Gaga & Katy Really Are the Ones

[POPANEINONEONE 279]

1 minute ago, TMM90 said:

No it was 2

Spoiler

 

 

 

[nATAH 43,215]

14 minutes ago, tomdsgn said:

I’d argue Gaga really only had 2 mega successful eras, the GP stopped eating at her table some time ago now

ASIB was pretty huge, luv

[tomdsgn 1,913]

17 minutes ago, NATAH said:

ASIB was pretty huge, luv

Yeah cause that definitely counts as a Lady Gaga album 

[Maxine Puth 9,052]

3 minutes ago, tomdsgn said:

Yeah cause that definitely counts as a Lady Gaga album 

LGBC is an album  and you said era not album. ASIB was an era with all the red carpets, promo, and major televised performances. #1 movie, #1 hit with an Oscar and the album won multiple Grammys. ARUTW became a moderate hit and INLA won a Grammy as well.

[Guillaume Hamon 6,027]

To me the 2 stunning performers of this generation are Gaga and Beyoncé.

Katy 's underrated but I would place her a few notches underneath.

Folks like Ari and Doja also are already great and still have a lot of potential as performers imo...

[nATAH 43,215]

18 minutes ago, tomdsgn said:

Yeah cause that definitely counts as a Lady Gaga album 

you said era  ASIB era was a GP smash

[skedaddleBItCh 2,785]

Both of them are great in their own way!  No matter what people would say, Katy is still one of the pop stars who shaped late 2000's and early 2010's pop scenes, along with Gaga and many others, so it's sad that fans in this forum discredit her impact and thrash her later works, and then gets compared to Gaga later on when surely both would be displeased to hear so if ever.

[Meat 18,962]

1 hour ago, tomdsgn said:

the GP stopped eating at her table some time ago now

ASIB was the highest selling female album of 2018 and HOG was the highest earning drama of 2021. How did the GP stop eating at her table? 

[RAMROD 104,866]

1 hour ago, tomdsgn said:

I’d argue Gaga really only had 2 mega successful eras, the GP stopped eating at her table some time ago now

You're stuck in 2013 and haven't left, I fear

[nATAH 43,215]

20 minutes ago, Meat said:

ASIB was the highest selling female album of 2018 and HOG was the highest earning drama of 2021. How did the GP stop eating at her table? 

plus we all know chromatica ball would have had plenty more sold out dates and we got Joker 2 coming out, a sequel to a smash hit movie

she's providing the GP with a buffet and they are EATING

[gypsy101 5,428]

gaga will always be relevant. they’re not comparable.

[Hyperobject 66,768]

16 minutes ago, NATAH said:

plus we all know chromatica ball would have had plenty more sold out dates and we got Joker 2 coming out, a sequel to a smash hit movie

she's providing the GP with a buffet and they are EATING

right? Gaga is the GP’s darling right now idk. she’s still very relevant, Chromatica streams were great, her acting career is just getting bigger, she’s still in her moment no matter what some people say. :3 

[tomdsgn 1,913]

1 hour ago, Ororo Munroe said:

right? Gaga is the GP’s darling right now idk. she’s still very relevant, Chromatica streams were great, her acting career is just getting bigger, she’s still in her moment no matter what some people say. :3 

Ask GP to name any of her recent (non ASIB) songs and I bet they’d struggle. 

[Hyperobject 66,768]

2 minutes ago, tomdsgn said:

Ask GP to name any of her recent (non ASIB) songs and I bet they’d struggle. 

but why exclude ASIB songs tho? they were huge hits and the movie was very successful. I’m talking about Gaga still being popular and relevant even if her songs aren’t spending 10+ weeks on billboard hot 100. also, I’m sure a lot of people know Rain on Me, it has more than 800mil streams on Spotify alone, and our fanbase isn’t a kpop one (like BTS or Blackpink), where most of the streams are coming from the dedicated fans who stream songs 24/7 nonstop. 

[Reginald 13,835]

 

Katy's first few albums (the ones with the songs written by Bonnie McKee) were excellent. Gaga is on an entirely different level in 2022, though. They can't compare.