Lorde: “I haven’t made a Jack Antonoff record.”

[enissa11 2,984]

1 hour ago, Jose P said:

But that’s your opinion, if we go objectively, Jack produced these girls’ most critically acclaimed and significant albums. 

critical acclaim are also opinions just as meaningless 

[edgy 6,918]

the way I was almost right and off by one name, I- 
 

[Sunny21 608]

3 hours ago, gagaisitalian said:

I LOVEEE Folklore... Cardigan is the biggest bop and it's still a ballad (also one of my top 3 Taylor songs). 

 

3 hours ago, deactivated001 said:

I agree that it's gotten old, but IMO NFR, Melodrama, and Folklore + 1989 are each of those artists best albums. 

 

3 hours ago, Jose P said:

But that’s your opinion, if we go objectively, Jack produced these girls’ most critically acclaimed and significant albums. 

Jack Antonoff has NOTHING to do with Cardigan. 🙂

Cardigan was written by Taylor and Aaron DESSNER (The National, Big Red Machine), and produced by Aaron!

folklore - Taylor and Aaron co-wrote 9 songs out of 16 (Cardigan, The 1, The Last Great American Dynasty, Seven, Invisible String, Mad Woman, Epiphany, Peace, and Hoax). He's the sole producer on 9 and co-producer on Exile and Betty with Joe Alwyn. 

Jack co-wrote 4 songs on folklore and co-produced 6 (with Taylor, Aaron and Joe) out of 16.   

folklore is TAYLOR'S album, but if you prefer to give all the credit to a male producer, it's Aaron. (I'm tempted to quote Cardi B... but I won't.) 🙂

[Perfect Celebrity 1,572]

I don’t know what everyone is getting in a fuss about. He’s been taking a lot of work in the last decade, consistently, as anyone should because it’s their income and that obviously matters to everybody. Every artist he works with tends to have a cohesive vision and I totally support Lorde’s comments. Maybe Jack should take a few years hiatus since the public is starting to notice he’s working on “too many projects”, sure but only if it’s convenient for him right now in his life. 

[Neight Shayde 7,925]

I don't think people would be saying these to someone like Mark Ronson who also produces for different female artists, because you really don't hear a signature MR sound for most of the works he's involved in.

There are noticeable similarities with the way the songs are structured with Jack.

[Ziggy 12,236]

14 hours ago, littlepotter said:

PERIOD! I've been saying this since before people stopped stanning him and it's one of the main reasons I don't like him working with everyone. Everyone attributes Melodrama's success to him and it's so insulting to Lorde.

I wouldn’t ever give him credit for melodrama, but a lot of what I’m hearing production wise this time sounds like other recent work of his. I think it’s simply a fact of him not being quite as versatile as people say/working on too many big pop records

[Anderson123 39,445]

10 hours ago, edgy said:

the way I was almost right and off by one name, I- 
 

"Giant hits". This doesn't sound like Lorde. Melodrama is one of my favorite albums of all time but lets be real, none of the songs were hits. I don't think that has anything to do with Jack by the way.

[littlepotter 75,361]

7 minutes ago, Ziggy said:

I wouldn’t ever give him credit for melodrama, but a lot of what I’m hearing production wise this time sounds like other recent work of his. I think it’s simply a fact of him not being quite as versatile as people say/working on too many big pop records

Yes exactly

[gagaisitalian 3,573]

On 8/13/2021 at 10:06 PM, Jose P said:

But that’s your opinion, if we go objectively, Jack produced these girls’ most critically acclaimed and significant albums. 

You're right it is my opinion. Did I say it wasn't?

[INNA 3,756]

I feel like the hint of discredit to his name is  very appropriate considering how often he recycles his creations. It’s so basic

[SEANGT 5,511]

Sigh