Triplet single choice: Plastic Doll vs. Sine From Above vs. 1000 Doves

[Biggest Bitch 5,230]

Inspired by @Cherry Blues 

[Cherry Blues 349]

That's very hard because "Sine From Above" is very beautiful and emotional but "Plastic Doll" so catchy and FameGa 😵 

[Dominic 11,922]

1000 Doves is a personal fave but i would die to see a video for SFA just for the drop and outro so I'd have to pick that. 

[AVeryGagaHolyDick 25,665]

2 minutes ago, Cherry Blues said:

That's very hard because "Sine From Above" is very beautiful and emotional but "Plastic Doll" so catchy and FameGa 😵 

I personally don't hear any similarity between The Fame music and Plastic Doll. If anything, it's closer to PRISM's deep cuts (Love Me etc.) 

[Cherry Blues 349]

Just now, KEVIN STEVE said:

I personally don't hear any similarity between The Fame music and Plastic Doll. If anything, it's closer to PRISM's deep cuts (Love Me etc.) 

For me Plastic Doll has a picturesque and also little dramatic vibe like Paparazzi and its just so warm like the songs from The Fame - like for example Boys Boys Boys. But its also more electronic than the two examples - not electronic like Lovegame for example, but still.

Plastic Doll is not trendy in a 2020 way, but AvantGardeGa POP for me, really.

Artful but warm 

👄🧊👄🧊👄🧊👄🧊👄🧊👄🧊👄🧊👄

[MelbHawker 6,583]

I voted 'Sine From Above' just because I think the video would KILL me. 1000 Doves would perform the best chart-wise though. 

[high heeled fem 3]

18 minutes ago, Dominic said:

1000 Doves is a personal fave but i would die to see a video for SFA just for the drop and outro so I'd have to pick that. 

This is so true, I absolutely love 1000 doves, I also love Sine 

so this is a hard choice I can’t choose 

[Dramatica 13,690]

None 

#JusticeForAlice

[TasteLikeWhiskey 1,561]

I actually think all three of these will make for good singles. I voted 1000 doves as it is my favorite, but my non-gaga fan friends all love Plastic Doll. I don't get the hate for it. Even the non-gaga fans get that the 'cringy' lyrics are intentional and quite effective. That chorus is addictive af. 

[steven 5,963]

1000 Doves.

SFA would not do well on the radio, too noisy,  and not strong enough. And let’s not talk about Plastic Doll 

[Roboboy 3,771]

5 minutes ago, Steven said:

1000 Doves.

SFA would not do well on the radio, too noisy,  and not strong enough. And let’s not talk about Plastic Doll 

Plastic Doll is an incredible pop song. i'm literally so confused why everyone hates it its one of the best songs on here

[wook 943]

Sine From Above for Europe maybe... But Plastic Doll or 1000 Doves for singles chile  Especially when Sour Candy and Alice exist 

[steven 5,963]

11 minutes ago, LG6IsHere said:

Plastic Doll is an incredible pop song. i'm literally so confused why everyone hates it its one of the best songs on here

I don’t hate Plastic Doll, it’s grown on me and the chorus is one of the strongest on the album but I don’t see it becoming a single. 

[Cherry Blues 349]

 

2 hours ago, wook said:

Sine From Above for Europe maybe... But Plastic Doll or 1000 Doves for singles chile  Especially when Sour Candy and Alice exist 

Alice is a masterpiece and i love all songs from Chromatica, just Sour Candy is little wannabe - but its ok.

Singles should be:

Alice

Replay

Plastic Doll

Sines From Above

Fun Tonight 

911

They all are real good pop songs and some of them are even timeless. Alice is a smash.

Replay, Plastic Doll and Sine From Above are timeless.

911 is pure futuristic and needs to be a Chromatica single.

[wook 943]

58 minutes ago, Cherry Blues said:

 

Alice is a masterpiece and i love all songs from Chromatica, just Sour Candy is little wannabe - but its ok.

Singles should be:

Alice

Replay

Plastic Doll

Sines From Above

Fun Tonight 

911

They all are real good pop songs and some of them are even timeless. Alice is a smash.

Replay, Plastic Doll and Sine From Above are timeless.

911 is pure futuristic and needs to be a Chromatica single.

I get that you love the song but you need to seperate this from which songs are really good choice for singles 🙂 911 is not it simply because GP will not understand what is this about and it is not radio friendly. Sine From Above is too loud for radio. 
Sour Candy is a GP smash. Im not gonna lie because I love Replay and I would love this one to be a single but we can wish 😭