face was a bomb! I love Disco heaven 💗 

 

LG2 (The Fame Monster): 

-Should have been complete bigger album.

+Her real introduction. Dance in the dark is a masterpiece ✨

 

LG3 (Born This Way):

-Queen is huge filler and breaks the album quality.

+The other album is MAGIC. I adore Black Jesus 🤷🏻‍♂️

 

LG4 (ARTPOP): 

-The raw sexyness at times looks cheap aesthetic. I never liked Applause 😁 

+ Its not a bad album didn't deserve all that hate. I love Venus (should have been music video) and Aura.

 

LG5 (Joanne): 

-I know what happened to reinvent her look in GP eyes but i find it till now a really BAD album. Nothing above 5/10

+ 

 

LG6 (Chromatica):

-Stupid Love is not that bad but they destroy it with that crafty silly video. 

+Alice should have been the lead single with that pink Frankenstein suit. Replay second single. Sour Candy promo video.

 

[Celloo Deng 53,775]

TF - whilst it is appreciated by the GP, it is criminally underrated by the fanbase probably because a lot of them are too young to appreciate the slayage of the time. One of her best albums and pure pop genius.

TFM - her best album and Alejandro her best song.

BTW - it has high highs and low lows, overall it is a bit too messy and would have benefitted from cutting some of the filler.

ARTPOP - title track slays and is one of her best songs, she should do more of that style.

Joanne - Hey Girl is a great song and this album is underrated

Chromatica - Stupid Love is a bop!

Harlequin - WOAS and IMFCSMN are the best on the album 

Mayhem - Disease is amazing but I’m hoping for something more experimental to come from this album!

Edited 15 hours ago by Celloo Deng

[Blackout19 10,611]

2 hours ago, Kelly Atlantic said:

It should’ve replaced SHICD.

the best song on the album?! 

[Babylon Dynasty 1,801]

I can't think of many opinions but for LG6: Alice feels incomplete and even tho I like how it opens the album, I think is a weak song overall.

And Fun Tonight deserves its flowers too 

[Decodekid 27,088]

LG1. The Fame is probably one of her most cohesive and complete albums 

LG2. DITD could’ve been as monumental as BR 

LG3. Bad Kids is great, the real skip is Highway Unicorn  her best album regardless of anything tbh

LG4. As different as it is, this is her most cohesive work, and probably the one with the most interesting topics 

LG5. Good, but if she was truly going THIS alternative she shouldn’t have made it “too-pop safe” should’ve been full country/rock whatever you want to call it 

LG6.  Amazing album, often criticized for its production like y’all know a thing or two about it, that album was fun and needed, chill