Producer who understood GAGA SOUND the most

[FfFfFfFF 55,688]

Hello, it's me again  (but I saw that you edited your post so I need to make a correction..):

3 hours ago, PropaGaga said:

Also I never said it's more "truthful" than her other works (again, words are being put into my mouth) 

You did say that:

4 hours ago, PropaGaga said:

Joanne is Gaga at her most true self musically

[Windowlicker 3,517]

4 hours ago, FfFfFfFF said:

Hello, it's me again  (but I saw that you edited your post so I need to make a correction..):

You did say that:

Yes, because I was quoting you when you said Joanne wasn't her "true form" and I mocked it by putting it in quotations because it was a ridiculous statement. You're the only person who kept bringing up how I supposedly said it was the most "truthful" when I never did. I specifically said "I would say it's just as "true" to her as anything else she's released" so...

Hope that clears things up for you 

[AVeryGagaHolyDick 25,183]

On 5/11/2021 at 7:18 PM, Miss Dolly said:

She literally did. She is the main producer 

No lmaoooo

She's the producer = she paid for the song

It's literally written in the credits that the instrumental was made by Madeon and not Gaga

[Better Day 5,766]

Just now, KEVIN STEVE said:

No lmaoooo

She's the producer = she paid for the song

It's literally written in the credits that the instrumental was made by Madeon and not Gaga

Madeon was the co-producer. He created the bass and Gaga created everything is. She is classed as the “main producer” 

[Ronlop 6,882]

DJWS imo

[AVeryGagaHolyDick 25,183]

Just now, Miss Dolly said:

Madeon was the co-producer. He created the bass and Gaga created everything is. She is classed as the “main producer” 

As I told you, a producer is someone who pays for a song. Gaga paid for it, she is the producer. 

She is not the one who made the instrumental. Madeon is the one who did that (Gaga only worked  on the bassline, as credited.) 

[Better Day 5,766]

Just now, KEVIN STEVE said:

As I told you, a producer is someone who pays for a song. Gaga paid for it, she is the producer. 

She is not the one who made the instrumental. Madeon is the one who did that (Gaga only worked  on the bassline, as credited.) 

Madeon created the bass  they are listenable evidence and Gaga created the instrumental  It’s all written on the booklet 

[AVeryGagaHolyDick 25,183]

3 minutes ago, Miss Dolly said:

Madeon created the bass  they are listenable evidence and Gaga created the instrumental  It’s all written on the booklet 

It is LITERALLY written in the booklet that Madeon made the instrumental and that Gaga only did the bass line (which is essentially 3 notes BTW)

[Better Day 5,766]

Just now, KEVIN STEVE said:

This is LITERALLY written in the booklet that Madeon made the instrumental and that Gaga only did the bass line (with is essentially 3 notes BTW)

Why would she be classed as a “main producer” if she literally didn’t produce the song? 

[AVeryGagaHolyDick 25,183]

Just now, Miss Dolly said:

Why would she be classed as a “main producer” if she literally didn’t produce the song? 

Because she did produce the song, since she invested in it. She just didn't arrange it, other than that bassline

 

[Better Day 5,766]

Just now, KEVIN STEVE said:

Because she did produce the song, since she invested in it. She just didn't arrange it, other than that bassline

 

So you admit she created the song  It’s the only song she produced herself and you can tell 

[AVeryGagaHolyDick 25,183]

1 minute ago, Miss Dolly said:

So you admit she created the song  It’s the only song she produced herself and you can tell 

She didn't create it, she bought it, and that's what makes her the producer, not the arranger

The thread is about producers, not arrangers, but your initial comment seemed to praise Gaga for creating an instrumental that she didn't create

[Better Day 5,766]

5 minutes ago, KEVIN STEVE said:

She didn't create it, she bought it, and that's what makes her the producer, not the arranger

The thread is about producers, not arrangers, but your initial comment seemed to praise Gaga for creating an instrumental that she didn't create

If she bought it she would not have been the main producer. She gives everyone a credit when they write/produce a song. She literally produced the song as states the booklet 

[AVeryGagaHolyDick 25,183]

2 minutes ago, Miss Dolly said:

If she bought it she would not have been the main producer. She gives everyone a credit when they write/produce a song. She literally produced the song as states the booklet 

The producer is essentially the person who paid for the song. Some teams credit other people as producers as well, if they influenced the overall direction of the song. 

Gaga is the producer of Venus. That does not mean she did the instrumental herself.

The person who does the instrumental is mainly credited as “arranged by [name]” or “played and programmed by [name]”.

In the case of Venus, Madeon himself did arranged the song, aka made the instrumental, Gaga only worked on the bass

[Better Day 5,766]

1 minute ago, KEVIN STEVE said:

The producer is essentially the person who paid for the song. Some teams credit other people as producers as well, if they influenced the overall direction of the song. 

Gaga is the producer of Venus. That does not mean she did the instrumental herself.

The person who does the instrumental is mainly credited as “arranged by [name]” or “played and programmed by [name]”.

In the case of Venus, Madeon himself did arranged the song, aka made the instrumental, Gaga only worked on the bass

That is not what a producer is 

Producer - “a person who produces.” A producer is someone who creates. 
https://www.dictionary.com/browse/producer