Jump to content
news

TheNeedleDrop Reviews Rain On Me


ApplauseftAdele

Featured Posts

  • Replies 99
  • Created
  • Last Reply
andreas85

Fantano's review was spot-on. He is definitely not a hater, little monsters in this thread are haters and obviously can't stand any criticism. He also wasn't being unfair at all, he actually praised the music video and house beats. Fantano also said that ROM is just an ok pop song and that he was expecting more from Gaga so you can clearly see that he recognizes Gaga's talent. ROM isn't obviously kind of a song that people are going to remember after 10 years because it's just not very original in any way.

Link to post
Share on other sites

DiskoBaby
13 hours ago, JR Gg said:

Not surprised. He has NO taste in music :billie:

Wonder who still watches his channel :billie:

He probably has a more diverse taste than you do. How many albums do you actually listen to that he reviews? He gives attention to some of the most obscure albums and genres out there.

I'm not defending him but you gotta be a bit pressed to say he has NO taste in music when his life revolves around listening to all types of music. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

ApplauseftAdele
13 hours ago, Adarsh said:

“News” lol nobody cares for his opinion. Someone remove that tag.

Then why are there 6 pages of replies :laughga:

Link to post
Share on other sites

GC1234

Seriously what is wrong with making music that is pleasing to the ears without it having to be so deeply complex. It seems to be viewed as a bad trait for a song to be an earworm nowadays, but imo it’s the catchiness that gives a song memorability especially in years to come. Plus when you hear Gaga explain the meaning behind ROM, it gives the whole song a far more layered context, or maybe that’s just me lol :tony:

Get that fire exit door, I’m off...
Link to post
Share on other sites

Lextyr97

I literally cannot stand this dude. Even when he praised Million Reasons, it made my blood boil

Link to post
Share on other sites

DiskoBaby

Tbh I wasn't really impressed with ROM either.

It's cute.

It's a fun pop song, and it's obviously made for the charts.

It's so commercial friendly.

But that's not a bad thing.

I just don't see it as one of her best.

It's not something I'll be listening to years from now thinking it's one of her best songs or one of the best pop songs.

It's just a cute song to listen to for now. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Nosferatu
11 hours ago, Alright said:

ROM literally sounds like that music that would come out of the old plastic toy phones when you’d press 1, calm your tits. So generic, quantized and boring. Such corporate manufactured garbage. No way ppl listen to that sh*t without watching the music video. They're like obligated to make big ass budget videos cause the music is so fkn trash, they gotta distract ppl from the bland music. Using bright changing colours, gimmicks and choreos to distract the viewers from that boring french house rip-off. It's like they wanted to make a french house song but they took away everything that makes the house music interesting. So bland and flavorless. 

Didn't you post literally the exact same thing on the Ajay thread Ms. AjayIIfan? :billie: You seem to be very proud of yourself for coming up with that "old plastic toy phones" thing :billie: Are you also a TheNeedleDrop fan? :billie:

"Boring, manufactured, basic, generic" are bold words coming from someone who seemingly stans youtubers of all things :billie:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Regina George
14 hours ago, ApplauseftAdele said:

Did he lie?

Yes he did. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

ApplauseftAdele
15 minutes ago, Regina George said:

Yes he did. 

Where? Gaga and Ariana have both explored the pop genre better in the past. Gaga with Bad Romance, Ariana with NTLTC. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

not Chromatica

Girl, please. His main argument for it not being that good is that it didn't serve him the "the fireworks" that he expected from a Gaga & Ari collab.  Any GGD rando (that's not a 'music critic') could have said the same thing, and some of them did. It's literally based off of unwarranted expectations, which is something that's been plaguing Gaga's career since TFM. Even then people were shitting on Bad Romance because it was too 'weird' and 'not Poker Face-y enough'. The song as it is is a smash and he could have still put it the 'meh' category, but if he would at least give us a proper reason. This 'expectations' thing ain't it.

Link to post
Share on other sites

DiskoBaby
11 minutes ago, Chromatica said:

Girl, please. His main argument for it not being that good is that it didn't serve him the "the fireworks" that he expected from a Gaga & Ari collab.  Any GGD rando (that's not a 'music critic') could have said the same thing, and some of them did. It's literally based off of unwarranted expectations, which is something that's been plaguing Gaga's career since TFM. Even then people were shitting on Bad Romance because it was too 'weird' and 'not Poker Face-y enough'. The song as it is is a smash and he could have still put it the 'meh' category, but if he would at least give us a proper reason. This 'expectations' thing ain't it.

But why shouldn't we have higher expectations? Why should her creative music peak be an EP released eleven years ago?

Link to post
Share on other sites

not Chromatica
4 minutes ago, DiskoBaby said:

But why shouldn't we have higher expectations? Why should her creative music peak be an EP released eleven years ago?

No one said that.

Link to post
Share on other sites

DiskoBaby
6 minutes ago, Chromatica said:

No one said that.

You literally just said that. 

It's literally based off of unwarranted expectations, which is something that's been plaguing Gaga's career since TFM. 

I'm not going to argue what her fans think because that's all subjective. But what critics and the general audience thinks who aren't big fans of hers still consider The Fame Monster and Bad Romance as her best work. Every album she released since then has been a hit or miss. Good but not great or outstanding. It's not bad but we expect more from her.

That's the main concensus of her music since 2011. We should expect someone as talented as her to want to top herself and be innovative. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...