“We’re not going back.” Forget TFM and BTW.

[HotLikeMexico 5,174]

1 hour ago, Shadow said:

It seems to have a grungy,  industrial sound like Nine Inch Nails/Marilyn Manson and gothic tones like Evanescence/the Pretty Reckless.  Comparisons are lazy, i acknowledge, but it's where my mind goes when listening to Disease.  

I love NIN but I don’t get how people keep saying this is like an NIN song. Disease is very industrial inspired, but I do not get NIN from it. 

[culturalbaptism 2,918]

2 hours ago, Didymus said:

Grunge and metal? Erm no. We don’t have to make **** up lol.

I know right? lmao it is nothing more than pop music with industrial synths nothing different from charli, sophie etc. 

Dead aunt is NOT a pop album is country and folk 

[Ladle Ghoulash 23,916]

4 minutes ago, culturalbaptism said:

I know right? lmao it is nothing more than pop music with industrial synths nothing different from charli, sophie etc. 

Dead aunt is NOT a pop album is country and folk 

Joanne is 100% a vintage pop record lmao 

[Shadow 6,625]

51 minutes ago, HotLikeMexico said:

I love NIN but I don’t get how people keep saying this is like an NIN song. Disease is very industrial inspired, but I do not get NIN from it. 

There are some songs from With Teeth, Year Zero, the Slip that have similar industrial sounds.  

Try listening to Disease and then NIN's Closer...

Edited October 27, 2024 by Shadow

[culturalbaptism 2,918]

2 minutes ago, Ladle Ghoulash said:

Joanne is 100% a vintage pop record lmao 

I still don't know how we all survived that era. Literally her worst album together with the jazz albums a hard no. I pretend that after ARTPOP comes a star is born. that is the true comeback and vintage pop record 

[Ladle Ghoulash 23,916]

42 minutes ago, culturalbaptism said:

I still don't know how we all survived that era. Literally her worst album together with the jazz albums a hard no. I pretend that after ARTPOP comes a star is born. that is the true comeback and vintage pop record 

OK 

 

[ThatsGossip111 243]

1 hour ago, Ladle Ghoulash said:

Joanne is 100% a vintage pop record lmao 

THANK YOU ! It’s all old school pop music, kinda like Harlequin. Music she grew up listening to and that had an influence on her artistry 

[RichAssPiss 4,921]

Disease is nothing like TFM or BTW. Superficially, it has some adjective overlap like "dark pop" but it's nothing like the 80s arena rock/European techno hybrid of BTW. It's missing most of her past signatures. It's pretty flat and linear without the syllable switching, the wordplay, the chanting. It's honestly like early  2000s nu-metal does dancefloor. 

[weed 73,785]

8 hours ago, Chlorine said:

Gaga reading this, thanking @Chlorine for explaining to everybody, and there’s squabbling about genre, missing the rest of the point.

[Blackout19 11,822]

[PSYCHOSHTICK 2,834]

9 hours ago, HotLikeMexico said:

I love NIN but I don’t get how people keep saying this is like an NIN song. Disease is very industrial inspired, but I do not get NIN from it. 

9 hours ago, Shadow said:

There are some songs from With Teeth, Year Zero, the Slip that have similar industrial sounds.  

Try listening to Disease and then NIN's Closer...

Disease’s bridge is literally an ode to the outro of Closer.
I’ve marked it:

2:44

4:22 (music video version)

 

[HotLikeMexico 5,174]

9 hours ago, Shadow said:

There are some songs from With Teeth, Year Zero, the Slip that have similar industrial sounds.  

Try listening to Disease and then NIN's Closer...

I just don’t hear the NIN similarities. I’m not saying she isn’t inspired by Trent, Disease is definitely industrial inspired, But that’s about it. I don’t think it’s sounds like a NIN track.

Closer is my favorite NIN track and I didn’t immediately think and still don’t think Disease sounded like it. Even with the example someone else provided at the outro, i think that just seems like a stretch. 

Personally Disease sounds like a Gesaffelstein song, and even more along the lines of electro-industrial ala KMFDM. 

Edited October 28, 2024 by HotLikeMexico

[HotLikeMexico 5,174]

14 minutes ago, PSYCHOSHTICK said:

Disease’s bridge is literally an ode to the outro of Closer.
I’ve marked it:

2:44

4:22 (music video version)

 

Yeah, I still think that’s a stretch. Sorry.

[Shadow 6,625]

6 hours ago, HotLikeMexico said:

I just don’t hear the NIN similarities. I’m not saying she isn’t inspired by Trent, Disease is definitely industrial inspired, But that’s about it. I don’t think it’s sounds like a NIN track.

Closer is my favorite NIN track and I didn’t immediately think and still don’t think Disease sounded like it. Even with the example someone else provided at the outro, i think that just seems like a stretch. 

Personally Disease sounds like a Gesaffelstein song, and even more along the lines of electro-industrial ala KMFDM. 

Perhaps I'm just so glad Lady Gaga is incorporating industrial sounds in her pop music again, it had me thinking NIN, but you may be right about it sounding more like KMFDM, I can hear the resemblance.

So would you say her industrial sounds have more of a German influence?  Electro-industrial is a sub-genre of industrial, which is a mix of rock influences and electronic music, so perhaps we're seeing different pieces of the same puzzle.

You mentioned Gesaffelstein.  Which tracks do you find the most similar to Disease?   

I still think her voice does sound like Amy Lee a bit.

 

 

 

 

 

 

[doppelganger 3,933]

The song is very Gaga and yet also very new.