Jump to content

'Chromatica' Discussion - ACT I


FATCAT

Featured Posts

Regina George
2 minutes ago, zcasx said:

If someone told you in 2013 that Katy would be serving better music videos than post-ARTPOP gaga even in her flop eras how bad would your meltdown be? from 1-10?

Shh they’ll come for you because of this truthful statement 

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Replies 54.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply
1 minute ago, NFRockwell said:

I think we all just gotta realize Gaga isn’t hip anymore :poot: her music doesn’t just go top 10 because she’s “Lady Gaga” like during her first three albums. The only actual way I see her getting top 5 hits now is

A. She gets enough hype from fans and music nerds (like Stupid Love) 

B. She actually goes out of her way to promote the song on a huge scale (Million Reasons, Shallow)

C. She collaborated with someone hip enough to get the younger public to stream (Rain On Me maybe) 

Shell always sell albums because she has a loyal fanbase, but even if she provides a “commercially” perfect single she’s not going to get a giant hit out of it without any of these things. I can tell you right now any song from Joanne that would’ve been the lead with the level of promotion PI got would’ve charted probably the same way. :selena: 

People said the same thing about Madonna and then Ray of Light happened. Lady Gaga is still a force.

they call me angela vidal
Link to post
Share on other sites

Chromaticunt
13 minutes ago, Bae said:

There are two 'ballads', I air quote ballads because they're more along the lines of Gypsy. There's not really any downer moments on the album.

My favorite song was '911' that was mentioned in the Paper Interview, the verses are super frantic and fast-paced with Bowie like vocals with a lot of Stache like synths, but then she talks about popping her pills in the pre-chorus and the chorus hits. it's really upbeat, classic Gaga chorus, but somehow way calmer than the verses, the synths change entirely (almost sounds like a different song), kinda gave me Electric Chapel chorus vibes. I think it was my favorite song and will def be a fan favorite.

  Hide contents

:billie: obviously trolling, but I need a song like that tbh 

 

Stank ass ho thieving my time with this bullsh*t NONSENSERY. 

wrestling beat up GIF

Link to post
Share on other sites

NFRatwell
4 minutes ago, zcasx said:

If someone told you in 2013 that Katy would be serving better music videos than post-ARTPOP gaga even in her flop eras how bad would your meltdown be? from 1-10?

Like a 2 because I stan Gaga for her music :ladyhaha:

Link to post
Share on other sites

NFRatwell
3 minutes ago, Kubi said:

People said the same thing about Madonna and then Ray of Light happened. Lady Gaga is still a force.

This isn’t three decades ago though :poot: Madonna didn’t have to win over the younger population’s streaming power 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Shaney
4 minutes ago, Chromaticunt said:

Stank ass ho thieving my time with this bullsh*t NONSENSERY. 

wrestling beat up GIF

Vile.

tenor.gif

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Stephen
8 minutes ago, zcasx said:

If someone told you in 2013 that Katy would be serving better music videos than post-ARTPOP gaga even in her flop eras how bad would your meltdown be? from 1-10?

My reaction at first

tenor.gif

My reaction after they tell me that Katy becomes a permaflop while Gaga has a #1 hit, universal acclaim, movie of the year, and wins an oscar

tenor.gif?itemid=15873053

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Babylon98
8 minutes ago, NFRockwell said:

I think we all just gotta realize Gaga isn’t hip anymore :poot: her music doesn’t just go top 10 because she’s “Lady Gaga” like during her first three albums. The only actual way I see her getting top 5 hits now is

A. She gets enough hype from fans and music nerds (like Stupid Love) 

B. She actually goes out of her way to promote the song on a huge scale (Million Reasons, Shallow)

C. She collaborated with someone hip enough to get the younger public to stream (Rain On Me maybe) 

Shell always sell albums because she has a loyal fanbase, but even if she provides a “commercially” perfect single she’s not going to get a giant hit out of it without any of these things. I can tell you right now any song from Joanne that would’ve been the lead with the level of promotion PI got would’ve charted probably the same way. :selena: 

I mean I understand where you're coming from, she can't get a hit from her name alone at this point in her career, however you had 4.4 million people tune in to listen to stupid love on her first day, if the song was a viable commercial choice and had an interesting factor that made it stand out I guarantee you we wouldn't see such a steep decline, just like we didn't see with shallow even though it hadn't premiered in the movies yet. Why? because lyric-wise, production wise it was interesting, wasn't overwhelming and had a lot of replay value, it turned out to be one of her biggest hits (for several other reasons of course) but I believe the first declines are telling of how the song is connecting 

Link to post
Share on other sites

eeaarrllaalloo
1 minute ago, Bae said:

Vile

giphy.gif

this gif tho

"By FaR ThE MoSt IrRiTatInG PoSteR oN "ChRoMaTiCa" DisCusSion.
Link to post
Share on other sites

  • FATCAT changed the title to 'Chromatica' Discussion - ACT I
  • Zilla locked this topic
  • FATCAT unpinned this topic

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...