Ranking Born This Way

[Smother Em Eh 7,086]

1. Marry The Night
2. Bloody Mary
3. Judas
4. The Edge Of Glory
5. Government Hooker
6. Heavy Metal Lover
7. Scheibe
8. Electric Chapel
9. Americano
10. Hair
11. Born This Way 
12. You & I
13. Bad Kids
14. Highway Unicorn (Road To Love)
15. Black Jesus Amen Fashion
16. The Queen
17. Fashion Of His Love

[TimotheeChalamet 5,468]

1. You And I

2. The Edge Of Glory 

3. Scheiße

4. Bloody Mary 

5. Marry The Night

6. Born This Way

7. Judas

8. Government Hooker

9. Electric Chapel

10. Hair

11. Black Jesus + Amen Fashion 

12. Bad Kids

13. The Queen

14. Heavy Metal Lover

15. Americano 

16. Fashion Of His Love

17. Highway Unicorn (Road To Love) 

[A Fried Egg 8,367]

1. Scheiße

2. Judas

3. Born This Way

[Gorehound 4,518]

1. Heavy Metal Lover 

2. Judas

3. Scheiße

4. Government Hooker

5. Electric Chapel

6. Bloody Mary

7. The Edge Of Glory

8. Marry The Night

9. Hair

10. Highway Unicorn (Road To Love)

11. Born This Way

12. Americano...

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

13. Black Jesus + Amen Fashion, You And I, The Queen, Fashion Of His Love, Bad Kids 

[HIMe 1,934]

God Tier :

1. Scheisse (1800 plays) (should be up there with Shallow, PF, BR as signature song tbh)

Top Tier :

2. Bloody Mary (400 plays)

3. Heavy Metal Lover (380 plays)

4. Marry The Night (340 plays)

High Tier :

5. Hair (290 plays)

6. Judas (220 plays)

Mid Tier :

7. Bad Kids (150 plays)

8. Born This Way (140 plays)

Low Tier :

9. The Edge Of Glory (50 plays) (surprised by the lack of longevity)

10. Electric Chapel (30 plays)

Trash Tier :

11. You and I (9 plays)

12. Government Hooker (8 plays)

13. Americano (7 plays) 

14. Highway Unicorn (7 plays) 

15. Fashion Of His Love (3 plays)

16. Black Jesus (1 play) 

17. The Queen (1 play)

I created my lastfm account at the end of 2012, which was long after the initial "hype" of the era, which also gives me a much better and accurate result (otherwise songs like BTW and Judas would have had over 1000 plays just from the first months).

[Bronco 9,139]

1. Scheisse

2. Judas 

3. The Edge Of Glory

4.Black Jesus / Amen Fashion

5. Hair

6. Marry The Night  

7. Heavy Metal Lover/Electric Chapel 

8. Born This Way 

9. You and I 

10. Bloody Mary 

11. Government Hooker

12. Bad Kids

13. Fashion Of His Love

14. Highway Unicorn

15. Americano 

16. The Queen

 

[swooning 447]

1. Scheiße

2. Judas

3. Bloody Mary

4. Marry the Night

5. Heavy Metal Lover

6. Electric Chapel

7. Fashion of His Love

8. The Edge of Glory

9. Government Hooker

10. Black Jesus † Amen Fashion

11. Americano

12. Bad Kids

13. Born This Way

14. You and I

15. Highway Unicorn (Road to Love)

16. Hair

17. The Queen