Gaga's voice strain during enigma 2019 due to chromatica recordings?

[KarmaPolice 4,731]

First of all, don't come at me. It's just a simple thought that hit me the other day.

 So in mid 2019, during Enigma's last run, Gaga's voice was getting tired. Monsters debated, some thought nothing was going on, other that she was overworked. Now that we know that she was recording Chromatica while performing at Las Vegas and still promoting Shallow/A Star Is Born.... do you think that she simply oversang during that period which brought to her voice getting tired and strained?

Keep in mind that Chromatica has the most demanding vocals she ever recorded along with the ASIB soundtrack.

 

[Der Meister 3,000]

During that period (end of 2018 beginning of 2019) she was going through a break up with Carino, depressed, drinking, smoking a lot, and performing in the desert.. all of that did damage her voice. But since then she has recovered, I saw her in Miami in February and her voiced seemed to be much better, although it sounds a little deeper than normal now.

[HeardASine 442]

I think that that's definitely possible. Chromatica's songs are very vocally challenging, and she did mention that she was chain smoking constantly throughout the creation process as well. 

[JazzGa 14,621]

Personally I think she was just drinking and smoking and enjoying Vegas, since it's what one does when one is a high roller   I never worry about things like that, it's like judging an athlete for not being in Olympic shape 100% of their life  

[KarmaPolice 4,731]

1 minute ago, the Devil of Pop said:

Personally I think she was just drinking and smoking and enjoying Vegas, since it's what one does when one is a high roller   I never worry about things like that, it's like judging an athlete for not being in Olympic shape 100% of their life  

We were worried because the strain was present in all of the last run of Enigma. Sure it's ok to have some downs with your voice but she couldn't even belt properly! And on the top of that monsters had the audacity to say that she wasn't doing anything except for enigma but the poor woman was working her ass off!

[MelbHawker 6,583]

11 minutes ago, KarmaPolice said:

Chromatica has the most demanding vocals she ever recorded 

[Economy 49,769]

I don't know but her voice was definitely strained at the Oscars

 

Fortunately the GP was too focused on the Gaga-Bradley chemistry to notice and she didn't get negative PR for it

 

 

 

[KarmaPolice 4,731]

Just now, MelbHawker said:

Educate yourself. She basically used her whole range.

 

[Bolkins 4,125]

I think you could be right, there definitely was a dip in vocal quality towards the end of the shows. I saw her back in January 2019 and she was on point, I just rewatched the videos I recorded and the only bad voice I can hear is mine. 

She was incredibly busy last year she could of just been exhausted by the end of it. 

 

[MelbHawker 6,583]

1 minute ago, KarmaPolice said:

She basically used her whole range.

I wouldn't call the vocals in Chromatica 'demanding' though. Just my opinion. 

[DC 25,164]

Just now, Bolkins said:

I just rewatched the videos I recorded and the only bad voice I can hear is mine. 

Omg 

Also you have Enigma footage? Are they DVD edit worthy? 

[Guest]

Just now, MelbHawker said:

I wouldn't call the vocals in Chromatica 'demanding' though. Just my opinion. 

Literally tho. I don't hear miss germanotta popping whistle notes like miss carey..

Just now, ProjectJoanne said:

Omg 

Also you have Enigma footage? Are they DVD edit worthy? 

leave. now. its time for bed  

[DC 25,164]

Just now, monster said:

leave. now. its time for bed  

It's 11 am and I'm working on music 

[Guest]

Just now, ProjectJoanne said:

It's 11 am and I'm working on music 

fine you can stay up for another hour

[Creyk 17,817]

One of the issues is that all that heavy drinking has permanently deepened her once angelic voice.