Better first trailer?

[julz 7,120]

As we prepare for the Joker 2 first trailer tomorrow, let's look back and pit these two trailers  Which one gave you more excitement for its film? Gave you more shock value or very unexpected? Which trailer is very well made, editing, song choice, how Gaga's acting was showcased. Which trailer didnt give too much?

 

 

 

 

 

[julz 7,120]

For me it's ASIB because:

 - Shallow. I knew it's gonna be a big song of hers...that aaAaahhh. And it's a new song!

 - I like seeing Gaga in her natural form, raw. 

 - HoG gave too much in the trailer i think. 

 - i like the color grading in ASIB trailer.  I also like how they showed the title in the end.

[Dennis 8,391]

ASIB.

I was obsessed with the Shallow studio version. It just sounded BIG.

For HOG, I immediately knew the accent was gonna be an issue.

[Anderson123 38,379]

A Star Is Born easily. I was very excited about new Gaga music and curious to hear what she'd write for this. House of Gucci was fun but it was more about Gaga's acting skills and just the overall experience of seeing a cast of A list actors working together on this thriller drama / dark comedy.

[Future Lovers 6,914]

In a way they both achieved the same thing and that was show the quality of the respective film. 

ASIB’s trailer showed that it was going to be a beautiful film that is well acted, performed, and fully formed. 

HoG’s trailer showed it was going to be an absolute trainwreck with everyone involved completely missing the mark. 

ASIB’s trailer is better by sheer virtue of showing us a look at a better film. 

[Ivy 12,557]

ASIB, I think it represents the movie better and the way it mixes in the song gives so much emotion to it, it's perfect 

Gucci one is fun but it makes the movie seem more mysterious and exciting than it ended up unfortunately

[REALITY 76,593]

1000% ASIB. As soon as I saw the trailer for HOG, I knew it was going to be mediocre at best tbh  Something about it just felt off 

[Didymus 34,379]

ASIB is one of the best trailers of all time tbh.

[ImAnEnigma26 154]

HOG trailer is great, but I almost cried watching the ASIB trailer. That role completely changed the trajectory of her career. She is truly her own unique entity in the entertainment world. 

[NUTELLA 10,168]

I still haven't seen HoG, but I'm going to vote for that trailer because

Heart of Glass > Shallow lol

[AVeryGagaHolyDick 25,461]

Everything about A Star Is Born was great, and that trailer was spectacular. The music screamed #1 Oscar-and-Grammy-winning monster smash hit.

But for House of Gucci, Gaga’s looks are the only great thing, the rest being absolutely horrendous. THAT SONG WAS A CHOICE.

[Stephen 30,423]

hehe obviously asib looks better even in the teaser, but for some reason the gucci one got me more hyped probably bc it's so camp

[julz 7,120]

I must say, HoG actually made me think more than ASIB that Gaga was gonna take an acting Oscar, or nom. Plus the fact that it was too iconic, i mean Gaga's FatherSonandHoG line and the teacup scene.

[bestie 217]

ASIB 100% ... As soon as Gaga walked out of 250 Anni I knew we were in for a HOT MESS!

[River 116,823]

House of Oochi trailer was all over the place and had too many identical scenes from the movie, you could know all the plot, like for real, they evn told me that SHE killed him, that he's dead, like who does that, omg spoilers in the troilers