HMH is a grower - it might not go number one but i think its a solid song

[jeremiahsaint1000 487]

at first listen i thought it was good, listened to it again and thought it was a flop. but now after a few days i feel like its epic, its not perfect but something about the chorus is transcendent - imagine her singing this live at the Chromatica ball...... like those soaring vocals are going to be insane in a stadium setting

[Blackout19 10,644]

[Noorat 233]

I don't like the idea of the song. I want something "fresh" something "new" I don't want another 'before i cry' or 'brooklyn night'  the production or 'I wanna be with you' (Dope Demo).

[Nathan 2,079]

Another thread on this 

 

[LilyLark 9,934]

21 minutes ago, Noorat said:

I don't like the idea of the song. I want something "fresh" something "new" I don't want another 'before i cry' or 'brooklyn night'  the production or 'I wanna be with you' (Dope Demo).

Sis it's a movie ballad-was always going to be pretty safe.

[warhol killer 8,580]

It's gonna be a classic hit, but not a no. 1. I can hear this at singing competitions like with what happened with I'll Never Love Again. I just didn't really like the hype some said here about it being "her next no. 1!!!" although it might be an exaggeration.

[Bradley 57,763]

I agree. I love it so much more now that I've given it a few listens.

If it gets played on the radio consistently the GP is gonna grow on it pretty quickly too.

[Maria Brink 1,501]

Yes!! Some people out here forgetting this was a song made for a movie 😂😂 Pls I cannot handle all you LMs who b**** and moan about every little thing Gaga does. She doesn’t care about you and your opinion. The song is beautiful, and I know y’all just mad it’s not a heavy dance track.. No matter what she does y’all will never be happy. 

[Maria Brink 1,501]

2 hours ago, Noorat said:

I don't like the idea of the song. I want something "fresh" something "new" I don't want another 'before i cry' or 'brooklyn night'  the production or 'I wanna be with you' (Dope Demo).

My reply above was directed at this btw LOL

[nATAH 43,943]

2 hours ago, Noorat said:

I don't like the idea of the song. I want something "fresh" something "new" I don't want another 'before i cry' or 'brooklyn night'  the production or 'I wanna be with you' (Dope Demo).

you kinda sound like a toddler

[RAMROD 105,528]

Well, majority of active GGD members have agreed on that too

 

 

[Gabi001 2,183]

I wasn't feeling the song before, but today I suddenly can't get it out of my head and I love it! And I didn't even tried to overplay it to let it grow on me, I literary listened to it maybe 5 times since release.

[LUCARTPOP 5,899]

What's with the #1 obession? 

[Suspiria 10,683]

4 hours ago, LilyLark said:

Sis it's a movie ballad-was always going to be pretty safe.

I hate this argument what would be the point in even doing it if it 'was always going to be pretty safe' ie she didn't have much creative freedom.

(As a disclaimer, I don't dislike the song. It could've been a lot more boring and generic)